Evidence for b → d γ transitions from a sum of exclusive final states in the hadronic final state mass range 1.0GeV/c2 < M(X d) < 1.8GeV/c2
B. Aubert, M. Bóna, D. Boutigny, Y. Karyotakis, J. P. Lees, V. Poireau, X. Prudent, V. Tisserand, A. Zghiche, J. Garra Tico, E. Graugés, L. Lopez, A. Palano, M. Pappagallo, G. Eigen, B. Stugu, L. Sun, G. S. Abrams, M. Battaglia, D. N. Brown, J. Button‐Shafer, R. N. Cahn, Y. Groysman, R. G. Jacobsen, J. A. Kadyk, L. T. Kerth, Yu. G. Kolomensky, G. Kukartsev, D. Lopes Pegna, G. Lynch, L. M. Mir, T. J. Orimoto, I. L. Osipenkov, M. T. Ronan, K. Tackmann, T. Tanabe, W. A. Wenzel, P. del Amo Sanchez, C. M. Hawkes, A. T. Watson, H. Koch, T. Vazquez Schroeder, D. Walker, D. J. Asgeirsson, T. Çuhadar-Dönszelmann, B. G. Fulsom, C. Hearty, T. S. Mattison, J. A. McKenna, A. Khan, M. Saleem, L. Teodorescu, V. E. Blinov, A. D. Bukin, В. П. Дружинин, V. B. Golubev, A. P. Onuchin, S. I. Serednyakov, Yu. I. Skovpen, E. P. Solodov, K. Yu. Todyshev, M. Bondioli, S. Curry, I. Eschrich, D. Kirkby, A. J. Lankford, P. Lund, M. Mandelkern, E. C. Martin, D. P. Stoker, S. Abachi, C. Buchanan, S. D. Foulkes, J. W. Gary, F. Liu, O. Long, B. C. Shen, G. M. Vitug, L. Zhang, H. P. Paar, S. Rahatlou, V. Sharma, J. W. Berryhill, C. Campagnari, Ana Luiza Noronha da Cunha, B. Dahmes, T. M. Hong, D. Kovalskyi, J. D. Richman, T. W. Beck, A. M. Eisner, C. J. Flacco, C.a. Heusch, J. Kroseberg, W. S. Lockman, T. Schalk, B. A. Schumm, A. Seiden, M. G. Wilso, L. O. WinstromarXiv2007 · arXiv
We present preliminary results of a search for $B \to X_d\gamma$ decays with a hadronic mass $1.0 \text{ GeV}/c^2 < M(X_d) < 1.8 \text{ GeV}/c^2$. We consider seven final states with up to four charged pions and one neutral pion or $\eta$, which correspond to about 50% of the total $X_d$ fragmentation in this mass range. Based on a sample of 383 million $B\bar{B}$ events collected by the BaBar experiment at PEP-II, we measure a partial branching fraction $\sum_{i=1}^{7} \mathcal{B}(B \to X_{d,i}\gamma)|(1.0 \text{ GeV}/c^2 < M(X_d) < 1.8 \text{ GeV}/c^2) = (3.1 \pm 0.9 \pm 0.6 \pm 0.5) \times 10^{-6}$, where the uncertainties are statistical, systematic, and model-dependent respectively.
Introduction
In the Standard Model (SM) of particle physics, Flavor-Changing Neutral Currents (FCNCs) are processes where a quark changes its flavor without changing its electrical charge (e.g., a bottom quark $b$ transitioning into a down quark $d$). These transitions are forbidden at the tree level and can only occur through higher-order loop diagrams, commonly referred to as "penguin diagrams."
Feynman diagram of a $b \to d \gamma$ transition via a W-boson loop (penguin diagram).
