Evaluation Study on a Novel Structure CCHP System with a New Comprehensive Index Using Improved ALO Algorithm

Jie Ji, Fucheng Wang, Mengxiong Zhou, Renwei Guo, Rundong Ji, Hui Huang, Jiayu Zhang, Muhammad Shahzad Nazir, Peng Tian, Chu Zhang, Jiahui Huang, Yaodong WangSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel Combined Cooling, Heating, and Power (CCHP) system design for chemical enterprises, featuring improved components and energy storage. By employing an enhanced Ant Lion Optimization (ALO) algorithm, they optimize system capacity for better economic, energy, and environmental performance, achieving significant cost savings and emission reductions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The efficient utilization of energy is a critical challenge, especially in industrial settings like chemical enterprises. Traditional Combined Cooling, Heating, and Power (CCHP) systems often struggle to meet the unique and dynamic energy demands (cooling, heating, and power) of these facilities due to their complex production processes. This leads to suboptimal energy efficiency, higher costs, and increased environmental impact. The paper aims to address this by proposing a novel CCHP system structure and an advanced optimization method to configure its capacity effectively, ensuring it meets the specific needs of chemical plants while maximizing overall performance.

Methods

The core of this research lies in two main areas:

  • Novel CCHP System Structure: The authors propose an improved CCHP system design that incorporates multi-stage lithium bromide chillers and various energy storage devices. This aims to enhance the system's ability to handle fluctuating loads and improve energy recovery.
  • Improved Ant Lion Optimization (ALO) Algorithm: To determine the optimal capacity configuration for the proposed CCHP system, the researchers developed an enhanced ALO algorithm. This algorithm is designed to overcome the limitations of the standard ALO, such as premature convergence to local optima, by introducing a continuous contraction boundary and an increasing weight coefficient. This improved algorithm is used to optimize a comprehensive evaluation index that balances economic, energy, and environmental benefits.

Datasets

The study utilizes simulated load data for a chemical enterprise in the Huai'an area, representing typical daily cooling, heating, and power demands across summer, winter, and transition seasons. Photovoltaic (PV) output predictions were obtained using PVsyst software, based on meteorological data (solar irradiance and sunshine duration) for the region.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "One-Size-Fits-All" Problem: The paper highlights that standard CCHP systems are not ideal for specialized industrial loads like those in chemical plants, necessitating a tailored approach.
  • Synergy of Improved Components and Optimization: The combination of a novel system structure (multi-stage chillers, energy storage) and an advanced optimization algorithm (improved ALO) is crucial for achieving superior performance.
  • Comprehensive Evaluation is Key: Moving beyond single-objective optimization, the paper emphasizes the importance of a multi-faceted evaluation index (economic, energy, environmental) to truly assess system performance.
  • ALO Algorithm's Potential for Real-World Problems: The successful application of the improved ALO algorithm demonstrates its effectiveness in solving complex engineering optimization problems with dynamic and multi-objective constraints.

Key Results

The proposed novel CCHP system, optimized with the improved ALO algorithm, demonstrated significant improvements over typical CCHP systems:

  • Economic Benefits: Annual cost savings of up to 13%.
  • Environmental Benefits: Reduction in carbon dioxide emissions by up to 36.39%.
  • Energy Efficiency: Increase in primary energy utilization rate by up to 18%.
  • Overall Performance: The comprehensive evaluation index reached an optimal value of 0.814.
  • The system was shown to fully supply multi-loads with low cost and high efficiency across different seasons.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Simplification: The paper acknowledges that the energy storage modeling is "slightly rough" and its reliability was verified against a reference model.
  • Generalizability: While the study focuses on a chemical enterprise, further research could explore the applicability of this optimized CCHP system to other industrial sectors with different load characteristics.
  • Real-World Implementation: The study is based on simulation and modeling. Future work could involve the experimental validation and implementation of the proposed system in a real-world scenario.
  • Further Algorithm Refinement: While the improved ALO algorithm shows promise, continuous exploration of its parameters and potential further enhancements could lead to even better optimization results.

Summary updated

Abstract

The CCHP system is a reasonable and effective method to improve the current situation of energy use. Capacity allocation is of great significance in improving the performance of the CCHP system. Due to the particularity of chemical enterprises’ production process, the demand for cooling, heating, and power load is also relatively particular, which makes the dynamic loads challenging to be satisfied. Because of the above problems, the structure of the typical CCHP system is improved, embodied in the collocation of multi-stage lithium bromide chiller, and the use of various energy storage devices. Based on the improved ant lion intelligent optimization (ALO) algorithm, the comprehensive evaluation index coupled with energy benefit, economic benefit, and environmental benefit, is taken as the objective function, and the equipment capacity configuration of the CCHP system for chemical enterprises is studied. Considering winter, summer, and transition seasons, the results show that the system is better than the typical CCHP system. The annual cost savings of the new structural system are up to 13%, and the carbon dioxide emissions of the new structural system are reduced by up to 36.39%. The primary energy utilization rate of the new structure system is increased by 18%, and the comprehensive evaluation index also performs better. The optimal index can reach 0.814.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ji2022evaluation,
  author = {Jie Ji and Fucheng Wang and Mengxiong Zhou and Renwei Guo and Rundong Ji and Hui Huang and Jiayu Zhang and Muhammad Shahzad Nazir and Peng Tian and Chu Zhang and Jiahui Huang and Yaodong Wang},
  title = {{Evaluation Study on a Novel Structure CCHP System with a New Comprehensive Index Using Improved ALO Algorithm}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su142215419},
}
Figure