Abstract
This longitudinal study investigates the psychological structure of professional burden among Japanese public school teachers. By tracking 406 educators over a one-year period, the research evaluates the directional relationships between three types of work-related stress: school management, educational tasks, and individual student/parent support. Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) reveals that while individual stress levels are highly stable year-to-year, the immediate pressures of classroom teaching and external relations significantly inflate the perceived burden of administrative duties.
Introduction
Teacher overwork is a critical social issue in Japan. However, "burden" is not a monolithic experience; it encompasses diverse tasks such as lesson preparation, classroom management, faculty meetings, and handling parent-teacher associations (PTA). This study aims to understand the directional structure of these burdens—specifically, whether stress in one area predicts future stress in another (cross-lagged effects) or if these pressures interact simultaneously within a teacher's daily workflow.
Methods
The researchers conducted a longitudinal internet survey at two time points: Time 1 (Jan–Feb 2017) and Time 2 (March 2018). The final sample consisted of 406 full-time public elementary and junior high school teachers (81.8% male; average age 50.51).
Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) was used to test two models:
- Cross-Lagged Effect Model: Evaluates if a burden at Time 1 predicts changes in other burdens at Time 2.
- Simultaneous Effect Model: Evaluates how burdens influence each other within the same time point (Time 2), controlling for baseline levels at Time 1.
The "Sense of Burden" was categorized into three latent factors:
- School Management Burden: Administrative tasks and school events.
- Educational Burden: Lesson preparation and classroom management.
- Individual Response Burden: Career counseling and parent/PTA interactions.
Results
The study compared the longitudinal causal structure against a simultaneous interaction model.
Cross-Lagged Stability
The cross-lagged model (Figure 1) demonstrated high stability within each burden category over the one-year interval. However, the "lagged" effects—where stress in one category at Time 1 predicts a change in another at Time 2—were weak and statistically insignificant.
Simultaneous Interactions
The Simultaneous Effect Model (Figure 2) provided a superior fit for the data (CFI = .908, RMSEA = .076). It revealed that "School Management" acts as a cumulative sinkhole for other stresses. Specifically:
- Educational Burden significantly increased the perceived School Management Burden (β = .221, p < .05).
- Individual Response Burden had the strongest impact on perceived School Management Burden (β = .364, p < .001).
Discussion
The findings suggest that the perceived burden of administrative work is often a byproduct of the pressures faced in teaching and external relations. The lack of significant cross-lagged effects suggests that the "vicious cycle" of teacher stress likely operates on a much shorter cycle (daily or weekly) than the one-year interval measured here.
Limitations
The study's sample was heavily skewed toward male teachers (over 80%), which may not fully represent the gender distribution in Japanese elementary schools. Future research should utilize shorter time intervals to better capture the dynamic flow of professional burden.
Summary updated