Exclusive measurements of quasi-free eta-photoproduction from deuterium

Jeffrey M. Weiss, P. Achenbach, R. Beck, V. Hejny, V. Kleber, M. Kotulla, B. Krusche, V. Kuhr, R. Leukel, V. Metag, Vincent Léon, R.o. Owens, F. Rambo, A. Schmidt, U. Siodlaczek, H. Stroeher, F. Wissman, M. WolfarXiv 2002 · DOI · arXiv

Title: Exclusive Measurements of Quasi-Free $\eta$-Photoproduction from Deuterium

Abstract

Quasi-free photoproduction of $\eta$-mesons from the deuteron has been measured at the tagged photon facility of the Mainz microtron MAMI using the TAPS photon spectrometer. Incident photon energies ranged from the production threshold at 630 MeV up to 820 MeV. Through a fully exclusive measurement, $\eta$-mesons and recoil nucleons were detected in coincidence. Above the free nucleon production threshold, where final state interaction effects are minimal, a nearly constant ratio of $\sigma_n/\sigma_p = 0.66 \pm 0.10$ was observed. At lower energies, the ratio increases due to re-scattering effects. The results provide critical constraints on the nature of the $S_{11}(1535)$ resonance, specifically disfavoring models that characterize it as a $K\Sigma$ bound state.

Introduction

The $S_{11}(1535)$ nucleon resonance is a unique state in nuclear physics, characterized by its exceptionally strong coupling to the $\eta$-meson. Understanding its internal structure—whether it is a standard three-quark state or a more exotic configuration like a $K\Sigma$ quasi-bound state—requires precise measurements of its production from both protons and neutrons. Since free neutron targets are unavailable, researchers utilize deuterium. However, extracting "quasi-free" information from a bound system like the deuteron is challenging due to nuclear effects like Fermi motion and final state interactions (FSI).

Experimental Methodology

The experiment was conducted at the Mainz Microtron (MAMI) facility using a tagged photon beam and a liquid deuterium target. The TAPS spectrometer, consisting of 504 $BaF_2$ crystals, detected the $\eta \to \gamma\gamma$ decay.

A significant advancement in this study is the exclusive measurement technique. By detecting the recoil nucleon (proton or neutron) in coincidence with the $\eta$-meson, the researchers could kinematically reconstruct the reaction. This approach allows for the "undoing" of Fermi motion effects, effectively isolating the interaction on a single nucleon.

Total cross section $\sigma_{tot}$ for $\eta$-photoproduction on deuterium as a function of incident photon energy $E_\gamma$. The dashed lines indicate the thresholds for coherent production and production on the free nucleon.

Results and Discussion

The primary result of this study is the determination of the neutron-to-proton cross-section ratio, $\sigma_n/\sigma_p$.

The Isospin Ratio

Above the threshold where re-scattering effects are negligible, the ratio was found to be approximately 0.66 ± 0.10. This value is consistent with the 0.67 ± 0.07 extracted from inclusive data using participant-spectator models. The stability of this ratio across the energy range of the $S_{11}$ resonance is a key finding.

The ratio $\sigma_n/\sigma_p$ as a function of photon energy $E_\gamma$. The horizontal solid and dashed lines represent the average value and its uncertainty. The curves represent various theoretical model predictions.

Testing Resonance Models

The energy dependence of the $\sigma_n/\sigma_p$ ratio provides a sensitive test for the structure of the $S_{11}(1535)$. Certain "coupled-channel" models, which interpret the $S_{11}$ as a $K\Sigma$ bound state, predict a significant rise in the ratio with increasing energy. The experimental data, showing a relatively flat distribution, disfavors these specific predictions and suggests that the $S_{11}$ behaves more like a conventional three-quark state.

Final State Interactions (FSI)

At energies near the production threshold (below ~710 MeV), the ratio observed in Figure 5 rises toward unity. This behavior is attributed to re-scattering effects, where the produced $\eta$-meson or nucleon interacts with the spectator nucleon before escaping the nucleus. The exclusive measurement allows for a clearer separation of these nuclear effects from the underlying elementary production process.

Conclusion

This first fully exclusive measurement of $\eta$-photoproduction from deuterium provides a robust determination of the $\sigma_n/\sigma_p$ ratio. The results support the dominance of the isovector component in the $S_{11}(1535)$ excitation and challenge exotic bound-state interpretations of the resonance. Future studies at higher energies will be essential to further explore the interplay of higher-lying resonances and refine our understanding of nucleon structure.

Summary updated

Abstract

Quasi-free photoproduction of eta-mesons from the deuteron has been measured at the tagged photon facility of the Mainz microtron MAMI with the photon spectrometer TAPS for incident photon energies from the production threshold at 630 MeV up to 820 MeV. In a fully exclusive measurement eta-mesons and recoil nucleons were detected in coincidence. At incident photon energies above the production threshold on the free nucleon, where final state interaction effects are negligible, an almost constant ratio of sigma(n)/sigma(p)=0.66+/-0.10 was found. At lower incident photon energies the ratio rises due to re-scattering effects. The average ratio agrees with the value extracted from a comparison of the inclusive d(gamma,eta)X cross section to the free proton cross section via a participant - spectator model for the deuteron cross section (sigma(n)/sigma(p)=0.67+/-0.07). The angular dependence of the ratio agrees with the expected small deviation of neutron and proton cross section from isotropy due to the influence of the D13(1520) resonance. The energy dependence of the ratio in the excitation energy range of the S11(1535) resonance disfavors model predictions which try to explain this resonance as K-Sigma bound state.
BibTeX
@misc{weiss2002exclusive,
  author = {Jeffrey M. Weiss and P. Achenbach and R. Beck and V. Hejny and V. Kleber and M. Kotulla and B. Krusche and V. Kuhr and R. Leukel and V. Metag and Vincent Léon and R.O. Owens and F. Rambo and A. Schmidt and U. Siodlaczek and H. Stroeher and F. Wissman and M. Wolf},
  title = {{Exclusive measurements of quasi-free eta-photoproduction from deuterium}},
  year = {2002},
  eprint = {nucl-ex/0210003},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/nucl-ex/0210003},
}
Figure