Evolution of chromosome arm aberrations in breast cancer through genetic network rewiring

Elena Kuzmin, Toby M. Baker, Tom Lesluyes, Jean Monlong, Kento T. Abe, Paula P. Coelho, Michael Schwartz, Dongmei Zou, Geneviève Morin, Alain Pacis, Yang Yang, Constanza Martínez, Jarrett Barber, Hellen Kuasne, Rui Li, Mathieu Bourgey, Anne-Marie Fortier, Peter Davison, Atilla Ömeroğlu, Marie-Christine Guiot, Quaid Morris, Claudia L. Kleinman, Sidong Huang, Anne‐Claude Gingras, Jiannis Ragoussis, Guillaume Bourque, Peter Van Loo, Morag ParkbioRxiv 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that chromosome 4p loss is an early and common event in basal-like breast cancer, driving enhanced proliferation and contributing to the development of complex aneuploid karyotypes. The researchers identified a novel gene, C4orf19 (renamed PGCA1), within this region that plays a key role in this process by interacting with the PDCD10-GCKIII kinase module.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Triple-negative breast cancer (TNBC), a particularly aggressive subtype of breast cancer, often exhibits complex chromosomal abnormalities, including large deletions. However, the functional consequences and evolutionary timing of these deletions, particularly chromosome arm losses, remain poorly understood. This paper aims to elucidate the role of chromosome 4p (chr4p) loss in basal-like breast cancer, a subtype enriched for TNBC, by characterizing its evolutionary emergence, functional impact on proliferation, and the underlying molecular mechanisms. Understanding these early genetic events is crucial for developing more effective therapeutic strategies for this challenging disease.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Genomic Analysis: They analyzed The Cancer Genome Atlas (TCGA) data to identify recurrent chr4p deletions in basal breast cancer.
  • Phylogenetic Reconstruction: Using whole-genome sequencing (WGS) data from a unique panel of primary tumor/patient-derived xenograft (PT/PDX) basal breast cancers, they reconstructed the evolutionary history of these tumors to pinpoint the timing of chr4p loss.
  • Functional Assays:
    • Gene Function Studies: They used gene function studies to investigate the role of genes within the chr4p region, specifically identifying C4orf19.
  • Genome-wide Pooled Overexpression Screens: These screens utilized barcoded libraries of human open reading frames to identify chromosomal regions that, when overexpressed, suppress proliferation in a context-dependent manner.
  • Single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNAseq): This technique was used to infer copy number status at a single-cell resolution and identify transcriptional programs associated with chr4p deletion.
  • Immunofluorescence and RNA-in situ hybridization (RNA-ISH): These methods were used to validate findings and assess protein localization and expression.
  • Proximity-dependent biotinylation (miniTurboID) coupled with mass spectrometry: This technique was used to reveal the physical neighborhood of C4orf19.
  • Co-immunoprecipitation (Co-IP) assays: Used to confirm protein-protein interactions.

Datasets

  • The Cancer Genome Atlas (TCGA): Used for analyzing copy number and gene expression data in basal breast cancer.
  • Primary Tumor/Patient-Derived Xenograft (PT/PDX) panel: A unique collection of 23 primary tumor/PDX basal breast cancers was used for phylogenetic reconstruction.
  • Human Open Reading Frame (ORF) collection: Used for genome-wide pooled overexpression screens.
  • Normal breast epithelial cell lines (MCF10A): Used as a control in functional assays.
  • Basal breast cancer patient-derived xenograft (PDX)-derived cell lines (GCRC1915, GCRC1735): Used in functional assays and for scRNAseq.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • chr4p Loss as an Early Driver: The study strongly suggests that chr4p loss is not a late-stage event but an early clonal event in basal breast cancer evolution, occurring even before whole-genome duplication. This highlights its significant role in initiating tumorigenesis.
  • Proliferation Enhancement: chr4p loss is directly linked to enhanced cell proliferation, a hallmark of cancer. This is a crucial functional consequence that drives tumor growth.
  • C4orf19 (PGCA1) as a Novel Player: The identification of C4orf19 as a gene within chr4p that suppresses proliferation when overexpressed is a significant discovery. Its interaction with the PDCD10-GCKIII kinase module, leading to the proposed name PGCA1, opens new avenues for understanding the molecular underpinnings of chr4p loss.
  • Context-Dependent Gene Function: The finding that overexpression of chr4p genes suppresses proliferation in a context-dependent manner (i.e., only in cells with chr4p deletion) is a critical insight. This suggests that the genetic background of the cell dictates the functional outcome of gene dosage changes, implying complex network rewiring.
  • Network Rewiring and Aneuploidy: The study posits that chr4p loss contributes to the emergence of complex aneuploid karyotypes through genetic network rewiring, where the loss of specific chromosomal regions creates vulnerabilities that are then exploited by the cancer cell.

