TL;DR
This paper introduces a novel evaluation system for "zero-pollution villages" in China, inspired by the CASBEE framework, which quantifies both internal environmental quality (Q) and external environmental load (L). By combining Fuzzy Analytical Hierarchy Process (FAHP) and TOPSIS methods, they developed a robust weighting system to assess 76 indicators across 6 criteria, demonstrating its effectiveness in a case study of Zhejiang Province.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
China's rural revitalization strategy emphasizes creating ecologically livable environments, leading to the concept of "zero-pollution villages." However, a standardized and scientific evaluation system for these villages was lacking. Existing approaches often focused on agriculture-centric villages and overlooked the broader environmental impact on the surrounding areas. This paper addresses this gap by developing a comprehensive evaluation framework that considers both the internal quality of a village and its external environmental footprint, crucial for sustainable rural development.
Methods
The core of this research lies in the development of a novel evaluation system and a combined weighting methodology.
- Evaluation System: Inspired by the CASBEE (Comprehensive Assessment System for Built Environment Efficiency) principle, the system defines a village as an ecosystem. It establishes two main target strata: "Internal Environmental Quality (Q)" and "External Environmental Load (L)." This system is structured into four levels: 2 target layers, 6 criterion layers, 21 sub-criterion layers, and 76 detailed indicator layers.
- Combined Weighting Method (FAHP-TOPSIS): To determine the importance of each indicator, the researchers employed a hybrid approach.
- FAHP (Fuzzy Analytical Hierarchy Process): This method was used to capture subjective expert judgments and establish initial weights, addressing the inherent fuzziness in human decision-making. Experts were surveyed using a 0.1-0.9 scale for pairwise comparisons.
- TOPSIS (Technique for Order Preference by Similarity to an Ideal Solution): This objective method was integrated to adjust the weights based on expert credibility, considering factors like age, education, and professional familiarity. This combination aims to balance subjective expert insights with objective data analysis for more robust weighting.
Datasets
The study utilized data from:
- Expert Surveys: A questionnaire-based survey was administered to 40 experts from various disciplines (architecture, urban and rural planning, ecology, agriculture) to gather subjective judgments for the FAHP method.
- Field Surveys and Questionnaires: Data was collected from 26 villages in Zhejiang Province for the application and validation of the evaluation system.
- Existing Construction Guidelines: The evaluation system's results were compared against official guidelines for pollution-free villages in Zhejiang Province for validation.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Holistic Village Assessment: The paper moves beyond single-issue environmental assessments by integrating both internal village quality (Q) and external environmental impact (L) into a unified framework. This provides a more comprehensive picture of a village's sustainability.
- Bridging Subjective and Objective Weights: The FAHP-TOPSIS combination is a significant methodological contribution, offering a more nuanced and reliable way to assign indicator weights by incorporating both expert opinion and objective data correction.
- Importance of "External Load": The study highlights that while internal village environments may improve, the external environmental load remains a critical factor, underscoring the interconnectedness of rural ecosystems.
- Positional Title as a Key Expert Factor: Interestingly, the study found that "positional title" had the highest entropy weight among expert influencing factors, suggesting that professional standing plays a significant role in expert judgment, while "education" had the lowest.
Key Results
- Evaluation System Structure: A detailed system with 2 target layers, 6 criteria, 21 sub-criteria, and 76 indicators was successfully established.
- Weighting Results: In the external load (L), "waste" received a higher weight (0.512) than "resource consumption" (0.488), with industrial pollutant emissions being a key sub-criterion. For internal quality (Q), "living environment" (0.2705) was weighted highest, followed by "effective governance" (0.2512).
- Village Application:
- Three Typical Villages: Yuantou Village (Zone A, VEE=3.18) and Zhangluwan Village (Zone B, VEE=2.31) showed higher pollution-free degrees than Yang'ao Village (Zone C, VEE=1.16). This aligned with existing construction guidelines.
- 26 Villages Surveyed: 88.5% of the surveyed villages fell into Zone B (low-pollution), and 11.5% into Zone C (general pollution), indicating significant improvement but still short of the "zero-pollution" standard.
Limitations and Future Work
- Village Type Specificity: The current evaluation system may not be universally applicable to all types of villages due to variations in geography, climate, economic development, and industrial structures.
- Weight Accuracy: While adjustments were made based on expert knowledge, the weights represent relative values among surveyed experts, and further refinement is needed.
- Scope of Survey: The survey of 26 villages is a good start but does not fully capture the construction status across Zhejiang Province.
Future research should focus on expanding the research scope to include more diverse village types, further enhancing the accuracy of indicator weights, and potentially incorporating more objective data sources.
Summary updated