Evidence of progressive tissue loss in the core of chronic MS lesions: A longitudinal DTI study

Alexander Klistorner, Chenyu Wang, Con Yiannikas, Nevin John, Michael G. Dwyer, Joshua Barton, Stuart L. Graham, Yuyi You, Sidong Liu, Michael BarnettNeuroImage 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses diffusion tensor imaging (DTI) to show that chronic Multiple Sclerosis (MS) lesions aren't static but actively lose tissue over time, particularly in males. This progressive tissue loss, measured by increased water diffusion, is linked to brain atrophy and suggests a need for therapies that can halt or reverse this ongoing damage.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Multiple Sclerosis (MS) is a chronic inflammatory disease of the central nervous system (CNS) that leads to irreversible neurological disability. While acute inflammation and demyelination are known drivers of damage, the fate of chronic, stable MS lesions has been less clear. Are these lesions simply scars, or do they continue to degrade over time? Understanding this is crucial for developing effective treatments. Previous longitudinal studies on chronic MS lesions have been limited by short follow-up periods, small sample sizes, and sometimes contradictory results. This paper aims to address this by using DTI to longitudinally track changes within chronic MS lesions and surrounding white matter in a substantial cohort of patients with relapsing-remitting MS (RRMS) over a significant period.

Methods

The researchers employed Diffusion Tensor Imaging (DTI), a neuroimaging technique that measures the diffusion of water molecules in the brain. Water diffusion is anisotropic (direction-dependent) in white matter due to the organized structure of axons and myelin. DTI can detect changes in this diffusion pattern, which can reflect alterations in tissue microstructure.

Key techniques used:

  • Longitudinal DTI acquisition: DTI scans were acquired from 55 RRMS patients at baseline and again approximately 42 months later.
  • Region of Interest (ROI) analysis: Specific regions were defined:
  • Lesion Core: The central part of chronic T2 lesions, identified by shrinking the lesion mask. This was done to isolate the effect of chronic inflammation and potential remyelination at the lesion edge.
  • Peri-lesional White Matter (PLWM): Areas immediately surrounding the lesion core, including a "rim" and two expanding shells.
  • Normal Appearing White Matter (NAWM): Areas of white matter that appeared normal on conventional MRI, sampled from the corpus callosum.
  • Diffusion Metrics: Standard DTI metrics were calculated:
  • Axial Diffusivity (AD): Diffusion parallel to the main fiber orientation.
  • Radial Diffusivity (RD): Diffusion perpendicular to the main fiber orientation.
  • Mean Diffusivity (MD): The average of AD and RD, a directionally independent measure.
  • Fractional Anisotropy (FA): A measure of the degree of anisotropy.
  • Statistical Analysis: Paired t-tests were used to compare baseline and follow-up measures. Pearson correlation coefficients were used to assess relationships between variables. A General Linear Model was used to analyze the effect of various factors on lesional diffusivity change.
  • Brain Atrophy Measurement: Lateral Ventricular Volume (LVV) was measured using the NeuroSTREAM technique to estimate brain atrophy, as conventional T1-based methods were affected by slight changes in image resolution over time.

Datasets

The study utilized data from:

  • 55 consecutive patients with Relapsing-Remitting Multiple Sclerosis (RRMS).
  • 20 age- and gender-matched healthy control subjects.

