Evidence for a vestigial nematic state in the cuprate pseudogap phase

Sourin Mukhopadhyay, Rahul Sharma, Chung Koo Kim, Stephen Edkins, Mohammad Hamidian, Hiroshi Eisaki, Shin‐ichi Uchida, Eun-Ah Kim, Michael J. Lawler, A. P. Mackenzie, J. C. Davis, Kazuhiro FujitaProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents compelling evidence for a "vestigial nematic" state in the pseudogap phase of cuprate superconductors. By using advanced scanning tunneling microscopy, the authors demonstrate that two distinct broken-symmetry phases, the density-wave (DW) and nematic (NE) states, share a common characteristic energy that is directly linked to the pseudogap energy itself, suggesting a unified underlying mechanism.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cuprate superconductors, when doped with holes, enter a mysterious "pseudogap" (PG) phase characterized by a suppression of electronic states. Within this phase, two unusual broken-symmetry states have been observed: a density-wave (DW) state, which theoretically should open an energy gap, and a nematic (NE) state, which should not. The puzzle lies in the fact that the DW state appears without a clear energy gap opening at its transition temperature, while the NE state emerges at the pseudogap temperature and is theoretically incapable of opening a Fermi-surface gap. Furthermore, the ordering temperatures of these two states seem unrelated. This paper aims to resolve this perplexing phenomenology by proposing and providing evidence for a vestigial nematic state as the unifying explanation.

Methods

The core technique employed is sublattice-phase-resolved spectroscopic imaging scanning tunneling microscopy (SI-STM). This advanced method allows for the simultaneous imaging of electronic structure at the atomic scale, resolving the contributions from different atomic sites (Cu, O<sub>x</sub>, O<sub>y</sub>) within the CuO<sub>2</sub> unit cell. By performing Fourier analysis on these real-space images, the researchers can identify and characterize both the Q=0 nematic (NE) state and the finite-Q density-wave (DW) state. Specifically, they analyze the Bragg amplitudes to quantify nematicity and the power spectral density of the d-symmetry form factor to study the DW state. This allows for the simultaneous visualization and comparison of these two broken-symmetry states across various doping levels and energies.

Datasets

The study utilizes experimental data from underdoped Bi<sub>2</sub>Sr<sub>2</sub>CaCu<sub>2</sub>O<sub>8+δ</sub> samples with hole densities (p) ranging from 0.06 to 0.17. These samples were prepared and characterized by the authors. No external datasets were used for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Unified Energy Scale: The most striking finding is that both the DW and NE states exhibit their maximum spectral intensity at the same characteristic energy, which is consistently identified as the pseudogap energy (Δ*). This suggests that these seemingly distinct phenomena are governed by a common energy scale.
  • Vestigial Nematicity: The authors propose that the observed phenomenology can be explained by a "vestigial nematic" (VN) state. This state arises from a disordered, short-range DW that breaks translational symmetry but, due to disorder, does not establish long-range order. This disordered DW, however, still influences the electronic structure in a way that leads to a nematic-like breaking of rotational symmetry.
  • DW without a Gap, NE without a Gap-Opening: The VN hypothesis elegantly explains why the DW state appears without a new gap opening at its transition temperature (TDW) and why the NE state, which shouldn't open a gap, emerges at the pseudogap temperature (T). The underlying disordered DW has already opened a gap at T, and TDW is merely a detection threshold for the short-range DW modulations.
  • Intertwined Symmetries: The paper highlights how the breaking of two distinct symmetries (rotational for NE, translational for DW) are not independent but rather stem from a single microscopic origin – the disordered DW.

Key Results

  • The characteristic energy of maximum spectral intensity for both the NE state (E<sub>max</sub><sup>N</sup>) and the DW state (E<sub>max</sub><sup>D</sup>) are indistinguishable from each other across the studied doping range (0.06 ≤ p ≤ 0.17).
  • Both E<sub>max</sub><sup>N</sup>(p) and E<sub>max</sub><sup>D</sup>(p) follow a doping dependence that is indistinguishable from the independently measured pseudogap energy Δ*(p).
  • The onset temperatures for the NE (T<sub>NE</sub>) and DW (T<sub>DW</sub>) states appear unrelated and vary differently with doping, consistent with T<sub>DW</sub> being a detection threshold rather than a true phase transition.
  • No new energy gap opening is observed at the appearance of the DW state.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Discrimination of DW Type: The authors note that their current work, and the VN theory, does not discriminate between a conventional charge density wave (CDW) and a pair density wave (PDW) as the underlying microscopic mechanism for the DW state. Further experiments would be needed to distinguish between these possibilities.
  • Theoretical Refinement: While the VN hypothesis provides a strong framework, further theoretical development may be needed to fully capture all nuances of the observed phenomena, particularly concerning the precise role of disorder.
  • Broader Material Systems: The study focuses on Bi<sub>2</sub>Sr<sub>2</sub>CaCu<sub>2</sub>O<sub>8+δ</sub>. Future work could explore whether this vestigial nematic state is a universal feature of the cuprate pseudogap phase across other material families.

Summary updated

Abstract

The CuO<sub>2</sub> antiferromagnetic insulator is transformed by hole-doping into an exotic quantum fluid usually referred to as the pseudogap (PG) phase. Its defining characteristic is a strong suppression of the electronic density-of-states <i>D</i>(<i>E</i>) for energies |<i>E</i>| < [Formula: see text], where [Formula: see text] is the PG energy. Unanticipated broken-symmetry phases have been detected by a wide variety of techniques in the PG regime, most significantly a finite-<i>Q</i> density-wave (DW) state and a <i>Q</i> = 0 nematic (NE) state. Sublattice-phase-resolved imaging of electronic structure allows the doping and energy dependence of these distinct broken-symmetry states to be visualized simultaneously. Using this approach, we show that even though their reported ordering temperatures <i>T</i> <sub><i>DW</i></sub> and <i>T</i> <sub><i>NE</i></sub> are unrelated to each other, both the DW and NE states always exhibit their maximum spectral intensity at the same energy, and using independent measurements that this is the PG energy [Formula: see text] Moreover, no new energy-gap opening coincides with the appearance of the DW state (which should theoretically open an energy gap on the Fermi surface), while the observed PG opening coincides with the appearance of the NE state (which should theoretically be incapable of opening a Fermi-surface gap). We demonstrate how this perplexing phenomenology of thermal transitions and energy-gap opening at the breaking of two highly distinct symmetries may be understood as the natural consequence of a vestigial nematic state within the pseudogap phase of Bi<sub>2</sub>Sr<sub>2</sub>CaCu<sub>2</sub>O<sub>8</sub>.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{mukhopadhyay2019evidence,
  author = {Sourin Mukhopadhyay and Rahul Sharma and Chung Koo Kim and Stephen Edkins and Mohammad Hamidian and Hiroshi Eisaki and Shin‐ichi Uchida and Eun-Ah Kim and Michael J. Lawler and A. P. Mackenzie and J. C. Davis and Kazuhiro Fujita},
  title = {{Evidence for a vestigial nematic state in the cuprate pseudogap phase}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1073/pnas.1821454116},
}
Figure