Evolution of Green Industrial Growth between Europe and China based on the Energy Consumption Model

Yanbing Mao, Kui Liu, Jizhi ZhouSustainability 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how Europe and China achieve "green industrial growth" – economic expansion with reduced greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. It reveals two distinct models: Europe relies on increasing renewable energy, while China prioritizes energy efficiency improvements in fossil fuel use. Understanding these models is crucial for developing effective sustainable development policies globally.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The core challenge this paper tackles is how to reconcile industrial growth with environmental sustainability, specifically by reducing greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. While the ideal scenario is high industrial output with low GHG emissions, the reality is often a trade-off. This research aims to understand the different strategies employed by developed economies (Europe) and a rapidly developing economy (China) to achieve this "green industrial growth." It questions whether a single approach to reducing emissions is universally applicable or if context-specific strategies are necessary, especially given differing energy resource endowments and technological capabilities.

Methods

The study employs two primary quantitative methods:

  • Hierarchical Cluster Analysis (HCA): This technique is used to group countries and Chinese provinces based on their industrial growth, GHG emissions, and energy consumption patterns. HCA helps to identify distinct "models" of green industrial growth by revealing similarities and differences in these key indicators over time. The paper specifically mentions using Euclidean Distance as the statistical distance measure.
  • Principal Component Analysis (PCA): PCA is used to reduce the dimensionality of the data, allowing for a visualization of the relationships between industrial growth, GHG emissions, and renewable energy consumption. This helps to identify the main drivers of green industrial growth in different regions.

Additionally, the study utilizes linear regression models to evaluate the relationships between variables like energy consumption, GHG emissions, and industrial output.

Datasets

The data used in this study spans from 2007 to 2016 and includes:

  • Chinese Data: Collected from the Chinese National Bureau of Statistics.
  • European Data: Collected from the European Environmental Agency (EEA) and Eurostat.
  • Eastern European Countries: Romania, Poland, and the Czech Republic.
  • Western European Countries: UK, Netherlands, Spain, Austria, Germany, and France.

Energy data includes both "green energy" (wind, solar, nuclear, natural gas) and "traditional energy" (coal, oil). All energy units were converted to the weight of standard coal.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Two Distinct "Models" of Green Industrial Growth: The most significant insight is the identification of two contrasting pathways: the "Europe Model" driven by renewable energy adoption and the "China Model" driven by energy efficiency improvements in fossil fuel use.
  • Renewable Energy as Europe's Primary Strategy: Europe's success in reducing GHG emissions while growing its industrial sector is strongly linked to its increasing reliance on renewable energy sources.
  • Energy Efficiency as China's Key Driver: Despite rapid industrial growth and increasing GHG emissions initially, China has managed to decouple growth from emissions through significant improvements in energy efficiency, particularly in its use of fossil fuels.
  • Context Matters: The study highlights that the effectiveness of different strategies is influenced by regional factors, such as the availability of fossil fuels versus renewable resources.
  • Decoupling is Possible, but Through Different Means: Both regions demonstrate a decoupling of industrial growth from GHG emissions, but the mechanisms are fundamentally different.

Key Results

  • Europe: Achieved negative annual GHG emission rates, with renewable energy consumption reaching a maximum of 33% and averaging 16% of gross energy consumption.
  • China: Experienced significant increases in GHG emissions (50-77%) during rapid industrial growth initially. However, after 2012, GHG emission rates decreased to 7% or less. This reduction was primarily attributed to improved fossil energy efficiency, as renewable energy consumption remained below 10% in most industrial provinces.
  • HCA and PCA Findings: Cluster analysis revealed distinct groupings of countries and provinces based on their industrial growth and energy consumption patterns. PCA indicated that in Europe, PC2 (representing renewable energy consumption) was associated with GHG emission reduction, while in China, PC1 (representing energy efficiency) played a similar role.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Granularity: While the study covers a significant period, the analysis of Chinese provinces might benefit from more granular data to fully capture regional variations.
  • Policy Specificity: The paper identifies broad strategies but could delve deeper into the specific policies and technological innovations that underpin these models.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that either the utilization of renewable energy or the improvement of fossil energy efficiency through technological progress can be viable options for promoting sustainable development. Further research could explore the long-term viability and scalability of both the "China Model" and the "Europe Model," as well as potential hybrid approaches. The study also implies that understanding the Porter Hypothesis in the context of these different models could further promote green growth.

Summary updated

Abstract

Greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions are an important factor in the evaluation of green industrial growth, when low GHG emissions along with high industrial growth are expected. In this paper, the improvement of sustainable development of industry in China (2007–2015) was investigated via analysis of the relationships between the GHG emissions and energy consumption in comparison to European countries. A hierarchical cluster analysis (HCA) was conducted to distinguish industrial growth with GHG emission and energy consumption structures. The results of this research indicated that green industrial growth in Europe had a negative annual rate of GHG emissions. This contributed to the ratio of renewable energy consumption increasing to a maximum of 33% and an average of 16%. In comparison, the GHG emissions in China increased at a rate of 50% to 77% in the main industrial provinces since 2007 with their rapid industrial growth. The rate of GHG emissions decreased after 2012, which was 7% or less than the rate of emissions in the industrial provinces. Contrary to in Europe, the decreasing rate of GHG emissions in China was attributed to the improvement of fossil energy efficiency, as renewable energy consumption was less than 10% in most industrial provinces. Our data analysis identified that the two different energy consumption strategies improved green industrial growth in Europe and China, respectively. Our data analysis identified the two different energy consumption strategies employed by Europe and China, each of which promoted green industrial growth in the corresponding areas. We concluded that China achieved green industrial growth through an increase in energy efficiency through technology updates to decrease GHG emissions, which we call the “China Model.” The “Europe Model” proved to be quite different, having the core characteristic of increasing renewable energy use.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{mao2019evolution,
  author = {Yanbing Mao and Kui Liu and Jizhi Zhou},
  title = {{Evolution of Green Industrial Growth between Europe and China based on the Energy Consumption Model}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/su11247168},
}
Figure