Executive Hometown Identity and Green Innovation in Enterprises of Heavy Polluting Industries—A Dual Perspective Based on Conscious Motivation and Resource Access

Yujia Liu, Ligang Liu, Ying LiSustainability 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that executives' hometown identity significantly boosts green innovation in China's heavy polluting industries, particularly in private firms. This effect stems from increased environmental awareness and better access to government subsidies, with social capital and organizational resources acting as crucial moderators.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Heavy polluting industries face immense pressure to adopt green innovation to transition away from unsustainable development models and meet China's ambitious environmental goals. However, these industries often struggle with high costs, risks, and a weak technological foundation, hindering their ability to innovate sustainably. While executive characteristics are known to influence corporate decisions, existing research has primarily focused on cognitive aspects like education or background, overlooking how an executive's sense of belonging to a region (hometown identity) might impact green innovation. This paper addresses this gap by exploring how an executive's hometown identity influences green innovation through both their internal motivations (environmental awareness) and their ability to access external resources (government subsidies), considering the unique socio-cultural context of China.

Methods

The researchers employed a quantitative approach using panel data from Chinese A-share listed companies in heavy polluting industries between 2013 and 2020. They utilized a fixed-effects model, validated by a Hausman test, to analyze the relationships. The study investigated the direct effect of executive hometown identity on green innovation, explored the mediating roles of environmental awareness and government subsidies, and examined the moderating effects of executive social capital (corporate-associated and government-associated capital) and organizational redundancy resources (non-sinking and sinking). Regression analysis and robustness tests, including lag period treatment, variable substitution, environmental regulation control, instrumental variables, and propensity score matching, were used to ensure the reliability of the findings.

Datasets

The study used data from listed companies in the heavy polluting industry on the Shanghai and Shenzhen A-share markets from 2013 to 2020. Data sources included:

  • Annual reports of companies (for R&D investment, administrative expenses, other cash flows, and executive information).
  • CSR reports, corporate environmental reports, and sustainability reports (for energy consumption data).
  • Media tools such as China Securities Journal, Flush Finance, Sina.com, Sina Finance, and China Research Data Service Platform.
  • CSMAR database for other relevant data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Hometown pride fuels green action: Executives who identify with their hometown are more likely to prioritize local environmental well-being, translating this into a stronger drive for green innovation within their companies.
  • Local networks unlock resources: Hometown identity fosters informal ties that help executives navigate local policies and secure crucial government subsidies, providing the financial and resource backing needed for green initiatives.
  • Private firms benefit most: The positive impact of hometown identity on green innovation is significantly more pronounced in private enterprises, suggesting they are more agile in leveraging these personal connections for strategic advantage.
  • Social capital's double-edged sword: While corporate-associated capital can dilute the positive effects of hometown identity by focusing executives on short-term gains, government-associated capital, especially in private firms, amplifies the benefits by facilitating access to government support.
  • Redundancy breeds boldness: Ample organizational resources (both easily deployable and already invested) empower executives to pursue high-risk green innovation with greater confidence, reinforcing the positive influence of their hometown identity.

Key Results

  • Direct Effect: Executive hometown identity significantly promotes corporate green innovation (H1 supported).
  • Mediating Effects:
    • Executive hometown identity positively influences environmental awareness, which in turn promotes green innovation (partial mediation).
  • Executive hometown identity positively influences access to government subsidies, which in turn promotes green innovation, but this effect is significant only for private enterprises (partial mediation for private firms).
  • Moderating Effects:
    • Executive corporate-associated capital weakens the positive effect of hometown identity on green innovation (H2a supported).
  • Executive government-associated capital strengthens the positive effect of hometown identity on green innovation, but only in private enterprises (H2b partially supported, significant for private firms).
  • Both non-sinking and sinking redundant resources positively moderate the relationship between executive hometown identity and corporate green innovation (H3a and H3b supported).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Measurement of Green Innovation: The study uses the ratio of R&D investment to energy consumption. Future research could explore alternative metrics or expand to industries with better energy consumption data disclosure.
  • Hometown Identity Measurement: The current measure (same province) is a simplification. Future work could use more nuanced measures of individual heterogeneity in hometown identity.
  • Regional Differences: The intensity of hometown culture varies by region. Future studies could investigate how this regional variation impacts the effectiveness of hometown identity on green innovation.

The paper suggests that future research could also expand the sample size or industry scope, refine the measurement of hometown identity, and explore regional variations in its impact.

Summary updated

Abstract

Green innovation is an important step for enterprises in heavy polluting industries to break through the original crude development model and make the leap to sustainable operation. As important decision makers, executives’ home country identification affects their environmental awareness motivation and resource access advantage. Based on the dual perspective of conscious motivation and resource access, this paper aims to investigate the influence mechanism and boundary conditions of executives’ hometown identity on green innovation of enterprises in heavy polluting industries. Using a sample of listed companies in the heavy polluting industry in Shanghai and Shenzhen A-shares from 2013 to 2020, a theoretical exploration and an empirical analysis of this relationship is conducted based on the fusion of the framework of geographic dependency theory and social identity theory. This study finds that executive hometown identity promotes corporate green innovation and is more significant in private enterprises. The results of the mechanism test show that hometown identity mainly contributes to the implementation of green innovation in terms of both executive awareness motivation (environmental awareness) and corporate resource acquisition (government subsidies), but the latter is only significant in private enterprises. Further analysis reveals that the relationship between hometown identity and green innovation is weakened by executive corporate-associated capital, while government-associated capital shows an enhanced effect on the relationship, but only in the private enterprises; redundant resources play a positive moderating role in the relationship between executive hometown identity and corporate green innovation. The findings of this study provide a theoretical basis and managerial insights into the green innovation practices of firms in heavy polluting industries under the informal system.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2023executive,
  author = {Yujia Liu and Ligang Liu and Ying Li},
  title = {{Executive Hometown Identity and Green Innovation in Enterprises of Heavy Polluting Industries—A Dual Perspective Based on Conscious Motivation and Resource Access}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/su15086398},
}
Figure