Evidence of initial success for China exiting COVID-19 social distancing policy after achieving containment

Kylie E. C. Ainslie, Caroline E. Walters, Han Fu, Sangeeta Bhatia, Haowei Wang, Xiaoyue Xi, Marc Baguelin, Samir Bhatt, Adhiratha Boonyasiri, Olivia Boyd, Lorenzo Cattarino, Constanze Ciavarella, Zulma M. Cucunubá, Gina Cuomo-Dannenburg, Amy Dighe, Ilaria Dorigatti, Sabine van Elsland, Richard G. FitzJohn, Katy A. M. Gaythorpe, Azra C. Ghani, William D. Green, Arran Hamlet, Wes Hinsley, Natsuko Imai, David Jorgensen, Edward Knock, Daniel J. Laydon, Gemma Nedjati‐Gilani, Lucy Okell, Igor Siveroni, Hayley A Thompson, H. Juliette T. Unwin, Robert Verity, Michaela Vollmer, Patrick Walker, Yuanrong Wang, Oliver J. Watson, Charles Whittaker, Peter Winskill, Christl A. Donnelly, Neil M. Ferguson, Steven RileyWellcome 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the relationship between social distancing measures, economic activity (proxied by movement data), and COVID-19 transmission in China. It finds that while initially correlated, movement and transmission became decoupled as China eased restrictions, suggesting this decoupling is a key indicator of successful exit strategies from lockdowns.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As the COVID-19 pandemic unfolded, governments worldwide implemented strict social distancing and lockdowns to curb transmission. However, these measures had severe economic consequences. A critical question emerged: how could countries safely ease these restrictions and restart their economies without triggering a resurgence of the virus? This paper tackles this by examining China's experience, specifically looking at whether a return to economic activity (measured by people's movement) could occur independently of a rise in COVID-19 transmission.

Methods

The researchers used daily reported COVID-19 case data from mainland China and Hong Kong, along with daily within-city movement data as a proxy for economic activity. They employed the EpiEstim R package to estimate the effective reproduction number ($R_t$), which measures transmissibility over time. The core of their analysis involved calculating rolling correlations between $R_t$ and movement data for different regions. They also performed sensitivity analyses to understand the impact of different lag times between movement and transmission.

Datasets

  • COVID-19 Case Data: Daily reported confirmed cases from mainland China (by province) and Hong Kong SAR, sourced from the Chinese Center for Disease Prevention and Control (CCDC) dashboard.
  • Movement Data: Daily within-city movement indices for major metropolitan cities in mainland China, Hong Kong SAR, and Macau SAR, provided by Exante Data Inc. This data is based on near real-time people movement statistics from Baidu and is measured relative to 2019 averages.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Decoupling is Key: The most significant insight is that a successful exit from lockdown isn't just about reducing cases, but about achieving a state where people can move and economic activity can resume without a corresponding increase in transmission. This "decorrelation" is the crucial takeaway.
  • Initial Correlation is Expected: During the strict lockdown phase, it's natural for movement and transmission to be highly correlated. As people stay home, both decrease.
  • China's Gradual Reopening: The study highlights that China managed to increase movement and restart economic activity to a degree without immediately seeing a surge in new cases, indicating a degree of success in their exit strategy.
  • Hong Kong's Different Approach: Hong Kong's experience, with intermediate levels of activity and no large outbreak, offers a contrasting but also successful model, suggesting that a complete lockdown isn't the only path.

Key Results

  • Strong Initial Correlation: In the early stages of the epidemic and during strict lockdowns in China, within-city movement and transmission ($R_t$) were strongly positively correlated.
  • Correlation Diminishes: As China eased restrictions and movement increased, this correlation rapidly decreased. Towards the end of the study period, the correlation was no longer apparent, even with substantial increases in movement.
  • No Large Outbreak in Hong Kong: Hong Kong maintained intermediate levels of local activity while avoiding a large outbreak, demonstrating an alternative to strict lockdowns.
  • Up-tick with Reintroduction: A slight increase in transmission was observed towards the end of the study period, coinciding with the re-introduction of cases from Europe and the US, suggesting that imported cases remain a risk.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Correlation vs. Causation: The authors acknowledge that their analysis demonstrates correlation, not causation. While movement undoubtedly influences transmission, the study doesn't definitively prove causality.
  • Data Limitations: The analysis is limited by the availability of daily case data, which has reporting delays. The estimates of $R_t$ might be biased if the proportion of detected cases varied significantly over time.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests that monitoring the decorrelation between movement and transmission is a crucial goal for countries planning to emerge from lockdowns. Future work could involve extending this analysis to later time periods and other countries to further validate these findings. The authors also note the difficulty in parsing complex figures and suggest potential improvements for visualization.

Summary updated

Abstract

<b>Background</b>: The COVID-19 epidemic was declared a Global Pandemic by WHO on 11 March 2020. By 24 March 2020, over 440,000 cases and almost 20,000 deaths had been reported worldwide. In response to the fast-growing epidemic, which began in the Chinese city of Wuhan, Hubei, China imposed strict social distancing in Wuhan on 23 January 2020 followed closely by similar measures in other provinces. These interventions have impacted economic productivity in China, and the ability of the Chinese economy to resume without restarting the epidemic was not clear. <b>Methods</b>: Using daily reported cases from mainland China and Hong Kong SAR, we estimated transmissibility over time and compared it to daily within-city movement, as a proxy for economic activity. <b>Results</b>: Initially, within-city movement and transmission were very strongly correlated in the five mainland provinces most affected by the epidemic and Beijing. However, that correlation decreased rapidly after the initial sharp fall in transmissibility. In general, towards the end of the study period, the correlation was no longer apparent, despite substantial increases in within-city movement. A similar analysis for Hong Kong shows that intermediate levels of local activity were maintained while avoiding a large outbreak. At the very end of the study period, when China began to experience the re-introduction of a small number of cases from Europe and the United States, there is an apparent up-tick in transmission. <b>Conclusions:</b> Although these results do not preclude future substantial increases in incidence, they suggest that after very intense social distancing (which resulted in containment), China successfully exited its lockdown to some degree. Elsewhere, movement data are being used as proxies for economic activity to assess the impact of interventions. The results presented here illustrate how the eventual decorrelation between transmission and movement is likely a key feature of successful COVID-19 exit strategies.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ainslie2020evidence,
  author = {Kylie E. C. Ainslie and Caroline E. Walters and Han Fu and Sangeeta Bhatia and Haowei Wang and Xiaoyue Xi and Marc Baguelin and Samir Bhatt and Adhiratha Boonyasiri and Olivia Boyd and Lorenzo Cattarino and Constanze Ciavarella and Zulma M. Cucunubá and Gina Cuomo-Dannenburg and Amy Dighe and Ilaria Dorigatti and Sabine van Elsland and Richard G. FitzJohn and Katy A. M. Gaythorpe and Azra C. Ghani and William D. Green and Arran Hamlet and Wes Hinsley and Natsuko Imai and David Jorgensen and Edward Knock and Daniel J. Laydon and Gemma Nedjati‐Gilani and Lucy Okell and Igor Siveroni and Hayley A Thompson and H. Juliette T. Unwin and Robert Verity and Michaela Vollmer and Patrick Walker and Yuanrong Wang and Oliver J. Watson and Charles Whittaker and Peter Winskill and Christl A. Donnelly and Neil M. Ferguson and Steven Riley},
  title = {{Evidence of initial success for China exiting COVID-19 social distancing policy after achieving containment}},
  booktitle = {Wellcome},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.12688/wellcomeopenres.15843.1},
}
Figure