TL;DR
This paper introduces a comprehensive evaluation framework for smart and interactive landscape design in waterside parks, focusing on sustainability. By integrating environmental psychology, landscape ecology, and GIS, the study assesses the effectiveness of such designs in promoting ecological, social, and user experience benefits, offering practical guidance for future urban development.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
As cities become "smarter" and more sustainable, there's a growing demand for high-quality leisure experiences, particularly in urban parks. Waterside parks, being crucial ecological and recreational spaces, are prime candidates for integrating "smart" technologies. However, there's a lack of established frameworks to systematically evaluate the effectiveness and value of smart, interactive designs in these spaces from a sustainability perspective. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing and applying such a framework, considering the multifaceted needs of a sustainable city.
Methods
The study employs a multi-disciplinary approach, combining:
- Literature Review: To understand the concepts of smart cities, sustainable development, and intelligent interaction in landscape design.
- Framework Development: A hierarchical evaluation model was constructed using the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP). This involved:
- Identifying key evaluation criteria (e.g., safety, ecological sustainability, interactive experience) through expert consultation and literature review.
- Breaking down these criteria into specific indicators (programme layer).
- Determining the relative importance of these indicators through expert voting and pairwise comparisons.
- Calculating weights and performing consistency tests to ensure the reliability of the model.
- Empirical Case Study: The framework was applied to Haeundae Waterside Park in Busan, South Korea.
- Questionnaires: Distributed to visitors to gather subjective feedback on various indicators using a Likert scale.
- Data Analysis: Collected data was analyzed to calculate composite scores for each indicator and an overall score for the park.
- SWOT Analysis: Conducted for urban regeneration context of the case study.
Datasets
The primary data for evaluation was collected through:
- Paper and online questionnaires administered to visitors of Haeundae Waterside Park. A total of 300 questionnaires were collected.
- Satellite positioning maps and on-site research records for the case study area.
No new benchmark datasets were introduced; the study focused on evaluating an existing park.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Multidimensionality of Smart Parks: The study emphasizes that smart interactive parks are not just about technology but a holistic integration of ecological, social, and technological aspects to enhance user experience and promote sustainability.
- Prioritization of Factors: For waterside parks, safety and ecological sustainability emerged as the most critical evaluation factors, outweighing convenience and serviceability. This highlights the foundational importance of these aspects for public spaces.
- Bridging Theory and Practice: The research successfully translates theoretical concepts of smart interaction and sustainability into a practical evaluation framework, demonstrating its applicability to real-world urban regeneration projects.
- Waterside Parks as Microcosms: Waterside parks are identified as ideal testbeds for smart interactive design due to their unique ecological significance and high public engagement potential, offering a pathway to broader sustainable urban development.
- The Power of Integrated Design: The study underscores that successful smart interactive design requires a synergistic approach, combining environmental psychology, landscape ecology, and GIS to create spaces that are not only technologically advanced but also ecologically sound and socially beneficial.
Key Results
The evaluation of Haeundae Waterside Park yielded the following:
- Overall Score: The park received an overall score of 3.6897, categorized as "Good."
- Criterion Scores:
- Ecological Sustainability: Scored highest at 4.1204 ("Excellent").
- Safety: Scored 3.9256 ("Good").
- Humanistic Care: Scored 3.6961 ("Good").
- Service-Oriented: Scored 3.6692 ("Good").
- Convenience: Scored 3.6276 ("Good").
- Interactive Experience: Scored lowest at 3.5837 ("Good").
- Key Indicators: The study identified safety of spatial layout, accessibility of service facilities, and interactive experience of lighting as the top three factors influencing the smart interactive landscape.
- Policy Recommendations: The study proposes five policy recommendations, including standardizing smart facilities, integrating green technologies, building data-sharing platforms, enhancing visitor education, and establishing continuous monitoring mechanisms.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations:
- Data Scope and Depth: Questionnaire data was collected with limited scope and depth, potentially affecting accuracy due to tourist mobility and age structure.
- Indicator Specificity: Due to time and resource constraints, certain specific indicators (e.g., ecological adaptability of vegetation, age-group spatial experience) were not explored in depth.
- Case Study Limitation: The study was limited to a single waterside park, which, despite its typicality, may not fully represent the diversity of geographies, cultures, and management modes globally.
- Technological Evolution: The rapid development of smart technologies means that the selected technical evaluation criteria might become outdated.
Future research directions include:
- Expanding Scope: Applying the evaluation system to other types of urban public spaces (riverside green spaces, etc.) to test universality and optimize the framework.
- Enhanced Data Collection: Utilizing big data technology and intelligent sensing devices for more precise and dynamic data collection.
- Global Application: Exploring smart interactive landscape applications in different cultural and geographic contexts.
- Virtual Testing Platforms: Integrating AI and VR to create virtual testbeds for simulating sustainability performance and reducing trial-and-error costs.
- Policy and Public Engagement: Combining policy support with public participation to develop more practical sustainable landscape design models.
Summary updated