Evidence and assessment of parenchymal patterns of ultrasonography for breast cancer detection among Chinese women: a cross-sectional study

Zhongtao Bao, Yanchun Zhao, Shuqiang Chen, Xiaoyu Chen, Xiang Xu, Linglin Wei, Ling ChenBMC Medical Imaging 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how different breast tissue patterns, as seen on ultrasound, correlate with breast cancer risk in Chinese women. Researchers found that "heterogeneous" and "fibrous" parenchymal patterns are significantly associated with a higher risk of breast cancer, suggesting ultrasound can be a valuable tool for risk assessment in this population.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Breast cancer is a significant health concern for women globally, including in China. While screening is crucial for early detection, existing risk assessment models may not be universally applicable, particularly for diverse populations like Chinese women. Ultrasound is a frequently used and cost-effective imaging modality in China for breast cancer detection, especially given that Chinese women tend to have denser breasts, which can reduce mammography's sensitivity. However, a deeper understanding of how specific ultrasound-visible breast tissue characteristics (parenchymal patterns) relate to breast cancer risk in this demographic is needed. This paper aims to bridge that gap by assessing these patterns and their association with cytopathological confirmed breast cancer.

Methods

The researchers conducted a retrospective cross-sectional study involving over 6,000 Chinese women who underwent breast ultrasound examinations. They categorized breast parenchymal patterns into four types based on ultrasound imaging characteristics:

  • Heterogeneous: Characterized by a high percentage of fatty tissues, with ductal diameters less than 50% of the breast mass.
  • Ductal: Defined by ductal diameters exceeding 50% of the breast mass, with a mesh-like hypoechoic structure.
  • Mixed: A combination where ductal diameters are 50% of the breast mass, featuring iso-echoic fibro-glandular tissue and hypoechoic ductal ingredients.
  • Fibrous: Described as a dense classification of the breast, with ductal diameters less than 50% of the breast mass, dense iso-echoic fibro-glandular tissue, and less hypoechoic ductal ingredients.

These classifications were made by seven experienced sonographer physicians. The study then compared the prevalence of these patterns between women with cytopathologically confirmed breast cancer and age-matched controls without confirmed cancer. Statistical analyses, including ANOVA and Fischer's exact test, were used to determine significant associations and odds ratios (OR). Inter-observer agreement among sonographers was also assessed using Cohen's kappa.

Datasets

The study utilized retrospective ultrasound examination data from 6,125 Chinese women collected between April 2015 and May 2019 from two hospitals in Fujian, China. The final analysis included 541 women with cytopathologically confirmed breast cancer and 849 age-matched women without confirmed breast cancer. No new benchmark datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Ultrasound Patterns as Risk Indicators: The study strongly suggests that specific ultrasound-identified breast parenchymal patterns are not just descriptive but can serve as indicators of breast cancer risk.
  • "Heterogeneous" and "Fibrous" as High-Risk: The "heterogeneous" and "fibrous" patterns emerged as significantly associated with a higher likelihood of having breast cancer. This is a crucial finding for risk stratification.
  • Population-Specific Associations: The findings highlight that these associations might be specific to the Chinese population, underscoring the need for tailored risk assessment tools.
  • Agreement Among Experts: While not perfect, the fair to good agreement among sonographers in categorizing these patterns indicates that the classification system is reasonably reproducible, which is essential for clinical application.

Key Results

  • Heterogeneous Pattern: Was found to be significantly higher in women with confirmed breast cancer (9% vs. 2%), with an odds ratio (OR) of 3.927 (95% CI: 2.327-6.627, p<0.0001).
  • Fibrous Pattern: Also showed a significantly higher prevalence in the confirmed cancer group (55% vs. 31%), with an OR of 2.702 (95% CI: 2.161-3.378, p<0.0001).
  • Ductal and Mixed Patterns: Did not show a significant difference in prevalence between the confirmed cancer and control groups.
  • Inter-Observer Agreement: Cohen's kappa for agreement among sonographer physicians was 0.591, indicating fair to good agreement.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Retrospective Design: The study's retrospective nature limits the ability to establish causality definitively.
  • Lack of Mammography Correlation: The study did not explore the correlation between ultrasound parenchymal patterns and mammographic patterns, which could provide a more comprehensive view.
  • Cost Consideration: The authors mention that adding mammography to ultrasound might increase costs for patients, influencing the choice of screening methods.
  • Single-Center Data: While data came from two hospitals, a broader, multi-center study could enhance generalizability.

Future work could involve prospective studies to confirm these findings, investigate the combined utility of ultrasound and mammography for risk assessment, and explore the underlying biological mechanisms linking these parenchymal patterns to cancer development. The study suggests that these findings have the potential to form the basis for breast cancer risk prediction models in Chinese women.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{bao2021evidence,
  author = {Zhongtao Bao and Yanchun Zhao and Shuqiang Chen and Xiaoyu Chen and Xiang Xu and Linglin Wei and Ling Chen},
  title = {{Evidence and assessment of parenchymal patterns of ultrasonography for breast cancer detection among Chinese women: a cross-sectional study}},
  journal = {BMC Medical Imaging},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1186/s12880-021-00687-0},
}
Figure