While the $b \to s\gamma$ transition is well-documented, the $b \to d\gamma$ transition is significantly rarer—approximately 20 times less frequent—due to suppression by the Cabbibo-Kobayashi-Maskawa (CKM) matrix. Previous experimental efforts focused on low-mass resonances like the $\rho$ or $\omega$ mesons. This study targets the previously unexplored hadronic mass range of $1.0$ to $1.8 \text{ GeV}/c^2$ to provide a more comprehensive measurement of the $b \to d\gamma$ rate.
Experimental Methods
The BABAR Collaboration employed a semi-inclusive approach to identify these rare decays. Rather than attempting to reconstruct every possible final state, the team focused on seven specific exclusive pathways involving combinations of charged pions ($\pi^\pm$), neutral pions ($\pi^0$), and eta ($\eta$) mesons. These states are estimated to represent roughly 50% of the total signal in the targeted mass range.
Key components of the analysis included:
Event Reconstruction: High-energy photons and meson candidates were identified using the BABAR detector's tracking and calorimetry systems.
Background Suppression: To filter out "continuum" background from $e^+e^-$ collisions, a Neural Network (NN) was utilized to distinguish the spherical topology of $B$ meson decays from the jet-like structure of background events.
Statistical Extraction: A two-dimensional maximum likelihood fit was performed on two kinematic variables: the energy-substituted mass ($m_{ES}$) and the energy difference ($\Delta E$).
Datasets and Simulation
The analysis utilized the full dataset from the BABAR experiment at the PEP-II storage ring, comprising 383 million $B\bar{B}$ pairs collected at the $\Upsilon(4S)$ resonance. Extensive Monte Carlo (MC) simulations were used to model signal shapes, background sources (such as $b \to s\gamma$ misidentification), and fragmentation processes using the JETSET model.
Results and Insights
The maximum likelihood fit yielded $178 \pm 53$ signal events, corresponding to a statistical significance of $3.1\sigma$ (including systematic uncertainties). In particle physics, this level of significance constitutes "evidence" for the process.
The measured partial branching fraction for the sum of the seven exclusive states is:
$$\mathcal{B} = (3.1 \pm 0.9_{\text{stat}} \pm 0.5_{\text{syst}} \pm 0.5_{\text{model}}) \times 10^{-6}$$
This result is consistent with Standard Model expectations. Furthermore, it provides a foundation for future, more precise determinations of the CKM matrix element ratio $|V_{td}/V_{ts}|$. Any significant deviation in this ratio in future measurements could indicate the presence of physics beyond the Standard Model.
Conclusion and Future Work
This study represents a significant step toward a fully inclusive measurement of the $b \to d\gamma$ transition. However, several challenges remain. The current measurement only covers about half of the expected final states in the $1.0–1.8 \text{ GeV}/c^2$ range, and the $13.6\%$ uncertainty from fragmentation modeling remains a primary bottleneck.
Future research at next-generation facilities like Belle II will aim to extend these measurements across the entire hadronic mass spectrum, potentially using "recoil" methods to reduce model dependence and provide a definitive test of the Standard Model's flavor sector.
