Executive Function and Postural Instability in People with Parkinson’s Disease

Dong Xu, Michael H. Cole, Kerrie Mengersen, Peter A. Silburn, Feng Qiu, Cara L. Graepel, Graham KerrParkinson 2014 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that specific aspects of executive function, particularly those involving attention and the ability to inhibit responses or ignore distractions, are significantly impaired in individuals with Parkinson's Disease (PD) and are directly linked to their poorer balance and gait. These findings highlight the critical role of executive function in maintaining mobility and suggest potential targets for interventions to improve quality of life for people with PD.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Parkinson's Disease (PD) is well-known for causing motor symptoms like tremors and rigidity, but it also significantly impacts cognitive function. While it's understood that both gait/balance issues and cognitive impairments are common in PD, the precise relationship between specific cognitive abilities and the severity of postural instability and gait disturbances has remained unclear. This lack of clarity hinders the development of targeted interventions. This paper aims to bridge this gap by investigating how different cognitive domains, especially executive functions, relate to balance and gait performance in people with PD, compared to healthy controls.

Methods

The researchers recruited 20 participants with PD and 20 age- and gender-matched healthy controls. They employed a multi-faceted approach to assess both cognitive function and motor performance:

  • General Cognition: Assessed using the Mini Mental State Exam (MMSE) and the Addenbrooke's Cognitive Examination (ACE).
  • Executive Function: Evaluated using the Trail Making Tests (TMT-A and TMT-B), which measure processing speed, attention, and cognitive flexibility, and a computerized cognitive battery. This battery included various Reaction Time (RT) tests, such as Simple RT (SRT), Choice RT (CRT) for location and color, and a more complex CRT with distracters (CRT-D) and stop signals (CRT-DS). These tests specifically probed response inhibition and the ability to handle distractions.
  • Clinical Mobility: Assessed using established clinical measures: the Tinetti Performance Oriented Mobility Assessment (balance and gait scores), the Timed Up & Go (TUG) test, the Berg Balance Scale (BBS), and the Functional Reach (FR) test.

Statistical analysis involved independent t-tests and Mann-Whitney U tests to compare groups, and Spearman's correlation to examine relationships between cognitive and motor measures.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized standardized clinical assessments and a custom computerized cognitive battery.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Executive Function, Not Just General Cognition, Matters: The study strongly suggests that it's not just overall cognitive decline, but specific executive functions that are most closely tied to balance and gait problems in PD. General cognitive scores (MMSE, ACE) showed no association with balance and gait in either group.
  • Inhibition and Distraction are Key: The ability to inhibit responses and ignore distractions emerged as particularly crucial. Impaired performance on tasks requiring response inhibition (like the CRT-L and CRT-C) and handling distracters (CRT-D) was directly linked to worse balance and gait.
  • TMT-B Errors as a Sensitive Indicator: While TMT-A (processing speed) and TMT-B (set-shifting) times were longer in PD patients, the number of errors on the TMT-B was a more sensitive indicator of executive dysfunction and was significantly associated with poorer balance and gait. This suggests that simply slowing down isn't the whole story; making mistakes due to cognitive overload is a critical factor.
  • PIGD and Rigidity Link to Executive Function: The severity of postural instability and gait disturbance (PIGD) and rigidity, core motor symptoms in PD, were significantly correlated with executive function deficits, particularly with TMT B-A scores. This highlights a complex interplay between motor and cognitive symptoms.

Key Results

  • PD Group Underperforms: Participants with PD performed significantly worse than controls across all cognitive, executive function, balance, and gait assessments.
  • Specific Cognitive Deficits: PD participants took longer on TMT-A, TMT-B, and TMT B-A. They also made significantly more errors on the TMT-B (65% of PD participants vs. 15% of controls). Response inhibition tasks (CRT-L, CRT-C) also showed longer reaction times in the PD group.
  • Correlations with Balance/Gait:
    • Longer TMT-B times and more TMT-B errors were associated with poorer balance (TBS, TGS, BBS).
  • Slower reaction times on CRT tests involving distracters (CRT-DT, CRT-DS) were strongly correlated with poorer performance on balance (TGS, TTS, BBS) and gait (TUG) measures.
  • Increased PIGD scores were correlated with TMT B-A scores, indicating a link between gait instability and executive function.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations: * Small Sample Size: The study acknowledges that the relatively small sample size (n=20 per group) might have limited its capacity to detect all potential relationships between cognitive function and balance/gait. * Subjectivity in Clinical Scales: While validated, clinical balance and gait assessments can involve some subjective factors.

Future Work: * Intervention Development: The findings strongly suggest that interventions targeting executive functions, particularly attention and response inhibition, could be beneficial for improving balance and gait in people with PD. * Understanding Subtypes: Further research could explore how different PD subtypes (e.g., tremor-dominant vs. akinetic-rigid) are differentially affected by cognitive impairments and how these relate to mobility. * Predictive Value: The study hints that TMT-B errors might be a valuable clinical tool for identifying individuals at higher risk of falls due to executive dysfunction.

Summary updated

Abstract

The specific aspects of cognition contributing to balance and gait have not been clarified in people with Parkinson's disease (PD). Twenty PD participants and twenty age- and gender-matched healthy controls were assessed on cognition and clinical mobility tests. General cognition was assessed with the Mini Mental State Exam and Addenbrooke's Cognitive Exam. Executive function was evaluated using the Trail Making Tests (TMT-A and TMT-B) and a computerized cognitive battery which included a series of choice reaction time (CRT) tests. Clinical gait and balance measures included the Tinetti, Timed Up & Go, Berg Balance, and Functional Reach tests. PD participants performed significantly worse than the controls on the tests of cognitive and executive function, balance, and gait. PD participants took longer on Trail Making Tests, CRT-Location, and CRT-Colour (inhibition response). Furthermore, executive function, particularly longer times on CRT-Distracter and greater errors on the TMT-B, was associated with worse balance and gait performance in the PD group. Measures of general cognition were not associated with balance and gait measures in either group. For PD participants, attention and executive function were impaired. Components of executive function, particularly those involving inhibition response and distracters, were associated with poorer balance and gait performance in PD.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xu2014executive,
  author = {Dong Xu and Michael H. Cole and Kerrie Mengersen and Peter A. Silburn and Feng Qiu and Cara L. Graepel and Graham Kerr},
  title = {{Executive Function and Postural Instability in People with Parkinson’s Disease}},
  booktitle = {Parkinson},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1155/2014/684758},
}
Figure