Examining implicit bias of physicians who care for individuals with spinal cord injury: A pilot study and future directions

Leslie R. M. Hausmann, Larissa Myaskovsky, Christian Niyonkuru, M. Oyster, Galen E. Switzer, Kelly H. Burkitt, Michael J. Fine, Shasha Gao, Michael L. BoningerJournal of Spinal Cord Medicine 2014 · DOI

TL;DR

This pilot study reveals that physicians treating individuals with spinal cord injury (SCI) exhibit significant implicit racial bias, favoring white individuals over Black individuals. This bias is linked to poorer psychosocial outcomes for SCI patients, including increased disability in social integration, higher depression, and lower life satisfaction, highlighting a critical area for intervention in healthcare equity.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Despite a growing body of evidence demonstrating that healthcare providers hold implicit biases that can negatively impact patient care, this phenomenon has not been specifically examined within the context of physicians who specialize in treating individuals with spinal cord injury (SCI). Given the known racial and ethnic disparities in health and quality of life experienced by individuals with SCI, understanding whether their physicians harbor implicit racial biases and how these biases might affect patient outcomes is crucial for improving care and reducing these disparities. This paper aims to fill this knowledge gap by conducting a pilot study to investigate implicit racial bias among SCI physicians and its association with the functioning and well-being of their patients.

Methods

The study employed a cross-sectional design, combining data from surveys of individuals with SCI and their physicians.

  • Implicit Bias Measurement: Physicians completed the Implicit Association Test (IAT), a well-validated reaction-time measure designed to assess unconscious preferences. Specifically, the race IAT used here measures implicit pro-white/anti-black bias by assessing how quickly participants categorize stimuli (e.g., faces, words) that are congruent or incongruent with these racial categories. Scores range from -2 to +2, with positive scores indicating a pro-white bias.
  • Patient Outcomes Measurement: Individuals with SCI completed questionnaires assessing various aspects of their health and well-being, including:
  • Functioning: Assessed using subscales of the Craig Handicap Assessment and Reporting Technique Short Form (CHART-SF) for mobility, occupation, physical independence, and social integration. Scores were dichotomized to indicate disability (score <100) or non-disability (score = 100).
  • Health Status: Assessed with a single item from the SF-36, dichotomized into fair/poor vs. good/very good/excellent.
  • Emotional Well-being: Measured by the Patient Health Questionnaire-9 (PHQ-9) for depression and the Satisfaction with Life Scale.
  • Statistical Analysis: Multilevel regression analyses were used to examine the associations between physician IAT scores and patient outcomes, accounting for potential clustering of patients within physicians. Covariates included patient demographics (race, sex, age, SCI level, years since injury) and healthcare utilization (number of visits with SCI provider).

Datasets

  • Patient Data: Data were collected from 162 individuals with SCI who were part of an ongoing study on assistive technology used by individuals with SCI, recruited from four national Spinal Cord Injury Model Systems (SCIMS) sites between 2007 and 2011.
  • Physician Data: Data were collected from 14 SCI physicians who treated at least two of the participating SCI patients. Physicians were recruited in 2011.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Strong Implicit Bias in SCI Physicians: The study found a significant and strong implicit pro-white/anti-black bias among the participating SCI physicians, with an effect size (Cohen's d = 2.00) that is notably larger than that observed in many other healthcare provider samples. This suggests that implicit bias is a prevalent issue within this specialized medical field.
  • Bias Impacts Psychosocial Outcomes: The most striking finding is the association between higher physician implicit bias and poorer psychosocial outcomes for SCI patients. Specifically, greater bias was linked to a higher likelihood of disability in social integration, increased depression, and lower life satisfaction.
  • Differential Impact on Outcomes: Interestingly, physician implicit bias was not associated with disability in the domains of mobility, occupation, or overall self-reported physical health status. This suggests that psychosocial and emotional well-being may be more sensitive indicators of the impact of physician bias than physical functioning in the SCI population.
  • Feasibility Demonstrated: The study successfully demonstrated the feasibility of measuring implicit bias among SCI physicians and linking it to patient outcomes, providing a foundation for larger-scale research.

Key Results

  • Physician Implicit Bias: The mean IAT score for physicians was 0.62 (SD = 0.35), indicating a strong pro-white/anti-black bias. This effect size was interpreted as large in social science terms.
  • Social Integration: Greater physician implicit racial bias was associated with a significantly higher likelihood of disability in social integration (Odds Ratio = 4.80, 95% CI = 1.44, 16.04).
  • Depression: Physician implicit bias was associated with higher levels of depression among patients (B = 3.24, 95% CI = 1.06, 5.41).
  • Life Satisfaction: Conversely, greater physician implicit bias was associated with lower life satisfaction among patients (B = -4.54, 95% CI = -8.79, -0.28).

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations:

  • Small Sample Size: The study was a pilot with a small number of physicians (N=14) and SCI participants (N=162), limiting statistical power and generalizability.
  • Cross-Sectional Design: The study design does not allow for the determination of causality; observed associations could be due to other factors or reverse causality (e.g., patients with worse outcomes choosing different physicians).
  • Inability to Examine Interactions: The small sample size prevented the examination of whether physician bias has a differential impact on outcomes for minority patients or contributes to racial disparities.
  • Focus on Physician Bias Only: The study did not consider the potential impact of patients' own implicit biases.

Future Work:

  • Larger-Scale Studies: Future research needs to recruit larger samples of physicians and patients to achieve adequate statistical power and generalizability.
  • Investigate Mechanisms: Further studies should explore the mechanisms by which physician bias impacts patient outcomes, such as through communication, clinical recommendations, or adherence.
  • Broader Outcomes: Future research should expand to include a wider range of care processes and outcomes specific to SCI, such as wheelchair prescribing, bladder management, and the occurrence of pressure sores.
  • Interactions and Disparities: Studies should be designed to test interactions between physician bias and patient characteristics (e.g., race) to understand how bias contributes to disparities.
  • Prospective Design: Future studies could benefit from a prospective design, enrolling physicians first and then recruiting patients to better establish temporal relationships.

Summary updated

Abstract

This pilot study indicates that SCI providers are susceptible to implicit racial bias and provides preliminary evidence that greater implicit racial bias of physicians is associated with poorer psychosocial health outcomes for individuals with SCI. It demonstrates the feasibility of studying implicit bias among SCI providers and provides guidance for future research on physician bias and patient outcomes.
BibTeX
@article{hausmann2014examining,
  author = {Leslie R. M. Hausmann and Larissa Myaskovsky and Christian Niyonkuru and M. Oyster and Galen E. Switzer and Kelly H. Burkitt and Michael J. Fine and Shasha Gao and Michael L. Boninger},
  title = {{Examining implicit bias of physicians who care for individuals with spinal cord injury: A pilot study and future directions}},
  journal = {Journal of Spinal Cord Medicine},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1179/2045772313y.0000000184},
}
Figure