Evolution in Tencent’s Game Marketing Model under the Adolescent Model: Case Study of Arena of Valor

Bowen Dong, Boxiang Xiao, Hin YeungBCP 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper examines how Tencent’s flagship title, Arena of Valor (Honor of Kings), has adapted its marketing and operational strategies to comply with China’s increasingly strict "anti-addiction" regulations for minors. The authors argue that while the mandatory "Teen Model" has standardized play habits, it has also triggered unintended consequences like account-selling gray markets and a shift of domestic players to overseas servers.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Chinese gaming market is a behemoth, boasting over 600 million players and nearly 300 billion yuan in annual revenue. However, this growth has come with a significant social cost: youth game addiction. With approximately 122 million underage gamers in China (60% of the minor population), the government has implemented a "Teen Model" to strictly regulate playtime, duration, and content.

The authors tackle the dilemma faced by game operators: How can a company like Tencent actively respond to national policy and social resistance while maintaining a viable marketing model? They specifically look at the friction between aggressive product promotion and the ethical/regulatory necessity of protecting minors.

Methods

The researchers employ a Case Study Analysis focused on Arena of Valor (known domestically as Honor of Kings). To evaluate Tencent's strategy, they utilize the 6P Marketing Theory framework. While traditional marketing often focuses on the 4Ps (Product, Price, Place, Promotion), this study expands the scope to include:

  • Political Power: Navigating state regulations and national identity.
  • Public Relations: Managing social opinion and parental concerns.

The paper performs a multi-dimensional analysis of how these six factors interact under the constraints of the "anti-addiction system."

Datasets

The paper relies on a synthesis of secondary industry data and reports rather than a proprietary primary dataset. Key sources include:

  • Niko Partners: Data on the 122 million underage gamers in China.
  • Aurora Big Data: 2018 annual report data showing a 22.3% user penetration rate for Honor of Kings.
  • Sensor Tower: Revenue metrics (e.g., $268 million raked in during May 2022).
  • CNNIC (China Internet Network Information Center): Statistics on mobile device penetration among minors (82.9%).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Demonization" of History: A major point of contention is the game’s use of historical figures. By turning the poet Li Bai into an assassin or the politician Dee Renjie into an archer, Tencent risks "reversing history" in the eyes of educators and parents, potentially misleading minors.
  • The Promotion Paradox: Tencent promotes the game through its own social giants, WeChat and QQ. However, the "Teen Mode" on these platforms is often easy to bypass or remove, making the marketing efforts highly effective at reaching minors despite the intended restrictions.
  • The Educational Pivot: The authors suggest that games should move toward the "Minecraft" model—leveraging gameplay for education (e.g., spatial geometry, ecology) to reduce social resistance.
  • Gray Market Emergence: Strict time limits have inadvertently fueled a "gray industry" of buying and selling adult-verified accounts, allowing minors to circumvent the system.

Key Results

  • Demographic Shifts: Surprisingly, the game has a higher proportion of female gamers (54.1%) than male gamers (45.9%), with 22.2% of the total player base being minors.
  • Revenue Resilience: Despite regulatory pressure, the game remains a financial powerhouse, with the Chinese iOS market accounting for 95% of its global revenue.
  • Systemic Impact: The "Teen Model" has successfully standardized play habits for many, but the authors note it has also caused an "influx of target customers into the overseas game market" to avoid domestic restrictions.
  • Social Litigation: The paper highlights the 2021 lawsuit by the Beijing Youth Legal Aid and Research Center against Tencent, marking a shift where public interest organizations are now using the legal system to enforce corporate responsibility.

Limitations and Future Work

The paper is primarily a qualitative analysis and lacks granular, internal data from Tencent regarding the specific revenue impact of the "Teen Model" implementation.

Future Directions suggested by the authors include: * Technical Hardening: Moving beyond simple timers to using big data and "second face recognition" tests to detect minors using adult accounts. * Original IP Development: Moving away from "demonizing" historical figures toward creating original "IP universes" (similar to League of Legends or NetEase’s Onmyoji) to avoid cultural controversy. * Collaborative Governance: Shifting the burden of anti-addiction from just the enterprise to a "supporting role" that empowers parents and schools through better data transparency.

Summary updated

Abstract

China is the most promising game market in the world. However, with the development of the game industry, the Chinese market is facing a severe problem - the problem of addiction to games among the youth group. The issue of youth game addiction has become a problem that cannot be ignored in society. How game operators should actively respond to the national policy and simultaneously cope with the social resistance to games is the first problem that needs to be solved. Based on the above background, this study selects a typical case in China’s game market-Wang’s Glory-for multi-dimensional analysis. This study argues that introducing the youth mode has greatly standardized minors’ play modes and habits. With the launch of the youth model, indirect problems such as buying and selling accounts and the influx of many target customers into the overseas game market have arisen.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{dong2023evolution,
  author = {Bowen Dong and Boxiang Xiao and Hin Yeung},
  title = {{Evolution in Tencent’s Game Marketing Model under the Adolescent Model: Case Study of Arena of Valor}},
  booktitle = {BCP},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.54691/bcpbm.v38i.4087},
}
Figure