The data included pre- and post-gadolinium T1-weighted images, FLAIR CUBE images, and whole-brain diffusion-weighted imaging acquired at two time points (baseline and ~42 months later).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Chronic lesions are not static: The most striking finding is that chronic, stable MS lesions are not just passive scars but actively undergo tissue destruction over time. This challenges the notion that damage is solely an acute inflammatory event.
  • Progressive tissue loss is isotropic: The increase in water diffusion within the lesion core was largely isotropic (meaning it increased equally in all directions). This suggests a general breakdown of tissue structure rather than a specific directional change, which might be expected from, for example, Wallerian degeneration.
  • MD is a robust marker of chronic change: The study highlights the utility of Mean Diffusivity (MD) as a reliable indicator of microstructural change in chronic MS lesions, especially when dealing with complex white matter fiber arrangements.
  • Link between lesion progression and brain atrophy: The rate of tissue loss within lesions was significantly correlated with progressive brain atrophy (measured by ventricular enlargement). This suggests that ongoing neurodegeneration within lesions contributes to overall brain shrinkage.
  • Gender disparity in lesion progression: Males showed a significantly more pronounced increase in MD within lesions compared to females. This points to potential sex-based differences in MS pathology and progression.
  • NAWM remains stable: In contrast to the lesions, the normal-appearing white matter (NAWM) showed no significant changes in diffusivity over the follow-up period, reinforcing that the observed changes are localized to the lesions and their immediate surroundings.

Key Results

  • Significant increase in lesion core MD: Mean Diffusivity (MD) in the core of chronic MS lesions increased significantly from baseline (1.29 ± 0.19 µm²/ms) to follow-up (1.34 ± 0.20 µm²/ms), with a P-value < 0.0001. This represents an annual change of approximately 0.93%.
  • No change in NAWM diffusivity: Diffusivity indices in Normal Appearing White Matter (NAWM) remained stable over the follow-up period (P = 0.8).
  • MD increase linked to brain atrophy: A significant correlation was found between the increase in Lateral Ventricular Volume (LVV) and the increase in lesional MD (r = 0.47, P = 0.002).
  • Gender difference in MD change: Male patients exhibited almost twice the MD change in lesion cores compared to female patients (0.058 ± 0.03 µm²/ms vs. 0.030 ± 0.04 µm²/ms, P = 0.01).
  • Gradual diffusion increase from core to PLWM: The largest MD increase was observed in the lesion core, with a gradual decline in progression towards the peri-lesional white matter (PLWM).
  • PLWM shows small but significant MD increase: While smaller than in the lesion core, MD also increased significantly in the peri-lesional white matter (PLWM) over time.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations: * Unknown lesion age: The exact age of individual chronic lesions could not be determined, making it difficult to precisely correlate baseline tissue damage with longitudinal changes. * Lack of longitudinal DTI in controls: While NAWM served as an internal control, a dedicated longitudinal DTI study in healthy controls would have provided a more direct comparison for age-related changes. * Small sample size for therapy analysis: The sample size precluded a detailed assessment of the impact of disease-modifying therapies on the observed changes. * Potential for subtle inflammation at lesion edge: The small but significant MD increase in PLWM could potentially reflect ongoing low-grade inflammation or micro-lesion expansion at the edge of chronic lesions.

Future Work: * Development of pro-remyelinating therapies: The evidence of progressive axonal loss in chronic lesions highlights the urgent need for therapies that can promote remyelination and protect axons. * Consideration of gender in clinical trials: The observed gender disparity suggests that clinical trials should account for sex-based differences when assessing treatment efficacy. * Importance of controlling for brain atrophy: Future longitudinal studies must rigorously control for the effects of brain atrophy to ensure accurate interpretation of lesion changes. * Further investigation into PLWM changes: More research is needed to fully understand the mechanisms driving the subtle but significant MD increase in peri-lesional white matter.

Summary updated

Abstract

The significant increase of isotropic water diffusion in the core of chronic stable MS lesions likely reflects gradual, self-sustained tissue destruction in demyelinated white matter that is more aggressive in males.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{klistorner2017evidence,
  author = {Alexander Klistorner and Chenyu Wang and Con Yiannikas and Nevin John and Michael G. Dwyer and Joshua Barton and Stuart L. Graham and Yuyi You and Sidong Liu and Michael Barnett},
  title = {{Evidence of progressive tissue loss in the core of chronic MS lesions: A longitudinal DTI study}},
  booktitle = {NeuroImage},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1016/j.nicl.2017.12.010},
}
Figure