Evaluation of Sustainable City and Old-Age Security Policy Intervention in China

Run Tang, Xin Guan, Junfan Zhu, Bo Liu, Zeyu Wang, Fanbao XieSustainability 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel policy intervention evaluation model for sustainable city development in China, specifically addressing the challenges of rapid urbanization and an aging population. By employing a synthetic control method and dynamic simulation, the study demonstrates that China's "healthy city" pilot policies have a positive, albeit modest, impact on urban health and sustainable development.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

China is experiencing a dual challenge: rapid urbanization, with 60% of its population now living in cities, and a rapidly aging demographic. This convergence strains urban environments and necessitates cities that can accommodate residents of all ages, improving their quality of life and access to healthcare. Existing urban planning often overlooks the specific needs of the elderly, such as accessibility in residential buildings and public spaces. The paper aims to evaluate the effectiveness of China's "healthy city" pilot policies in addressing these intertwined issues and promoting sustainable urban development.

Methods

The study employs a multi-faceted approach:

  • Policy Intervention Evaluation Model: A framework is introduced to assess policy efficacy by analyzing inputs, processing, and outcomes.
  • Synthetic Control Method (SCM): This is the core methodological innovation. SCM is used to create a "synthetic" control group of non-pilot cities that best mimics the characteristics of the pilot cities before the policy intervention. This allows for a more robust comparison of outcomes by estimating the counterfactual scenario (what would have happened without the policy). The paper details the mathematical formulation of SCM, including factor models and weight calculations.
  • Dynamic Simulation Model: A system dynamics approach is used to simulate the urban health system's operation under various dynamic factors over a 10-year period. This helps understand the complex interplay of economic, human settlement, and ecological elements influencing urban health.
  • Entropy Weight Method: This method is used to calculate the comprehensive city health assessment index, normalizing data and assigning weights to different indicators.

Datasets

The study utilizes data from six Chinese cities designated as "pilot sustainable cities" at the end of 2016 (Jinan, Dalian, Changchun, Suzhou, Hangzhou, and others implied by the synthetic control analysis). These cities form the "treatment group." A control group is constructed from other non-pilot cities in China. The specific time period for analysis appears to span from 2005 to 2019, with a focus on the period after the policy intervention in 2017.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • SCM as a Superior Evaluation Tool: The paper highlights SCM's advantage over traditional methods like Difference-in-Difference (DID) for policy evaluation, particularly in complex urban systems where direct counterfactuals are hard to establish. The close match between observed and synthetic control values for pilot cities before the intervention underscores SCM's effectiveness.
  • Holistic Urban Health: The study emphasizes that "healthy cities" extend beyond just public health, encompassing environmental, social, and economic well-being. The integrated index system reflects this broader perspective.
  • Modest but Significant Policy Impact: While the "healthy city" pilot policy shows a positive effect, the measured effect size (0.015) is modest. This suggests that while the policy is beneficial, its impact might be gradual or require complementary measures to achieve more substantial improvements.
  • Dynamic Interplay of Factors: The dynamic simulation reveals that factors like population aggregation and the concentration of tertiary industries positively influence urban health. Conversely, the income gap and rapid urbanization can have complex and sometimes adverse effects, highlighting the need for nuanced policy design.

Key Results

  • Synthetic Control Fit: The study found that the synthetic control unit closely resembled the actual pilot cities in terms of layout and design before the policy intervention, indicating the robustness of the SCM approach.
  • Policy Effect Size: The healthy city pilot policy demonstrated a promotion effect on healthy city construction with an effect size of 0.015.
  • Varied Regional Impact: The implementation of the sustainable city pilot strategy had varying degrees of encouraging effects across different pilot cities, with Zhejiang showing a 2% variable rate and Beijing a 0.54% rate, while other regions had rates close to zero.
  • Positive Trend in Urban Health: The composite index for urban health showed a general rising trend in pilot cities, suggesting progress in sustainable city building.
  • Dynamic Factor Influence: The simulation indicated that the employment benefits of high-skilled laborers and the income gap had minimal impact on urban system health, while population aggregation and tertiary industry concentration played a favorable role.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Clarifying Indicator Relationships: The logical relationship between indicators used in the composite index system needs further clarification.
  • Data Sufficiency: There might be insufficient data to reliably gauge the success of all aspects of the policy.
  • Subjectivity in Generalization: The structure of the summarized system dynamics model is based on existing literature, and results derived from statistical methods may carry some subjectivity in generalization.

Future work suggested includes:

  • Further Clarification of Indicator Logic: Deepening the understanding of how different indicators interact.
  • Employing Advanced Analytical Tools: Using more sophisticated tools for system dynamics modeling to enhance generalization and reduce subjectivity.
  • Structural Equation Modeling: Examining the impact of healthy urban community home care policies on service utilization by the elderly.
  • Dynamic Simulation for Policy Optimization: Summarizing the influence of different policy interventions on optimal usage behavior and modeling their effects dynamically.

Summary updated

Abstract

It is becoming increasingly urgent to address the health of the urban environment and the aging population as cities increasingly absorb the majority of the world’s population. Efforts to promote “healthy cities” continue to garner interest as a means of empowering local communities to improve residents’ access to healthcare and encourage them to adopt more preventative practices. Due to the confluence of urbanization and population aging in China, the country’s cities must be designed and constructed to accommodate a wider range of residents and improve the quality of life for residents of all ages. A policy intervention evaluation model for the sustainable city index system is introduced after briefly reviewing the historical progression of sustainable city construction and the policies around the world. Then, six main pilot cities are selected to analyze their unique characteristics and trends across various dimensions. Finally, the dynamic simulation model is used to simulate the operation status of the pilot city system according to different dynamic factors. Two main conclusions are reached. (1) In different areas, the implementation of the sustainable city pilot strategy has had varying degrees of encouraging effects on building projects. (2) Overall, the pilot cities’ observed value is quite near to the control value calculated here. This suggests the synthetic control unit closely resembles the actual pilot city in terms of layout and design. (3) The healthy city pilot policy has a promotion effect on healthy city construction, as measured by its effect size of 0.015. This work can serve as a theoretical reference for promoting healthy city growth and as a guide for the city’s benign operation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{tang2023evaluation,
  author = {Run Tang and Xin Guan and Junfan Zhu and Bo Liu and Zeyu Wang and Fanbao Xie},
  title = {{Evaluation of Sustainable City and Old-Age Security Policy Intervention in China}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/su15076192},
}
Figure