TL;DR
This study investigates two methods for sealing the ureter during radical nephroureterectomy (NFU) in a porcine model: electrocoagulation (EC) and thulium laser (Tm-laser). The findings suggest both methods are equally effective in sealing the ureteral orifice and can withstand the pressures encountered during NFU, potentially reducing the risk of tumor cell spillage.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Radical nephroureterectomy (NFU) with distal ureter and bladder cuff (DUBC) resection is the standard treatment for upper tract urothelial carcinoma (UTUC). A significant concern with this procedure is the potential for intraoperative tumor cell spillage, which can lead to local recurrence. While various techniques exist for DUBC resection, their effectiveness and safety in preventing tumor cell dissemination remain a subject of debate. Specifically, the mechanical integrity of the sealed ureteral opening under the pressures generated during NFU is not fully understood. This paper aims to address this by evaluating two common sealing methods, electrocoagulation and thulium laser, to determine if they can effectively seal the ureteral orifice and withstand the intraluminal pressures during the procedure, thereby mitigating the risk of tumor cell spillage.
Methods
The researchers employed a porcine model to evaluate two ureter sealing methods: electrocoagulation (EC) and thulium laser (Tm-laser).
- Bursting Pressure (BP) Measurement: Six pigs were used to measure the BP of ureteral openings sealed by either EC or Tm-laser. Twelve ureters were divided equally between the two groups. The distal ureteral segment was placed in a container, and the orifice was sealed. Subsequently, the sealed ureter was subjected to increasing intraluminal pressure with saline until leakage occurred, defining the BP.
- Experimental NFU: Three pigs underwent experimental NFU. After general anesthesia and abdominal incision, bilateral ureteral orifices were cannulated and connected to a piezometer to measure intraluminal pressure. A simulated tumor was created, and the ureter was ligated. The procedure involved mobilizing and ligating the renal pedicle, followed by en bloc resection of the ureter and kidney. Intraluminal pressure was recorded at various stages of the NFU, particularly during ureter manipulation.
The study also involved statistical analysis using SAS v8.02 software, with t-tests and t'-tests used to compare means and variances.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized a porcine model for experimental procedures.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Equivalent Sealing Strength: Both electrocoagulation and thulium laser sealing methods demonstrated comparable effectiveness in sealing the ureteral orifice, as evidenced by similar bursting pressures. This suggests that clinicians have a choice between these methods without compromising the initial sealing integrity.
- Pressure Resilience: The intraluminal pressures generated during the experimental NFU procedure were consistently lower than the bursting pressure of the sealed ureteral orifices, regardless of the sealing technique used. This is a crucial finding, as it implies that the sealing is robust enough to withstand the stresses of the surgery.
- Reduced Risk of Spillage: The study's findings strongly suggest that intraoperative manipulation during NFU is unlikely to cause the sealed ureteral orifice to burst, thereby significantly reducing the risk of tumor cell spillage into the peritoneal cavity. This addresses a key oncological safety concern associated with the procedure.
Key Results
- The mean bursting pressure for the electrocoagulation group was 104.3 ± 25.0 cmH2O, and for the Tm-laser group, it was 74.8 ± 23.3 cmH2O. These values were not significantly different (P > 0.05), indicating comparable sealing effectiveness.
- The peak intraluminal pressure recorded during the experimental NFU was 35.9 ± 7.6 cmH2O, which was significantly lower than the bursting pressure of the sealed ureters (P < 0.05).
- The intraluminal pressure at various stages of the NFU fluctuated but remained well below the bursting pressure of the sealed ureteral orifices.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations:
- Ex Vivo vs. In Vivo BP Measurement: The bursting pressure was measured ex vivo, not in a live animal, which might not fully replicate in vivo conditions.
- Species Differences: The experimental NFU was performed on pigs, and their urinary system anatomy differs to some extent from humans.
- Lack of Oncological Safety Test: The study did not include an actual oncological safety test to definitively prove the absence of tumor cell spillage.
Future work could involve in vivo studies to further validate these findings and potentially conduct direct oncological safety assessments to confirm the prevention of tumor cell dissemination.
Summary updated