Excitation and Abundance of C3 in star forming cores:Herschel/HIFI observations of the sight-lines to W31C and W49N

B. Mookerjea, Thomas F. Giesen, J. Stützki, J. Cernicharo, J. R. Goicoechea, M. De Luca, T. A. Bell, H. M. Sen Gupta, Maryvonne Gérin, C. M. Persson, Paule Sonnentrucker, Z. Makai, J. H. Black, F. Boulanger, A. Coutens, E. Dartois, P. Encrenaz, É. Falgarone, T. R. Geballe, B. Godard, P. F. Goldsmith, C. Gry, P. Hennebelle, Eric Herbst, P. Hily-Blant, C. Joblin, Marzena Kaźmierczak, Robert Kołos, J. Krełowski, D. C. Lis, J. Martín‐Pintado, K. M. Menten, Raquel Rodriguez Monje, J. C. Pearson, M. Pérault, T. G. Phillips, R. Plume, M. Salez, Stephan Śchlemmer, M. Schmidt, D. Teyssier, C. Vastel, Shanshan Yu, P. Dieleman, R. Güsten, C. E. Honingh, P. Morris, Pieter R. Roelfsema, R. Schieder, A. G. G. M. TielensKölner 2010 · DOI

TL;DR

Astronomers have detected the triatomic carbon molecule (C3) in absorption towards star-forming regions W31C and W49N using the Herschel Space Observatory. This detection provides crucial insights into the molecule's abundance and excitation conditions in the warm envelopes of these nascent stellar systems, suggesting C3 is a significant tracer of these environments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the chemical composition and physical conditions of star-forming regions is fundamental to unraveling the processes of star and planet formation. Carbon-bearing molecules, in particular, play a vital role in the chemistry of these environments and are precursors to more complex organic molecules. Triatomic carbon (C3) is a simple yet important carbon chain molecule, but its detection and characterization in interstellar space have been challenging due to its weak spectral features and the complex excitation mechanisms involved. Previous studies had tentatively identified C3, but a detailed, spectrally resolved analysis of its ro-vibrational transitions was lacking, especially in the context of star-forming cores. This paper aims to address this gap by providing precise measurements of C3 absorption lines to determine its abundance and excitation temperature in the warm envelopes of star-forming cores.

Methods

The researchers utilized the Heterodyne Instrument for the Far-Infrared (HIFI) aboard the Herschel Space Observatory. HIFI's high spectral resolution and broad frequency coverage allowed for the observation of several ro-vibrational transitions of C3 in the $v_2$ bending mode, specifically at frequencies between 1654 and 1897 GHz. The observations were conducted in absorption against bright submillimeter continuum sources (W31C and W49N).

The data reduction involved standard procedures using the Herschel Interactive Processing Environment (HIPE) and the CLASS software. To analyze the absorption spectra, a multi-component Gaussian fitting approach was employed to simultaneously fit multiple C3 lines. This allowed for the determination of line centers, widths, and integrated intensities.

For excitation analysis, a "two-layer" model was initially used to estimate the rotational temperature ($T_{rot}$) from the derived state-specific column densities. This model assumes a warm absorbing layer in front of a continuum source. Subsequently, a more sophisticated radiative transfer model was applied to W31C, incorporating far-infrared pumping by dust continuum radiation and a temperature gradient within the source. This advanced model accounts for the complex interplay of excitation mechanisms in these environments.

Datasets

The primary dataset consists of spectrally resolved observations of C3 ro-vibrational transitions obtained by the Herschel Space Observatory's HIFI instrument. The observations targeted the sight-lines to two specific star-forming regions: W31C and W49N. No new observational datasets or benchmarks were introduced in this paper; rather, it leverages existing astronomical targets and advanced observational capabilities.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • C3 as a Tracer of Warm Envelopes: The detection of C3 in absorption, with velocity profiles matching the continuum sources, strongly suggests that C3 is predominantly located in the warm, surrounding envelopes of the hot cores in W31C and W49N, rather than in diffuse foreground clouds.
  • Rotation Temperature as a Proxy for Kinetic Temperature: The derived rotational temperatures ($T_{rot}$ of ~50-70 K) are found to be in good agreement with the kinetic temperatures of the absorbing gas and the dust temperatures of the sources. This is significant because radiative transitions within the vibrational ground state of C3 are forbidden, making $T_{rot}$ a reliable indicator of the gas kinetic temperature in these regions.
  • Infrared Pumping Dominates Excitation: The study highlights that far-infrared pumping by dust continuum radiation plays a crucial role in exciting the ro-vibrational transitions of C3, particularly in the $v_2=1-0$ band. This mechanism is more efficient than collisional excitation in these environments.
  • Abundance Consistent with Chemical Models: The derived C3 abundance of approximately $10^{-8}$ with respect to H2 is found to be consistent with predictions from warm-up chemical models of star-forming regions.

