Evidencing Fast, Massive, and Reversible H+ Insertion in Nanostructured TiO2 Electrodes at Neutral pH. Where Do Protons Come From?

Yee‐Seul Kim, Sébastien Kriegel, Kenneth D. Harris, Cyrille Costentin, Benoı̂t Limoges, Véronique BallandThe Journal of Physical Chemistry C 2017 · DOI

Introduction: The Quest for Green Aqueous Batteries

Titanium dioxide (TiO₂) has long been a cornerstone of materials science, valued for its low cost, minimal toxicity, and exceptional stability. While its applications in solar cells and lithium-ion batteries are well-documented, a significant shift is underway toward "green" aqueous (water-based) batteries. These systems promise safer, more sustainable alternatives to organic-solvent-based technologies. However, a major chemical hurdle remains: TiO₂ typically requires either organic solvents or highly acidic environments (pH < 2) to facilitate efficient charge storage through ion insertion.

At neutral pH, the concentration of free protons is vanishingly low ($10^{-7}$ M). This scarcity makes it difficult for the material to "find" enough protons to store significant charge, often limiting the performance of TiO₂ in safe, neutral-pH electrolytes. Researchers recently set out to determine if nanostructured TiO₂ could overcome this limitation and, crucially, identify the source of protons when the water itself is an insufficient donor.

Engineering the Electrode: GLAD and Amorphous TiO₂

To address these challenges, the research team employed a specialized fabrication technique known as Glancing Angle Deposition (GLAD). This method allowed for the creation of 1 μm thick films composed of amorphous TiO₂ nanorods. By growing the material as a "forest" of nanostructures rather than a dense film, the researchers created a massive surface area and an open, porous architecture. This structure is vital for high-rate applications, as it allows ions to move freely throughout the electrode volume.

The choice of an amorphous (disordered) structure over a crystalline one was intentional. Crystalline materials often possess rigid boundaries that can impede ion transport or suffer from structural strain during the expansion and contraction of charging cycles. The disordered nature of amorphous TiO₂ likely facilitates more rapid proton movement and better accommodates the mechanical stress of massive ion insertion.

Decoupling Charge: Cyclic Voltabsorptometry

Analyzing the charging process in such complex nanostructures requires more than standard electrochemical tools. The team utilized cyclic voltabsorptometry, a technique that merges traditional electrochemistry (measuring current) with optical spectroscopy (measuring light absorption).

As TiO₂ absorbs electrons and protons, it undergoes a visible color change, turning blue/black. By monitoring this optical change in real-time, the researchers could distinguish between two distinct charge storage mechanisms:

  1. Surface Capacitance: Electrical double-layer storage occurring at the interface.
  2. Faradaic Intercalation: Deep-material charging where protons are coupled with electrons and inserted into the bulk of the TiO₂.

This optical "window" into the material proved that the majority of the stored charge was not just sitting on the surface but was moving deep into the nanorod bulk.

The Neutral pH Breakthrough: Buffers as Proton Shuttles

The study's most striking revelation concerns the mechanism of proton delivery at neutral pH. The researchers evidenced that the intercalated protons do not originate from the water molecules themselves, which are poor proton donors at pH 7. Instead, the protons are provided by the acidic form of the buffer—in this study, HEPES.

The buffer acts as a "proton shuttle," effectively delivering H⁺ ions directly to the electrode surface. This allows the system to achieve massive storage levels previously thought impossible outside of strongly acidic conditions. Even at neutral pH, the material achieved an intercalation ratio of 20%, meaning one proton was inserted for every five titanium atoms.

Protons vs. Lithium: A Speed Comparison

Beyond capacity, the study highlighted a significant kinetic advantage for proton-based systems. When comparing proton insertion to lithium-ion (Li⁺) insertion in identical GLAD-produced films, the researchers found that protons diffuse 20 to 100 times faster than lithium ions.

While Li⁺ intercalation is the standard for modern portable electronics, its relatively slow diffusion limits the power density of batteries. The rapid movement of protons in amorphous TiO₂ suggests that H⁺-coupled systems could charge and discharge in a matter of seconds, opening the door to high-power energy storage devices that rival the speed of supercapacitors while maintaining the energy density of batteries.

Quantitative Results and Future Directions

The experimental results underscore the potential of this approach:

  • Total Capacity: The electrodes reached a total charge capacity of 310 C/g.
  • Charge Distribution: Optical deconvolution revealed that 77% of the stored charge results from faradaic bulk insertion, with only 23% attributed to surface capacitance.
  • Diffusion Kinetics: The apparent solid-state diffusion coefficient for protons in the TiO₂ lattice was estimated at approximately $10^{-15} \text{ cm}^2/\text{s}$.

Despite these promising results, challenges remain. The researchers noted "irreversible failure" when the electrodes were pushed to extreme potentials, likely due to the structural collapse of the nanorods. Additionally, the system's performance is highly sensitive to the specific buffer used. Future research must focus on optimizing buffer chemistry for industrial scales and integrating these high-performance cathodes with suitable anodes to create a fully functional, eco-friendly aqueous battery.

Summary updated

Abstract

Ongoing developments of sustainable energy technologies based on high-surface-area semiconductive metal oxide electrodes operating under mild and safe aqueous conditions require deep understanding of proton and electron transfer/transport throughout their porous structure. To address this issue, we investigated the electrochemical reductive protonation of high surface area nanostructured amorphous TiO2 electrodes (produced by glancing angle deposition) in both buffered and unbuffered aqueous solutions. Quantitative analysis of the two charge storage mechanisms was achieved, allowing proper deconvolution of the electrical double-layer capacitive charge storage from the reversible faradaic one resulting from the proton-coupled reduction of bulk TiO2. We evidence that this latter process occurs reversibly and extensively (up to an intercalation ratio of 20%) not only under strongly acidic pH conditions but also, more interestingly, under neutral pH with the intercalated proton arising from the buffer rather than water. Moreover, we show that in comparison with reductive Li+ intercalation the proton-coupled electron charge storage occurs more rapidly (in a few seconds). This important finding suggests that a high-rate and high-power charge storage device could potentially be achieved with the reversible H+-coupled charge/discharge process in TiO2 at neutral pH, opening thus new opportunities to the development of eco-friendly batteries for electrical energy storage.
BibTeX
@article{kim2017evidencing,
  author = {Yee‐Seul Kim and Sébastien Kriegel and Kenneth D. Harris and Cyrille Costentin and Benoı̂t Limoges and Véronique Balland},
  title = {{Evidencing Fast, Massive, and Reversible H<sup>+</sup> Insertion in Nanostructured TiO<sub>2</sub> Electrodes at Neutral pH. Where Do Protons Come From?}},
  journal = {The Journal of Physical Chemistry C},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1021/acs.jpcc.7b02395},
}
Figure