Examining the Influence of Crop Residue Burning on Local PM2.5 Concentrations in Heilongjiang Province Using Ground Observation and Remote Sensing Data

Ziyue Chen, Danlu Chen, Yan Zhuang, Jun Cai, Na Zhao, Bin He, Bingbo Gao, Bing XuRemote 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the impact of crop residue burning on local PM2.5 concentrations in Heilongjiang Province, China. While regional analysis showed no clear correlation, local-scale analysis revealed that crop residue burning significantly increases PM2.5 levels within a 50-80 km radius, highlighting its localized but potent effect on air quality.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Air pollution, particularly from fine particulate matter (PM2.5), is a major concern in China, with severe haze episodes becoming more frequent. Crop residue burning is often cited as a significant contributor, especially in agricultural regions like Heilongjiang. However, the precise influence of this burning on local PM2.5 concentrations, and the spatial extent of this influence, remains unclear. Previous studies have focused on quantifying emissions or establishing broad regional correlations, but a detailed understanding of how burning events translate to localized PM2.5 increases, and the effective "reach" of this pollution, has been lacking. This paper aims to fill this gap by combining ground-based PM2.5 measurements with satellite-derived fire data to pinpoint the localized impact of crop residue burning.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach:

  • Crop Residue Burning Spot Extraction: They utilized MODIS Thermal Anomalies/Fire products (MOD14A1) with a 1 km spatial resolution. To distinguish crop residue burning from other fire sources (like urban waste or forest fires), they overlaid these fire detection maps with a 30-meter resolution national land cover dataset. Fires detected specifically within "cropland" areas were identified as crop residue burning spots.
  • Buffer Zone Analysis: To assess the spatial influence of these burning spots, they created buffer zones of varying radii (10, 20, 50, 80, and 100 km) around them. Ground PM2.5 monitoring stations were then classified as either "close to" or "not close to" burning spots based on their proximity to these buffers.
  • Statistical and Correlation Analysis: For each buffer scenario, they compared the average PM2.5 concentrations between the "close to" and "not close to" station groups. They also performed Pearson correlation analysis to quantify the relationship between the presence of burning spots and local PM2.5 levels.

Datasets

  • Ground PM2.5 Concentrations Data: Hourly PM2.5 data from 55 ground observation stations in Heilongjiang Province were collected from the PM25.in website (which aggregates data from the China National Environmental Monitoring Center). The study period was October 31 to November 6, 2015, chosen for its high intensity of crop residue burning.
  • MODIS Thermal Anomalies/Fire Products (MOD14A1): This dataset provided daily fire detection information at a 1 km spatial resolution.
  • National Land Cover Data: A 30-meter resolution dataset from the Chinese Academy of Sciences was used to differentiate cropland from other land cover types, enabling the isolation of crop residue burning spots.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Regional vs. Local Impact: The most striking insight is the stark contrast between regional and local analyses. While the total number of burning spots across the entire province didn't correlate with overall PM2.5 levels, the localized impact was significant. This suggests that provincial-level averages can mask important localized pollution events.
  • Defining the "Reach" of Burning Pollution: The buffer zone analysis was crucial. It revealed that smaller buffer zones (10-20 km) yielded counterintuitive results (stations "not close" having higher PM2.5), indicating that the pollution plume extended much further. This led to the identification of a critical influencing area.
  • The Complexity of Air Pollution: The lack of a consistent, significant correlation between burning spots and PM2.5, even at the local scale, underscores that crop residue burning is not the sole driver of PM2.5. Other emission sources and meteorological factors play a substantial role, making air quality management a complex, multi-factorial challenge.

Key Results

  • Provincial Scale: No clear linear correlation was found between the total number of crop residue burning spots and mean PM2.5 concentrations at the provincial level in Heilongjiang.
  • Local Scale:
    • The valid influencing area of crop residue burning on local PM2.5 concentrations was determined to be between 50 and 80 km.
  • Stations located within this influencing area (close to burning spots) recorded mean PM2.5 concentrations more than 60 µg/m³ higher than stations not close to burning spots.
  • Despite this significant increase, the correlation coefficient between the existence of burning spots and local PM2.5 was not consistently significant across all buffer sizes and days, reinforcing the idea of multiple contributing factors.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Validation of Fire Products: The authors highlight that MODIS fire products might detect other types of fires, and few field experiments have been conducted to validate these products specifically for crop residue burning in China. This could lead to potential biases. They suggest future research should include more field experiments.
  • Source Apportionment: While this study shows a strong localized impact, it doesn't quantify the relative contribution of crop residue burning compared to other sources (traffic, industry). The authors recommend using source apportionment methods to better understand this.
  • Temporal Resolution: Daily fire maps from MODIS might not fully capture the dynamic, short-lived nature of burning events and their immediate impact. They suggest that higher temporal resolution data (e.g., from Himawari satellites with 10-minute intervals) could provide a more accurate real-time correlation.
  • Spatial Density of PM2.5 Stations: The study was limited by the relatively sparse distribution of ground PM2.5 monitoring stations. A denser network would allow for more detailed statistical analysis and potentially the development of regression models to better estimate local PM2.5 concentrations influenced by burning.

Summary updated

Abstract

Although a many studies concerning crop residue burning have been conducted, the influence of crop residue burning on local PM2.5 concentrations remains unclear. The number of crop residue burning spots was the highest in Heilongjiang province and we extracted crop residue burning spots for this region using MOD14A1 (Thermal Anomalies & Fire Daily L3 Global 1 km) data and national land cover data. By analyzing the temporal variation of crop residue burning and PM2.5 concentrations in Heilongjiang province, we found that the total number of crop residue burning spots was not correlated with the variations of PM2.5 concentrations at a provincial (regional) scale. However, crop residue burning exerted notable influence on the variations of PM2.5 concentrations at a local scale. We experimented with a set of buffer zone radiuses to examine the influencing area of crop residue burning. The results suggest that the valid influencing area of crop residue burning was between 50 and 80 km. The mean PM2.5 concentration measured at stations close to crop residue burning spots was more than 60 μg/m3 higher than that measured at stations not close to crop residue burning spots. However, no consistent, significant correlation existed between the existence of crop residue burning spots and local PM2.5 concentrations, indicating that local PM2.5 concentrations were influenced by a diversity of factors and not solely controlled by crop residue burning. This research also provides suggestions for better understanding the role of crop residue burning in local and regional air pollution.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chen2017examining,
  author = {Ziyue Chen and Danlu Chen and Yan Zhuang and Jun Cai and Na Zhao and Bin He and Bingbo Gao and Bing Xu},
  title = {{Examining the Influence of Crop Residue Burning on Local PM2.5 Concentrations in Heilongjiang Province Using Ground Observation and Remote Sensing Data}},
  booktitle = {Remote},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3390/rs9100971},
}
Figure