Key Results

  • Detection of C3 Absorption: The paper reports the first spectrally resolved detection of four ro-vibrational lines of C3 ($P(4)$, $Q(2)$, $Q(4)$, and $P(10)$) in absorption towards W31C and W49N.
  • Column Densities: The derived column densities for C3 are estimated to be in the range of $7-9 \times 10^{14} \text{ cm}^{-2}$ based on a simple excitation analysis. A more detailed radiative transfer model for W31C suggests a column density of $1.5 \times 10^{15} \text{ cm}^{-2}$.
  • Abundance: The abundance of C3 relative to H2 is found to be approximately $10^{-8}$.
  • Rotational Temperatures: The rotational temperatures derived for the absorbing gas are in the range of 50-70 K.
  • Non-detection in Diffuse Gas: The sensitivity of the observations did not allow for the detection of C3 absorption from diffuse foreground clouds, indicating that C3 is significantly less abundant in these less dense regions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Uncertainties in Collisional Rates: The authors acknowledge that the ro-vibrational collisional rates used in their models are based on "rather crude assumptions," which introduces uncertainty.
  • Model Simplifications: The "two-layer" excitation analysis relies on simplifications that might lead to an underestimate of the true column density. The radiative transfer model, while more sophisticated, still involves assumptions about the geometry and physical conditions of the source.
  • Parameter Range Exploration: The authors suggest that a more elaborate analysis is needed to fully explore the parameter space, particularly concerning the influence of kinetic temperature and geometrical arrangements on the observed absorption depths.
  • Future Work: The paper implies that further observations and more detailed modeling are warranted to refine the understanding of C3 excitation and abundance in various interstellar environments. The authors also note that the $P(10)$ line was yet to be observed in W49N with HIFI, suggesting future observations to complete the dataset for that source.

Summary updated

Abstract

We present spectrally resolved observations of triatomic carbon (C3) in several ro-vibrational transitions between the vibrational ground state and the low-energy nu2 bending mode at frequencies between 1654-1897 GHz along the sight-lines to the submillimeter continuum sources W31C and W49N, using Herschel's HIFI instrument. We detect C3 in absorption arising from the warm envelope surrounding the hot core, as indicated by the velocity peak position and shape of the line profile. The sensitivity does not allow to detect C3 absorption due to diffuse foreground clouds. From the column densities of the rotational levels in the vibrational ground state probed by the absorption we derive a rotation temperature (T_rot) of ~50--70 K, which is a good measure of the kinetic temperature of the absorbing gas, as radiative transitions within the vibrational ground state are forbidden. It is also in good agreement with the dust temperatures for W31C and W49N. Applying the partition function correction based on the derived T_rot, we get column densities N(C3) ~7-9x10^{14} cm^{-2} and abundance x(C3)~10^{-8} with respect to H2. For W31C, using a radiative transfer model including far-infrared pumping by the dust continuum and a temperature gradient within the source along the line of sight we find that a model with x(C3)=10^{-8}, T_kin=30-50 K, N(C3)=1.5 10^{15} cm^{-2} fits the observations reasonably well and provides parameters in very good agreement with the simple excitation analysis.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{mookerjea2010excitation,
  author = {B. Mookerjea and Thomas F. Giesen and J. Stützki and J. Cernicharo and J. R. Goicoechea and M. De Luca and T. A. Bell and H. M. Sen Gupta and Maryvonne Gérin and C. M. Persson and Paule Sonnentrucker and Z. Makai and J. H. Black and F. Boulanger and A. Coutens and E. Dartois and P. Encrenaz and É. Falgarone and T. R. Geballe and B. Godard and P. F. Goldsmith and C. Gry and P. Hennebelle and Eric Herbst and P. Hily-Blant and C. Joblin and Marzena Kaźmierczak and Robert Kołos and J. Krełowski and D. C. Lis and J. Martín‐Pintado and K. M. Menten and Raquel Rodriguez Monje and J. C. Pearson and M. Pérault and T. G. Phillips and R. Plume and M. Salez and Stephan Śchlemmer and M. Schmidt and D. Teyssier and C. Vastel and Shanshan Yu and P. Dieleman and R. Güsten and C. E. Honingh and P. Morris and Pieter R. Roelfsema and R. Schieder and A. G. G. M. Tielens},
  title = {{Excitation and Abundance of C3 in star forming cores:Herschel/HIFI observations of the sight-lines to W31C and W49N}},
  booktitle = {Kölner},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.48550/arxiv.1007.0649},
}
Figure