Evaluation of Urban Sustainability Based on Development Structures and Economic Aggregates: A Case Study of Jiaxing, China

Xufeng Zhang, Yanliang Liu, Akmaral Tleubergenova, Jinsong Liu, Rui Fan, Yun-En Tang, Xiang‐Zhou MengSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel method for evaluating urban sustainability by simultaneously considering development structures and economic aggregates, using emergy accounting. The study finds that while Jiaxing, China, exhibits high sustainability in its economic aggregates (driven by green GDP), its development structures are unsustainable due to over-reliance on ecosystem resources.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional urban sustainability assessments often focus on either development structures (e.g., natural, economic, social subsystems) or economic aggregates (e.g., GDP) in isolation. This approach fails to capture the complex interplay between how a city is built and how it functions economically, leading to an incomplete picture of its true sustainability. The authors argue that a comprehensive evaluation requires integrating both aspects, especially in rapidly urbanizing regions like China's Yangtze River Delta (YRD), where economic growth can come at a significant environmental cost. They aim to bridge this gap by developing a unified assessment framework.

Methods

The core of this study lies in the application of emergy accounting, a method that quantifies the total amount of solar energy required to produce goods and services. This allows for a unified comparison of diverse inputs and outputs within an urban system.

Key methodological components include:

  • Emergy Accounting: This framework quantifies renewable resources (R), nonrenewable resources (N), imports (I), exports (E), and waste (W) in terms of emergy. Unit emergy values (UEVs) are used to convert different forms of energy, matter, and currency into a common unit (solar emjoules, sej).
  • Quantification of Eco-Environmental Costs: This involves calculating the emergy needed to restore the urban ecosystem from damages caused by pollution and resource depletion. This includes:
  • Ecological Service Values: Estimating the emergy required for natural systems to dilute pollutants (e.g., water and air pollutants).
  • Natural Capital and Human Resources Losses: Using methods like the Potentially Disappeared Fraction (PDF) and Disability Adjusted Life Years (DALY) to quantify the emergy losses associated with species extinction and health impacts due to pollution.
  • Sustainability Evaluation System: The paper constructs a system of indicators that combine emergy-based metrics for both development structures and economic aggregates. This includes:
  • Development Structures: Indicators like the Environmental Loading Ratio (ELR), Waste Loading Ratio (WLR), Emergy Density (ED), Emergy per Person (EPP), Emergy Investment Ratio (EIR), Emergy Exchange Ratio (EER), and Emergy Sustainability Index (ESI).
  • Economic Aggregates: The study uses Green GDP, calculated by deducting eco-environmental costs from traditional GDP, to assess the sustainability of economic output.

Datasets

The study utilizes data from Jiaxing, China, for the period of 2005 to 2018. The raw data for input flows, output flows, and pollutants were collected from official statistical data and reports, including:

  • Jiaxing Statistical Yearbook
  • Zhejiang Statistical Yearbook
  • Jiaxing Water Resources Bulletin

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Dichotomy of Jiaxing's Sustainability: Jiaxing presents a classic case of rapid economic growth outpacing structural sustainability. While its economic engine is strong (high green GDP), the way it achieves this growth is environmentally taxing.
  • Emergy as a Unifying Metric: The paper effectively demonstrates how emergy accounting can integrate diverse environmental and economic factors into a single, comparable framework, offering a more holistic view than traditional metrics.
  • Green GDP as a More Nuanced Economic Indicator: By incorporating eco-environmental costs, Green GDP provides a more accurate reflection of economic sustainability than raw GDP, highlighting the true cost of development.
  • The Critical Role of Development Structures: The study emphasizes that even with strong economic performance, unsustainable development structures (particularly in the natural and economic subsystems) can undermine long-term urban viability.
  • Electricity and Wastewater as Key Stressors: The analysis pinpoints electricity consumption and wastewater discharge as significant factors impacting both the economic aggregates and development structures of Jiaxing, suggesting targeted areas for intervention.

Key Results

  • Economic Aggregates: Jiaxing shows high sustainability in its economic aggregates, evidenced by a significant increase in Green GDP (elevenfold from 2005 to 2018) and a rising proportion of Green GDP to total GDP (from 34.98% to 76.06%). This is attributed to industrial upgrading and resource conservation.
  • Development Structures: The sustainability of development structures is low. Indicators like the Environmental Loading Ratio (ELR) are significantly high (200-300), indicating a high environmental impact. The Emergy Sustainability Index (ESI) also shows low sustainability, though it has improved slightly in recent years due to pollution control measures.
  • Eco-Environmental Costs:
    • The emergy required for diluting water pollutants has decreased, but the demand for dilution still exceeds local water resources.
  • Emergy losses from air pollutants are significantly higher than from water pollutants, impacting both human resources and natural capital. Nitrogen oxides are a major contributor to natural capital loss.
  • Sensitivity Analysis: Green GDP is highly sensitive to changes in electricity use and wastewater discharge. A 20% increase in electricity use leads to a 15% increase in Green GDP, while a 20% increase in wastewater discharge leads to a 15% decrease.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Limitations: The study notes that emergy evaluation indicators based on eco-environmental costs could only be calculated from 2011 to 2018 due to data availability.
  • Focus on Jiaxing: While Jiaxing is presented as a model for the YRD, the findings might not be directly generalizable to all cities within the region without further comparative studies.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that cities in the YRD should adopt strategies focusing on industrial structure optimization, development model shifts, and improved management policies. They advocate for strengthening environmental governance, promoting low-carbon and circular economies, and enhancing public awareness and environmental management levels. The study also highlights the need for comprehensive analysis of environmental values and their contribution to economic activities to promote urban sustainability.

Summary updated

Abstract

Urban sustainability is the comprehensive manifestation of development structures and economic aggregates. The current sustainable evaluation of cities from a single aspect cannot comprehensively reflect urban sustainable development. Based on emergy, this study constructs an assessment method of urban sustainability from development structures and economic aggregates. Jiaxing is the case study explored as the sustainable development model of cities in the Yangtze River Delta (YRD) of China. High sustainability of economic aggregates is found in Jiaxing, which is driven by the growth of green GDP. However, the urban development of Jiaxing primarily depends on the input of ecosystem resources, which hinders the sustainability of development structures within Jiaxing. These findings indicate that economic aggregates drive the development of Jiaxing and that the development structures within Jiaxing are unsustainable, resulting from the low sustainability of the natural subsystem and the economic subsystem. As such, it is proposed that industrial structures, development models, and management policies be adopted within cities in the YRD of China in order to promote sustainable development of cities in the YRD of China. This study, therefore, seeks to provide methodological guidance for urban sustainable evaluation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2022evaluation,
  author = {Xufeng Zhang and Yanliang Liu and Akmaral Tleubergenova and Jinsong Liu and Rui Fan and Yun-En Tang and Xiang‐Zhou Meng},
  title = {{Evaluation of Urban Sustainability Based on Development Structures and Economic Aggregates: A Case Study of Jiaxing, China}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su141710683},
}
Figure