Ex vivoovine liver model simulating respiratory motion and blood perfusion for validating image-guided HIFU systems

Xu Xiao, Markus Domschke, Benjamin F. Cox, Helen McLeod, Ioannis Karakitsios, Andreas MelzerJournal of Therapeutic Ultrasound 2015 · DOI

Abstract

The effect of moving organs and blood perfusion on image guided procedures such as focused ultrasound is challenging therefore we have developed ex vivo ovine liver phantoms to simulate respiratory motion and blood perfusion. The simulator was used to validate ultrasound image-guided HIFU treatment when the target tissue was moving.

Introduction

High-Intensity Focused Ultrasound (HIFU) is a non-invasive therapeutic technique that uses concentrated sound waves to heat and destroy diseased tissue. However, applying HIFU to abdominal organs like the liver is complicated by two major physiological factors:

  1. Respiratory Motion: The liver moves significantly during breathing, making it a "moving target" for the ultrasound beam.
  2. Blood Perfusion: Flowing blood acts as a "heat sink," carrying away thermal energy intended to ablate the tumor, which can lead to incomplete treatment.

Testing new HIFU tracking algorithms on humans or live animals is expensive and ethically complex. This study presents a realistic, benchtop "phantom" that simulates these dynamic conditions to validate system accuracy before clinical application.

Methods

The researchers constructed a multi-modal simulator using a physical ovine (sheep) liver embedded in a 3% agar-gelatine block to provide a tissue-mimicking structural matrix. To simulate breathing, a medical air balloon connected to a standard lung ventilator was used to push the liver, while two water balloons provided the return force during expiration.

Experimental setup of the ovine liver phantom with simulated respiratory motion and perfusion.

To simulate blood flow, a heart-lung bypass machine pumped saline into the portal vein at a rate of 220 ml/min. The setup was designed to be MR-compatible, allowing for visualization via Digital Subtraction Angiography (DSA), 1.5T MRI, and ultrasound Doppler. The simulator was used to test the Exablate 2100 system, which utilizes real-time motion information from an ultrasound scanner to steer its focus and follow moving tissue.

Key Results

The system successfully generated up to 30 mm of superior-inferior motion, mirroring the typical range of liver motion in a breathing human. This provided a rigorous test for the HIFU system's tracking capabilities.

Multi-modal imaging (X-ray, MR, and Ultrasound) demonstrating vascular contrast and blood pulse simulation.

Vascular contrast was high in both X-ray and MR scans following saline perfusion. Ultrasound color Doppler confirmed a clear "blood pulse" within the model, proving the effectiveness of the extracorporeal circuit. Finally, the Exablate 2100 HIFU system successfully used real-time motion data to steer its focus, validating the phantom as a viable tool for testing dynamic tracking algorithms.

Discussion and Key Insights

The use of a ventilator-driven system achieved significant mechanical realism. By re-creating physiological flow, the model allows for testing how blood flow rates influence ultrasound sonication—a critical hurdle for HIFU efficacy. Furthermore, the phantom's compatibility across X-ray, MRI, and Ultrasound enables the validation of "image-fusion" techniques, where data from different imaging types are combined to guide treatment.

Limitations and Future Work

While robust, the model used saline for perfusion; saline's thermal properties differ slightly from whole blood, which contains proteins and cells that affect ultrasound absorption. Additionally, as an ex vivo model, the tissue will eventually degrade, limiting the testing window. Future iterations may incorporate more complex 3D rotation and deformation to better simulate human breathing patterns.

Overall, this model represents a significant step forward in providing a low-cost, high-fidelity environment for refining the next generation of non-invasive cancer treatments.

Summary updated

Abstract

The effect of moving organs and blood perfusion on image guided procedures such as focused ultrasound is challenging therefore we have developed ex vivo ovine liver phantoms to simulate respiratory motion and blood perfusion. The simulator was used to validate ultrasound image-guided HIFU treatment when the target tissue was moving.
BibTeX
@article{xiao2015ex,
  author = {Xu Xiao and Markus Domschke and Benjamin F. Cox and Helen McLeod and Ioannis Karakitsios and Andreas Melzer},
  title = {{Ex vivoovine liver model simulating respiratory motion and blood perfusion for validating image-guided HIFU systems}},
  journal = {Journal of Therapeutic Ultrasound},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1186/2050-5736-3-s1-p53},
}
Figure