Examining the Structure of Sense of Burden among Public Elementary and Junior High School Teachers (2)

Kota Tamai, Hidenori Fujita, Maki Yamada, Setsuko Waida, Yuta SuzukiThe Proceedings of the Annual Convention of the Japanese Psychological Association 2018 · DOI

Abstract

This longitudinal study investigates the psychological structure of professional burden among Japanese public school teachers. By tracking 406 educators over a one-year period, the research evaluates the directional relationships between three types of work-related stress: school management, educational tasks, and individual student/parent support. Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) reveals that while individual stress levels are highly stable year-to-year, the immediate pressures of classroom teaching and external relations significantly inflate the perceived burden of administrative duties.

Introduction

Teacher overwork is a critical social issue in Japan. However, "burden" is not a monolithic experience; it encompasses diverse tasks such as lesson preparation, classroom management, faculty meetings, and handling parent-teacher associations (PTA). This study aims to understand the directional structure of these burdens—specifically, whether stress in one area predicts future stress in another (cross-lagged effects) or if these pressures interact simultaneously within a teacher's daily workflow.

Methods

The researchers conducted a longitudinal internet survey at two time points: Time 1 (Jan–Feb 2017) and Time 2 (March 2018). The final sample consisted of 406 full-time public elementary and junior high school teachers (81.8% male; average age 50.51).

Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) was used to test two models:

  1. Cross-Lagged Effect Model: Evaluates if a burden at Time 1 predicts changes in other burdens at Time 2.
  2. Simultaneous Effect Model: Evaluates how burdens influence each other within the same time point (Time 2), controlling for baseline levels at Time 1.

The "Sense of Burden" was categorized into three latent factors:

  • School Management Burden: Administrative tasks and school events.
  • Educational Burden: Lesson preparation and classroom management.
  • Individual Response Burden: Career counseling and parent/PTA interactions.

Results

The study compared the longitudinal causal structure against a simultaneous interaction model.

Cross-Lagged Stability

The cross-lagged model (Figure 1) demonstrated high stability within each burden category over the one-year interval. However, the "lagged" effects—where stress in one category at Time 1 predicts a change in another at Time 2—were weak and statistically insignificant.

Figure 1: Cross-Lagged Effect Model showing high stability but low cross-category prediction over one year.

Simultaneous Interactions

The Simultaneous Effect Model (Figure 2) provided a superior fit for the data (CFI = .908, RMSEA = .076). It revealed that "School Management" acts as a cumulative sinkhole for other stresses. Specifically:

  • Educational Burden significantly increased the perceived School Management Burden (β = .221, p < .05).
  • Individual Response Burden had the strongest impact on perceived School Management Burden (β = .364, p < .001).
Figure 2: Simultaneous Effect Model illustrating how educational and individual burdens exacerbate administrative stress.

Discussion

The findings suggest that the perceived burden of administrative work is often a byproduct of the pressures faced in teaching and external relations. The lack of significant cross-lagged effects suggests that the "vicious cycle" of teacher stress likely operates on a much shorter cycle (daily or weekly) than the one-year interval measured here.

Limitations

The study's sample was heavily skewed toward male teachers (over 80%), which may not fully represent the gender distribution in Japanese elementary schools. Future research should utilize shorter time intervals to better capture the dynamic flow of professional burden.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{tamai2018examining,
  author = {Kota Tamai and Hidenori Fujita and Maki Yamada and Setsuko Waida and Yuta Suzuki},
  title = {{Examining the Structure of Sense of Burden among Public Elementary and Junior High School Teachers (2)}},
  booktitle = {The Proceedings of the Annual Convention of the Japanese Psychological Association},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.4992/pacjpa.82.0\_2ev-094},
}
Figure