Summary updated
Abstract
Author(s): Aubert, B; Bona, M; Boutigny, D; Karyotakis, Y; Lees, JP; Poireau, V; Prudent, X; Tisserand, V; Zghiche, A; Garra Tico, J; Grauges, E; Lopez, L; Palano, A; Pappagallo, M; Eigen, G; Stugu, B; Sun, L; Abrams, GS; Battaglia, M; Brown, DN; Button-Shafer, J; Cahn, RN; Groysman, Y; Jacobsen, RG; Kadyk, JA; Kerth, LT; Kolomensky, YG; Kukartsev, G; Lopes Pegna, D; Lynch, G; Mir, LM; Orimoto, TJ; Osipenkov, IL; Ronan, MT; Tackmann, K; Tanabe, T; Wenzel, WA; Del Amo Sanchez, P; Hawkes, CM; Watson, AT; Koch, H; Schroeder, T; Walker, D; Asgeirsson, DJ; Cuhadar-Donszelmann, T; Fulsom, BG; Hearty, C; Mattison, TS; McKenna, JA; Khan, A; Saleem, M; Teodorescu, L; Blinov, VE; Bukin, AD; Druzhinin, VP; Golubev, VB; Onuchin, AP; Serednyakov, SI; Skovpen, YI; Solodov, EP; Todyshev, KY; Bondioli, M; Curry, S; Eschrich, I; Kirkby, D; Lankford, AJ; Lund, P; Mandelkern, M; Martin, EC; Stoker, DP; Abachi, S; Buchanan, C; Foulkes, SD; Gary, JW; Liu, F; Long, O; Shen, BC; Vitug, GM; Zhang, L; Paar, HP; Rahatlou, S; Sharma, V; Berryhill, JW; Campagnari, C; Cunha, A | Abstract: We present preliminary results of a search for B → Xdγ decays with a hadronic mass 1.0 GeV/c2 l M(Xd) l 1.8 GeV/c2. We consider seven final states with up to four charged pions and one neutral pion or η, which correspond to about 50% of the total Xd fragmentation in this mass range. Based on a sample of 383 million B B events collected by the BaBar experiment at PEPII, we measure a partial branching fraction P7 Xd=1 B(B → Xdγ)|(1.0GeV/c2 l M(Xd) l 1.8GeV/c2) = (3.1±0.9+0.6 -0.5 ±0.5) · 10-6, where the uncertainties are statistical, systematic and model-dependent respectively.
BibTeX
@misc{aubert2007evidence,
author = {B. Aubert and M. Bóna and D. Boutigny and Y. Karyotakis and J. P. Lees and V. Poireau and X. Prudent and V. Tisserand and A. Zghiche and J. Garra Tico and E. Graugés and L. Lopez and A. Palano and M. Pappagallo and G. Eigen and B. Stugu and L. Sun and G. S. Abrams and M. Battaglia and D. N. Brown and J. Button‐Shafer and R. N. Cahn and Y. Groysman and R. G. Jacobsen and J. A. Kadyk and L. T. Kerth and Yu. G. Kolomensky and G. Kukartsev and D. Lopes Pegna and G. Lynch and L. M. Mir and T. J. Orimoto and I. L. Osipenkov and M. T. Ronan and K. Tackmann and T. Tanabe and W. A. Wenzel and P. del Amo Sanchez and C. M. Hawkes and A. T. Watson and H. Koch and T. Vazquez Schroeder and D. Walker and D. J. Asgeirsson and T. Çuhadar-Dönszelmann and B. G. Fulsom and C. Hearty and T. S. Mattison and J. A. McKenna and A. Khan and M. Saleem and L. Teodorescu and V. E. Blinov and A. D. Bukin and В. П. Дружинин and V. B. Golubev and A. P. Onuchin and S. I. Serednyakov and Yu. I. Skovpen and E. P. Solodov and K. Yu. Todyshev and M. Bondioli and S. Curry and I. Eschrich and D. Kirkby and A. J. Lankford and P. Lund and M. Mandelkern and E. C. Martin and D. P. Stoker and S. Abachi and C. Buchanan and S. D. Foulkes and J. W. Gary and F. Liu and O. Long and B. C. Shen and G. M. Vitug and L. Zhang and H. P. Paar and S. Rahatlou and V. Sharma and J. W. Berryhill and C. Campagnari and Ana Luiza Noronha da Cunha and B. Dahmes and T. M. Hong and D. Kovalskyi and J. D. Richman and T. W. Beck and A. M. Eisner and C. J. Flacco and C.A. Heusch and J. Kroseberg and W. S. Lockman and T. Schalk and B. A. Schumm and A. Seiden and M. G. Wilso and L. O. Winstrom},
title = {{Evidence for b → d γ transitions from a sum of exclusive final states in the hadronic final state mass range 1.0GeV/c2 < M(X d) < 1.8GeV/c2}},
year = {2007},
eprint = {0708.1652},
archivePrefix = {arXiv},
url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/0708.1652},
}