Key Results

  • Approximately 65% of basal breast cancer cases exhibit chr4p loss.
  • Phylogenetic analysis revealed that chr4p loss is an early clonal event, occurring before whole-genome duplication.
  • Overexpression of C4orf19 (PGCA1) suppressed proliferation in basal breast cancer cell lines.
  • Genome-wide screens identified chr4p and other chromosomal regions that suppress proliferation when overexpressed in a context-dependent manner.
  • chr4p loss was associated with decreased expression of genes involved in immune response pathways.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Minimal Deleted Region: The apparent lack of a clear minimal deleted region on chr4p suggests that the selective advantage is conferred by the loss of multiple genes, making it challenging to pinpoint a single tumor suppressor gene. Future work could focus on dissecting the contributions of individual genes within this region.
  • Isogenic Model Systems: The authors suggest that further studies in isogenic model systems are needed to test combinations of genetic events that interact with chr4p loss to confer a proliferative advantage.
  • Mechanism of Context-Dependency: While the context-dependent suppression of proliferation is observed, the precise molecular mechanisms underlying this phenomenon require further investigation.
  • Therapeutic Implications: The study provides a foundation for exploring therapeutic strategies targeting the PDCD10-GCKIII module or exploiting the vulnerabilities created by chr4p loss. Further research is needed to translate these findings into clinical applications.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The basal breast cancer subtype is enriched for triple-negative breast cancer (TNBC) and displays consistent large chromosomal deletions. Here, we characterize the evolution and maintenance of chromosome 4p (chr4p) loss in basal breast cancer. TCGA data analysis showed recurrent deletion of chr4p in basal breast cancer. Phylogenetic analysis of a unique panel of 23 primary tumor/patient-derived xenograft basal breast cancers revealed early evolution of chr4p deletion. Mechanistically we show that Chr4p loss is associated with enhanced proliferation. Gene function studies identified an unknown gene, C4orf19, within chr4p, which suppressed proliferation when overexpressed and is a novel member of a PDCD10-GCKIII kinase module, we name as PGCA1 . Genome-wide pooled overexpression screens using a barcoded library of human open reading frames, identified chromosomal regions, including chr4p, that suppress proliferation when overexpressed in a context-dependent manner implicating network interactions. Together this sheds light on the early emergence of complex aneuploid karyotypes involving chr4p and adaptive landscapes shaping breast cancer genomes.
BibTeX
@misc{kuzmin2023evolution,
  author = {Elena Kuzmin and Toby M. Baker and Tom Lesluyes and Jean Monlong and Kento T. Abe and Paula P. Coelho and Michael Schwartz and Dongmei Zou and Geneviève Morin and Alain Pacis and Yang Yang and Constanza Martínez and Jarrett Barber and Hellen Kuasne and Rui Li and Mathieu Bourgey and Anne-Marie Fortier and Peter Davison and Atilla Ömeroğlu and Marie-Christine Guiot and Quaid Morris and Claudia L. Kleinman and Sidong Huang and Anne‐Claude Gingras and Jiannis Ragoussis and Guillaume Bourque and Peter Van Loo and Morag Park},
  title = {{Evolution of chromosome arm aberrations in breast cancer through genetic network rewiring}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1101/2023.06.10.544434},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure