Evaluation of suitable reference genes for normalization of quantitative reverse transcription PCR analyses in Clavibacter michiganensis

Na Jiang, Qingyang Lyu, Sining Han, Xin Xu, R. R. Walcott, Jianqiang Li, Laixin LuoMicrobiologyOpen 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper addresses the critical need for reliable reference genes in quantitative reverse transcription PCR (qRT-PCR) experiments for Clavibacter michiganensis, a significant plant pathogen. By systematically evaluating six candidate housekeeping genes across diverse experimental conditions, the study identifies the most stable genes for accurate gene expression analysis, preventing misinterpretations in plant-pathogen interaction research.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Quantitative reverse transcription PCR (qRT-PCR) is a powerful tool for measuring gene expression, crucial for understanding how organisms function and interact with their environment. However, the accuracy of qRT-PCR heavily relies on the use of "reference genes" – genes whose expression remains constant regardless of experimental conditions. If these reference genes fluctuate, the entire gene expression analysis can be skewed, leading to incorrect conclusions. Clavibacter michiganensis (C. michiganensis), a Gram-positive bacterium responsible for bacterial canker in tomatoes, is a model organism for studying plant diseases. Despite its importance, there's a lack of validated reference genes for qRT-PCR studies in this pathogen, especially across various conditions like different growth media, host interactions, nutrient starvation, and the viable but nonculturable (VBNC) state. This gap hinders reliable gene expression studies, making it difficult to unravel the complex molecular mechanisms underlying C. michiganensis pathogenicity and its interactions with tomato plants.

Methods

The researchers employed a systematic approach to identify suitable reference genes. They selected six commonly used housekeeping genes in bacteria: gyrB, rpoB, tufA, bipA, gapA, and pbpA. These genes were chosen to avoid potential coregulation issues due to their diverse functions. To evaluate their stability, the expression of these genes was measured using qRT-PCR under five distinct experimental conditions:

  1. Nutrient-rich broth: TBY broth and modified M9 broth.
  2. Host environment mimic: Tomato seedling homogenate (TSH) medium.
  3. Nutrient starvation: 0.85% NaCl solution.
  4. Viable but nonculturable (VBNC) induction: 0.85% NaCl solution supplemented with CuSO4.

The raw qRT-PCR data (Ct values) were then analyzed using two widely accepted algorithms: geNorm and NormFinder.

  • geNorm identifies the most stable genes by calculating a gene expression stability measure (M) and pairwise variation (V), iteratively excluding the least stable genes.
  • NormFinder considers both intra- and inter-group variations to determine gene stability, providing a stability value (SV).

The study also included two pathogenicity genes, celA and chpC, as validation targets to assess the impact of using different reference genes on the observed expression levels of genes of interest.

Datasets

The study utilized Clavibacter michiganensis strain BT0505, isolated from a tomato field. The genome sequence of C. michiganensis strain NCPPB382 was used for primer design. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing biological samples under various controlled conditions were used for gene expression analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • No single reference gene fits all: The study strongly reinforces the principle that reference gene stability is highly condition-dependent. Genes that are stable in one environment may be highly variable in another.
  • Housekeeping genes aren't always stable: Even commonly used housekeeping genes can exhibit significant expression fluctuations, underscoring the necessity of empirical validation before use.
  • VBNC state requires specific validation: The VBNC state, a survival mechanism for bacteria under stress, presents unique challenges for gene expression analysis, and specific reference genes are needed for this condition.
  • Pathogenicity gene expression is sensitive to reference gene choice: The validation experiments clearly demonstrated that using unstable reference genes can lead to significant overestimation or underestimation of pathogenicity gene expression, highlighting the practical implications of this research.

Key Results

The study identified specific reference genes suitable for different experimental contexts:

  • Nutrient-rich conditions (TBY and mM9 broth): gyrB, bipA, and gapA were found to be stably expressed.
  • C. michiganensis-tomato interaction studies: pbpA, tufA, and gyrB were recommended.
  • Nutrient-poor conditions (starvation): bipA and rpoB were recommended.
  • Viable but nonculturable (VBNC) state: The combination of gyrB, pbpA, and rpoB was recommended.

The study also noted that the commonly used 16S rRNA was not suitable for normalization in this context. The validation experiments showed that normalizing pathogenicity genes (celA and chpC) with the least stable gene (gapA) resulted in significantly different fold-change values compared to normalization with the most stable genes.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited number of candidate genes: While six housekeeping genes were evaluated, a broader selection could potentially reveal even more stable candidates.
  • Specific strain and host: The findings are specific to Clavibacter michiganensis strain BT0505 and its interaction with tomato. Further studies might be needed for other strains or host plants.
  • Algorithm differences: The study acknowledges that geNorm and NormFinder sometimes provided different rankings, a common observation attributed to their distinct statistical algorithms. Future work could explore other validation algorithms.

The authors suggest that this study provides valuable information for selecting reference genes for C. michiganensis and potentially other phytopathogenic bacteria, paving the way for more accurate and reliable gene expression studies in plant pathology.

Summary updated

Abstract

Clavibacter michiganensis, the causal agent of bacterial canker of tomato, is a Gram-positive bacterium and a model for studying plant diseases. The real-time quantitative reverse transcription PCR (real-time qRT-PCR) assay is widely used to quantify gene expression in plant pathogenic bacteria. However, accurate quantification of gene expression requires stably expressed reference genes that are consistently expressed during the experimental conditions of interest. The use of inappropriate reference genes leads to a misinterpretation of gene expression data and false conclusions. In current study, we empirically assessed the expression stability of six housekeeping genes (gyrB, rpoB, tufA, bipA, gapA, and pbpA) of C. michiganensis under five experimental conditions using two algorithms, geNorm and NormFinder. C. michiganensis expressed gyrB, bipA, and gapA stably when growing in nutrient-rich broth (TBY broth and modified M9 broth). We concluded that pbpA, tufA, and gyrB were suitable reference genes in C. michiganensis-tomato interaction studies. We also recommended bipA and rpoB to be used to study bacterial gene expression under nutrient-poor conditions. Finally, gyrB, pbpA, and rpoB can be used to normalize the quantification of C. michiganensis gene expression while the bacterium is in the viable but nonculturable (VBNC) state. This study identified the most suitable reference genes depending on the experimental conditions for calibrating real-time qRT-PCR analyses of C. michiganensis and will be useful in studies that seek to understand the molecular interactions between C. michiganensis and tomato.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jiang2019evaluation,
  author = {Na Jiang and Qingyang Lyu and Sining Han and Xin Xu and R. R. Walcott and Jianqiang Li and Laixin Luo},
  title = {{Evaluation of suitable reference genes for normalization of quantitative reverse transcription PCR analyses in <i>Clavibacter michiganensis</i>}},
  booktitle = {MicrobiologyOpen},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1002/mbo3.928},
}
Figure