TL;DR
This study investigates water use in arid region maize cultivation using drip irrigation and mulch. By employing the SIMDualKc model, researchers quantified evapotranspiration (ETc), soil evaporation (Es), and plant transpiration (Tr), finding that mulch and strategic deficit irrigation significantly reduce water loss from soil evaporation, leading to higher water use efficiency.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Arid regions face severe water scarcity, making efficient agricultural water management crucial. Evapotranspiration (ETc), the combined process of soil evaporation (Es) and plant transpiration (Tr), is a major component of water loss in irrigated agriculture. While transpiration is essential for crop growth and yield, soil evaporation is considered "ineffective" water consumption. Accurately partitioning ETc into Es and Tr is vital for optimizing irrigation strategies. Traditional methods struggle with this partitioning, and understanding how water-saving techniques like drip irrigation under mulch and regulated deficit irrigation (RDI) impact this balance is critical for sustainable agriculture in water-stressed environments.
Methods
The researchers conducted a two-year field experiment in an arid region of Northwest China, comparing two irrigation treatments: full irrigation (T1) and strategic regulated deficit irrigation (T2). T2 involved reducing irrigation by 40% during the late vegetative and reproductive growth stages. They utilized the SIMDualKc model, a dual crop coefficient approach, to estimate daily ETc, Es, and Tr. This model was calibrated and validated using measured soil water content (SWC) and transpiration data. The study also incorporated drip irrigation under plastic film mulch, a common practice in the region, and adjusted model parameters to account for this.
Datasets
The study used meteorological data collected from an automatic weather station at the experimental site, including solar radiation, air temperature, relative humidity, and wind speed. Soil data, such as field capacity and wilting point, were also utilized. The primary datasets for model calibration and validation were:
- Soil Water Content (SWC): Measured using a neutron probe.
- Plant Transpiration (Tr): Measured using sap flowmeters.
The data collected over two growing seasons (2017 and 2018) served as the basis for model calibration and verification.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Mulch is a Game Changer for Soil Evaporation: The combination of drip irrigation and plastic film mulch significantly reduced soil evaporation (Es) compared to what might be expected with other irrigation methods. This highlights the effectiveness of mulch in conserving soil moisture.
- Strategic Deficit Irrigation Works (When Timed Right): Implementing regulated deficit irrigation (RDI) during specific growth stages (late vegetative and reproductive) successfully reduced overall water consumption without a proportional increase in ineffective soil evaporation. This suggests that RDI can be a powerful tool for water saving when applied strategically.
- SIMDualKc is a Reliable Tool for Partitioning: The SIMDualKc model proved adept at simulating the dynamic variations in soil water content and plant transpiration, validating its utility for accurately partitioning ETc into Es and Tr, even under challenging conditions like arid climates and mulch use.
- Transpiration Dominates Water Use: In both irrigation treatments, transpiration (Tr) accounted for the vast majority of evapotranspiration (ETc), consistently around 90%. This underscores the importance of maximizing plant water uptake for crop production.
- Canopy Cover is Key to Minimizing Evaporation: The study implies that achieving good canopy cover early in the growth stage is crucial. Once the ground is covered, deficit irrigation can be implemented without significantly increasing soil evaporation, as the canopy itself acts as a natural mulch.
Key Results
- ETc Reduction: The regulated deficit irrigation treatment (T2) resulted in a significant reduction in total evapotranspiration (ETc) compared to full irrigation (T1). ETc ranged from 507.9 to 519.1 mm for T1 and 428.9 to 430.9 mm for T2 over the two years.
- High Transpiration Ratio: The ratio of transpiration to evapotranspiration (Tr/ETc) was consistently high, around 90% for both treatments across both years, indicating efficient water use for crop growth.
- Reduced Soil Evaporation: The Es/ETc ratio was lower for T1 (6.3–6.8%) compared to T2 (10.1–10.2%). While T2 had a slightly higher proportion of Es, the overall ETc was lower, meaning the absolute amount of water lost to evaporation was still managed effectively due to the mulch.
- Model Performance: The SIMDualKc model demonstrated good performance in simulating soil water content and plant transpiration, with high R² values (0.84–0.97 for SWC, 0.91–0.97 for Tr) and low error metrics.
Limitations and Future Work
- Limited Scope of RDI: The study focused on RDI during specific late growth stages. Future work could explore the impact of RDI at different growth stages or combinations of stages.
- Incorporating Other Processes: The authors suggest that future research could improve ETc partitioning accuracy by incorporating soil water infiltration and root water uptake more dynamically, potentially using Richards' equation.
- Extending to Other Regions: While the methods are likely transferable, the specific calibrated crop coefficients might need adjustment for different climates, soil types, and maize varieties.
- Yield and Economic Analysis: The study focused on water use and partitioning. Future work could integrate these findings with crop yield and economic analyses to provide a more comprehensive assessment of the irrigation strategies.
Summary updated