TL;DR
This study reveals that H6N6 avian influenza viruses (AIVs) in China are highly dynamic, undergoing frequent reassortment events with other AIV subtypes. These H6N6 viruses, while generally low pathogenic, can infect mammals without prior adaptation and act as crucial intermediaries in the evolution of more dangerous strains like H5N6 and H7N9, highlighting the need for continuous surveillance.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Avian influenza viruses (AIVs) are a constant threat, with well-known subtypes like H5N1 and H7N9 causing significant human illness and economic losses. While surveillance often focuses on these highly pathogenic strains, less attention has been paid to low pathogenic AIVs (LPAIVs) that can still pose a risk. H6N6 viruses, in particular, have been detected with increasing frequency in various hosts, including wild birds, poultry, and even mammals. Crucially, recent evidence suggests H6N6 viruses are involved in the generation of more concerning subtypes like H5N6 and H7N9, acting as a genetic "mixing bowl." However, the evolutionary patterns and potential pandemic threat posed by H6N6 viruses remained unclear. This paper aims to fill that gap by investigating the emergence, evolutionary dynamics, and potential epidemic risk of H6N6 viruses in China.
Methods
The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:
- Phylogenetic Analysis: They used maximum likelihood (ML) phylogenetic trees to analyze the evolutionary relationships of H6 HA and N6 NA genes from a large dataset of H6N6 viruses. This involved clustering sequences based on similarity thresholds to identify representative strains and understand their lineage.
- Molecular Clock Analysis: To understand the temporal evolution of H6N6 viruses, they used a Bayesian molecular clock model. This method estimates the rate of genetic change over time and helps infer the timing of evolutionary events.
- Genotype Identification: By analyzing all eight gene segments of the H6N6 viruses, they identified and classified distinct genotypes, providing insights into the diversity and reassortment patterns.
- Animal Experiments: To assess the pathogenicity and host range, they conducted in vivo studies. This included intravenous pathogenicity index (IVPI) tests in chickens and intranasal inoculation in mice to evaluate viral replication and virulence.
Datasets
The study utilized two main sources of H6N6 virus data:
- Public Databases: A substantial number of H6N6 virus genome sequences (168 strains) were obtained from the NCBI and GISAID databases, covering data up to January 2019.
- Newly Isolated Strains: 30 H6N6 virus isolates were collected from domestic farms and live poultry markets in China between November 2014 and January 2019.
In total, 198 H6N6 virus genomes were analyzed.
Key Insights and Ideas
- H6N6 as a Genetic Intermediary: The most striking finding is the role of H6N6 viruses as a crucial intermediary in the evolution of other AIV subtypes. They frequently reassort with viruses like H5N6 and H7N9, contributing genetic material that can lead to the emergence of more dangerous strains.
- Constant and Uninterrupted Evolution: Molecular clock analysis suggests that the evolution of H6N6 viruses in China has been a continuous process, not significantly interrupted by strong selective pressures. This implies a steady rate of genetic change and reassortment.
- Mammalian Adaptation Potential: Despite being generally low pathogenic in chickens, H6N6 viruses demonstrated the ability to infect mice without prior adaptation. This suggests a potential for cross-species transmission and adaptation to mammalian hosts, raising concerns for human health.
- Frequent Reassortment Events: The study identified numerous reassortment events, with H6N6 viruses exchanging genetic material with at least six other AIV subtypes (H6N2, H5N6, H7N9, H5N2, H4N2, and H6N8). This highlights the dynamic nature of viral evolution in this subtype.
- NA Stalk Deletions: A significant observation was the presence of an 11-amino acid deletion in the NA stalk of several H6N6 strains from Anhui province. This structural change in the NA protein is known to affect viral characteristics and warrants further investigation.
Key Results
- 98 Genotypes Identified: Phylogenetic analysis of 198 H6N6 virus genomes revealed 98 distinct genotypes, underscoring the high genetic diversity and rapid evolution within this subtype.
- Low Pathogenicity in Chickens: Ten representative H6N6 viruses tested showed low pathogenicity in chickens, with IVPI values below 1.2.
- Replication in Mice: All 10 representative H6N6 viruses replicated well in the lungs of mice after intranasal inoculation, indicating a capacity for mammalian infection.
- NA Gene Lineage: The NA genes of the 30 laboratory strains clustered within the N6 Eurasian lineage, with a notable deletion in six out of seven Anhui strains.
Limitations and Future Work
- Focus on China: The study primarily focuses on H6N6 viruses circulating in China. While this provides valuable insights into the local evolutionary dynamics, a broader global perspective might reveal additional patterns.
- NA Deletion Significance: While the study identified NA stalk deletions in some strains and noted their potential impact on viral characteristics, further research is needed to fully elucidate the biological consequences of these deletions.
- Mammalian Adaptation Mechanisms: While H6N6 viruses can infect mice without prior adaptation, understanding the specific genetic or molecular mechanisms that facilitate this adaptation is a key area for future investigation.
- Continuous Monitoring: The authors emphasize the need for continuous monitoring and evaluation of H6N6 subtype viruses due to their role in AIV evolution and potential for epidemic emergence. This suggests ongoing surveillance and research efforts are crucial.
Summary updated