Evaluation of the dose distribution in Mapcheck using Enhanced Dynamic Wedge

Su-Man Kang, Eun-Sun Jang, Byung-Koo Lee, Bong-Jae Jung, Jung-Sub Shin, Cheolwoo ParkJournal of the Korean Society of Radiology 2012 · DOI

Abstract

Intensity Modulated Radiotherapy (IMRT) is increasingly used to deliver high radiation doses to tumors while sparing surrounding healthy tissue. This study evaluates the dose distribution of the Enhanced Dynamic Wedge (EDW) using the Mapcheck 2D detector system. Using a Varian Clinac iX linear accelerator, researchers measured dose profiles across various EDW angles (10° to 60°), field sizes, and depths (1.5 cm and 5.0 cm) with 6 MV and 10 MV X-ray energies. Results showed that the difference between measured and calculated percentage depth doses (PDD) was less than 1% (maximum 0.6%). The study confirms that EDW effectively reduces unnecessary scattered radiation compared to physical wedges and highlights the importance of accounting for higher doses in the "toe" direction during clinical treatment.

Introduction

In modern radiotherapy, achieving a specific dose gradient or "tilt" is often necessary to conform the radiation to the target volume. Traditionally, physical metal wedges were used to create this effect. However, physical wedges introduce several complications: they cause beam hardening, increase scattered radiation to the patient, and present mechanical risks.

The Enhanced Dynamic Wedge (EDW) addresses these issues by electronically creating the wedge effect through computer-controlled movement of the collimator jaws. This study rigorously validates the accuracy of the Mapcheck 2D diode array system in verifying EDW dose distributions, ensuring that quality assurance (QA) processes can reliably capture these dynamic profiles across various clinical parameters.

Methods

The experimental setup involved a Varian Clinac iX linear accelerator and the Mapcheck system, a 2D diode array with 1,020 detectors. A solid phantom was placed atop the Mapcheck to simulate tissue depth and provide scattering material.

Experimental setup showing the Mapcheck system and solid phantom on the treatment couch.

The researchers tested 6 MV and 10 MV X-ray beams at 100 MU. Variables included seven EDW angles (10°, 15°, 20°, 25°, 30°, 45°, and 60°), asymmetric field sizes (ranging from 8x4 cm to 10x10 cm), and two measurement depths: the maximum dose depth ($d_{max}$ = 1.5 cm) and 5.0 cm. Measured data were compared against calculations from the Omnipro IMRT treatment planning software (version 8.9), which served as the gold standard.

Mechanism of EDW

The EDW effect is produced by the motion of one of the independent collimator jaws (Y1 or Y2) while the beam is on. This dynamic movement modulates the fluence across the field, creating the desired wedge-shaped dose distribution without the need for physical attenuators.

Schematic representation of the Enhanced Dynamic Wedge (EDW) mechanism showing Y1-IN and Y2-OUT jaw movements and resulting dose profiles.

As illustrated in the schematic, the movement of the jaw (either moving in or out) creates a dose gradient. The "toe" of the wedge corresponds to the area where the jaw is open for the longest duration, resulting in a higher dose compared to the "heel," where the jaw spends more time blocking the beam.

Results and Discussion

The study found exceptional agreement between the Mapcheck measurements and the treatment planning system's calculations. The maximum difference in PDD at the field center was only 0.6%, well within the 1% tolerance typically required for clinical QA. The PDD values across all configurations ranged from 2.4% to 7.2%.

Key findings include:

  • Directional Sensitivity: The maximum PDD difference was 4.1% in the Y2-OUT direction and 1.7% in the Y1-IN direction. This suggests that the direction of jaw movement relative to the detector array orientation can influence the measured accuracy.
  • Clinical Implications: Clinicians must remain aware that the dose at the "toe" of the wedge is significantly higher than at the "heel." Proper orientation of the EDW is critical to avoid over-irradiating sensitive structures near the target.
  • Scatter Reduction: By eliminating physical blocks, EDW reduces the peripheral scattered dose, which is beneficial for patient safety and reducing the risk of secondary radiation-induced malignancies.

Conclusion

The Mapcheck system is a reliable and accurate tool for the QA of Enhanced Dynamic Wedges. The high degree of accuracy (within 1%) confirms that modern planning systems and linear accelerators can precisely execute dynamic jaw movements to achieve desired dose gradients. Future work could expand this validation to more complex heterogeneous phantoms and integrate real-time log file analysis to further enhance the precision of dynamic radiotherapy delivery.

