Evaluation of Sustainable Design Method for Three-Lane Entrance Ramps on Expressways in Urban Areas: A Case Study of Xi'an, China

Yutong Liu, Binghong Pan, Ruihua Song, Lin ZongIEEE Access 2023 · OpenReview

Abstract

Owing to the challenges faced by two-lane entrance ramps in merging areas on expressways in handling the growing traffic volume, designers are considering implementing three-lane entrance ramps. This approach alleviates capacity bottlenecks and facilitates efficient, safe, and green operations. However, according to the traditional design strategy, the long auxiliary lanes will bring large land occupation and construction consumption, creating obstacles to the reconstruction. To address this issue, this study proposes two new strategies and discusses the applicability of each scheme. A VISSIM microsimulation model was developed and calibrated using the collected data, and five evaluation indicators assessing environmental protection, capacity, traffic efficiency, safety, and construction consumption were selected. This study also presents a comprehensive evaluation (CE) method that combines the CRITIC (Criteria Importance Through Intercriteria Correlation) method and TOPSIS (Technique for Order Preference by Similarity to an Ideal Solution), which considers the association between indicators and offers a more rational evaluation, aiming to recommend optimal designs for various traffic cases. The results indicate that two-lane ramps are still the preferred choice for lower traffic volumes and merging ratios, whereas three-lane ramps demonstrate excellent potential for application under heavy traffic conditions. The CE reveals substantial improvements in optimal designs, with capacity, delay, CO emissions, and conflicts showing maximum enhancements of approximately 20%, 45%, 5%, and 55%, respectively.

Introduction

Merging areas on urban expressways are notorious for congestion, high crash rates, and increased emissions. As urban traffic demand swells, traditional two-lane entrance ramps frequently become major bottlenecks. While expanding to three-lane ramps is a logical solution for increasing capacity, traditional design standards often require extensive auxiliary lanes to allow vehicles to merge safely. In dense urban environments, these long lanes consume prohibitive amounts of land and construction resources, creating significant obstacles to infrastructure reconstruction.

This research addresses a two-fold challenge: developing more compact and sustainable three-lane ramp designs and establishing an objective framework to evaluate these designs when performance metrics, such as traffic speed, conflict with sustainability metrics, such as land use and construction costs.

Methodology

Simulation and Calibration

The researchers utilized a case study of Interchange G on the Xi’an Ring Expressway in China. They developed a digital twin of the interchange using VISSIM microsimulation. To ensure the simulation matched reality, the model was calibrated using high-fidelity field data, including radar data for precise vehicle speeds, UAV footage for analyzing driving behaviors, and AMAP platform data for regional congestion indices. The calibration process relied on the Greenshields Model to ensure the mathematical relationship between traffic volume, speed, and density was sound.

The Greenshields model used for calibrating the relationship between traffic volume, speed, and density.

Design Innovation

Three distinct three-lane schemes were proposed to balance performance and land use:

  • DATE (Double Auxiliary): The high-performance standard, utilizing two full auxiliary lanes.
  • STE (Speed Limit Lane): A compromise design where the first section of the auxiliary lane is shortened and subject to speed restrictions.
  • SATE (Single Auxiliary): A compact design where different ramp lanes merge into a single auxiliary lane or directly into the mainline.

Comprehensive Evaluation (CE) Framework

To rank these designs, the study combined two Multi-Criteria Decision-Making (MCDM) tools. The CRITIC method was used to assign weights to indicators by accounting for the correlation between variables (e.g., how delay and emissions often move together). These weights were then fed into TOPSIS, a technique that ranks designs based on how close they are to an "ideal" solution and how far they are from the "worst-case" scenario.

The hybrid CRITIC-TOPSIS framework used for multi-criteria decision-making.

Key Results and Insights

Analysis across 28 different traffic scenarios revealed that two-lane ramps remain the preferred choice for lower traffic volumes. However, a critical tipping point occurs when total traffic exceeds 5,000 vehicles per hour. Beyond this threshold, the two-lane system collapses, and the benefits of three-lane designs become exponential.

Under heavy traffic conditions, optimized three-lane designs offered massive improvements over traditional setups:

  • Capacity: Increased by up to 20%.
  • Traffic Delay: Reduced by up to 45%.
  • Safety: Traffic conflicts (potential crashes) were reduced by up to 55%.
  • Emissions: CO emissions saw a modest but important reduction of 5%.

Sustainability in this model is multi-dimensional. By including "Additional Square" (land occupation) as a primary indicator, the model penalizes designs that are high-performing but environmentally "expensive." In many scenarios, the SATE (Single Auxiliary) design emerged as the optimal middle ground, offering significant capacity boosts with a much smaller physical footprint.

Conclusion

This study demonstrates that three-lane entrance ramps are a viable solution for urban expressway bottlenecks when designed with sustainability in mind. The proposed hybrid evaluation framework allows engineers to recommend specific ramp designs based on the unique traffic volume and merging ratios of a site. Future work will explore these models on larger mainline configurations and refine driver behavior profiles to better reflect diverse global driving cultures.

Summary updated

Abstract

Owing to the challenges faced by two-lane entrance ramps in merging areas on expressways in handling the growing traffic volume, designers are considering implementing three-lane entrance ramps. This approach alleviates capacity bottlenecks and facilitates efficient, safe, and green operations. However, according to the traditional design strategy, the long auxiliary lanes will bring large land occupation and construction consumption, creating obstacles to the reconstruction. To address this issue, this study proposes two new strategies and discusses the applicability of each scheme. A VISSIM microsimulation model was developed and calibrated using the collected data, and five evaluation indicators assessing environmental protection, capacity, traffic efficiency, safety, and construction consumption were selected. This study also presents a comprehensive evaluation(CE) method that combines the CRITIC (Criteria Importance Through Intercriteria Correlation) method and TOPSIS(Technique for Order Preference by Similarity to an Ideal Solution), which considers the association between indicators and offers a more rational evaluation, aiming to recommend optimal designs for various traffic cases. The results indicate that two-lane ramps are still the preferred choice for lower traffic volumes and merging ratios, whereas three-lane ramps demonstrate excellent potential for application under heavy traffic conditions. The CE reveals substantial improvements in optimal designs, with capacity, delay, CO emissions, and conflicts showing maximum enhancements of approximately 20%, 45%, 5%, and 55%, respectively.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2023evaluation,
  author = {Yutong Liu and Binghong Pan and Ruihua Song and Lin Zong},
  title = {{Evaluation of Sustainable Design Method for Three-Lane Entrance Ramps on Expressways in Urban Areas: A Case Study of Xi'an, China}},
  booktitle = {IEEE Access},
  year = {2023},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=pAMjsqtKLf},
}
Figure