Summary updated

Abstract

세기조절방사선치료(intensity modulated radiation therapy ; IMRT)는 주변 정상장기 선량을 최소화하면서 종양에 집중적으로 고선량을 조사할 수 있는 장점으로 인하여 최근 그 사용이 급격히 증가하고 있다. 기능강화 동적쐐기 (enhanced dynamic wedge; EDW) 사용 시 기하학적 변화에 따른 Mapcheck에서의 선량분포를 측정 평가하고자 한다. Clinac ix에서 IMRT를 이용하여 EDW angle(<TEX>$10^{\circ}$</TEX>, <TEX>$15^{\circ}$</TEX>, <TEX>$20^{\circ}$</TEX>, <TEX>$25^{\circ}$</TEX>, <TEX>$30^{\circ}$</TEX>, <TEX>$45^{\circ}$</TEX>, <TEX>$60^{\circ}$</TEX>), field size(asymmetric field), depth 변화(1,5 cm, 5 cm)에 따른 선량분포를 검증하기 위해 Mapcheck위에 고체팬텀을 올려놓고 6 MV, 10MVX-ray로 100MU를 조사하였다. 6MV, 10MV의 에너지를 사용하여 기하학적변화에 따라 최대선량깊이(1.5 cm)와 5 cm 깊이에서 심부 선량백분율(percentage depth dose; PDD)은 치료계획장치에서 계산한 값의 차이가 최대 0.6%로 1%미만의 값으로 나타났다. 심부선량백분율은 조사야 중앙에서 최대선량깊이의 선량을 100%로 보았을 경우, 2.4%에서 7.2%의 범위에 있다. 또한 심부선량백분율 차이의 최대값은 Y2-OUT 방향에서 4.1%로 나타났고 Y1-IN 방향으로 1.7%로 나타났다. 동적쐐기를 사용하여 환자를 치료할 경우, 조사야 주변부의 불필요한 피폭을 유발하여 산란되는 선량을 줄이기 위하여 기능 강화 동적쐐기를 사용하는 것이 바람직할 것으로 사료된다. 특히 임상에서 환자를 치료할 경우, 쐐기의 toe방향 선량이 heel방향 선량보다 높다는 것을 염두에 두고 치료를 수행해야 할 것으로 사료된다. Intensity Modulated Radiotherapy (IMRT) is increasing its use recently due to its benefits of minimizing the dose on surrounding normal organs and being able to target a high dose specifically to the tumor. The study aims to measure and evaluate the dose distribution according to its dynamic changes in Mapcheck. In order to verify the dose distribution by EDW angle(<TEX>$10^{\circ}$</TEX>,<TEX>$15^{\circ}$</TEX>,<TEX>$20^{\circ}$</TEX>,<TEX>$25^{\circ}$</TEX>,<TEX>$30^{\circ}$</TEX>,<TEX>$45^{\circ}$</TEX>,<TEX>$60^{\circ}$</TEX>), field size (asymmetric field) and depth changes (1.5 cm, 5.0 cm) using IMRT in Clinac ix, a solid phantom was placed on the Mapcheck and 100MU was exposed by 6 MV, 10MV X-ray. Using a 6MV, 10MV energy, the percentage depth dose according to a dynamic changes at a maximum dose depth (1.5 cm) and at 5.0 cm depth showed the value difference of maximum 0.6%, less than 1%, which was calculated by a treatment program device considering the maximum dose depth at the center as 100%, the percentage depth dose was in the range between 2.4% and 7.2%. Also, the maximum value difference of a percentage depth dose was 4.1% in Y2-OUT direction, and 1.7% in Y1-IN direction. When treating a patient using a wedge, it is considered that using an enhanced dynamic wedge is effective to reduce the scattered dose which induces unnecessary dose to the surroundings. In particular, when treating a patient at clinic, a treatment must be performed considering that the wedge dose in a toe direction is higher than the dose in a heel direction.
BibTeX
@article{kang2012evaluation,
  author = {Su-Man Kang and Eun-Sun Jang and Byung-Koo Lee and Bong-Jae Jung and Jung-Sub Shin and Cheolwoo Park},
  title = {{Evaluation of the dose distribution in Mapcheck using Enhanced Dynamic Wedge}},
  journal = {Journal of the Korean Society of Radiology},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.7742/jksr.2012.6.5.343},
}
Figure