Evaluation of Seismic Performance of K-Shaped Eccentrically Braced Steel Frame Considering Aftershocks, Link and Beam-Column Joint Damage

Zhanchao Ma, Haifeng Yu, Yifan Zhu, Zhihui Liu, Qizhi Wang, Cuixia Wei, Tianjiao Jin, Hongzhi ZhangBuildings 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the seismic performance of K-shaped eccentrically braced steel frames (K-EBFs) by considering the combined effects of aftershocks, link damage, and beam-column joint damage. The findings reveal that these factors significantly increase structural response, failure probabilities, and reduce collapse resistance, highlighting the critical need to incorporate them into seismic design for accurate performance prediction.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Earthquakes rarely occur in isolation; they are often followed by a series of aftershocks, which can be as destructive as the main event, especially if the structure has already sustained damage. Traditional seismic performance evaluations often focus on mainshocks and may simplify or neglect the damage to critical components like links and beam-column joints. K-shaped eccentrically braced steel frames (K-EBFs) are designed to dissipate seismic energy through the inelastic deformation of their links. However, damage to these links, along with damage to the semi-rigid beam-column joints, can alter the structure's load-carrying paths and overall response. This paper addresses the critical gap in understanding how the combined effects of aftershocks, link damage, and beam-column joint damage influence the seismic performance, vulnerability, and collapse risk of K-EBF structures.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach to evaluate the seismic performance of K-EBF structures. They developed detailed finite element models of 12-story and 18-story K-EBFs using ABAQUS software. To assess seismic performance, they utilized Incremental Dynamic Analysis (IDA), which involves subjecting the models to a suite of ground motion records scaled to various intensity levels (represented by Peak Ground Acceleration, PGA).

Crucially, the study incorporated realistic damage models:

  • Beam-column joint damage: Modeled using a moment-rotation curve that accounts for yield, peak, and residual strengths, derived from experimental data.
  • Link damage: Modeled by transitioning the link connection from rigid to hinged once a critical plastic rotation threshold is reached, simulating severe buckling and loss of shear resistance.
  • Mainshock-aftershock sequences: Synthesized using a "repetition method" to simulate realistic seismic events.

Following IDA, fragility analysis was conducted to predict the probability of exceeding specific damage limit states (slight, moderate, severe, collapse) under different seismic intensities. Finally, structural collapse resistance was evaluated using the minimum collapse-resistant reserve coefficient (CMRP = 10%).

Datasets

The study utilized fifteen natural far-site earthquake records for seismic analysis. These records were selected based on specific criteria related to their seismic influence curves, magnitude, PGA, duration, epicentral distance, shear wave velocity, and frequency content. The ground motion records were then scaled to represent different earthquake levels: frequent (63% probability of exceedance), fortification (10% probability), and rare (2% probability). The damage limit states for capacity were adopted from the Chinese seismic design code (GB50011-2016).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The cumulative effect is significant: The combined impact of aftershocks, link damage, and beam-column joint damage is substantially greater than the sum of their individual effects. This highlights the importance of considering these factors simultaneously.
  • Aftershocks amplify damage: Even without considering component damage, aftershocks increase structural response (e.g., inter-story drift) and failure probabilities, especially at higher seismic intensities.
  • Links are critical energy dissipators: Damage to the links, which are designed to absorb seismic energy, significantly degrades the structure's performance and collapse resistance. This is because once damaged, they lose their primary energy dissipation role.
  • Taller structures are more vulnerable: The 18-story structure showed a more pronounced increase in response and a greater reduction in collapse resistance compared to the 12-story structure, likely due to amplified higher-order mode effects and P-Delta effects.
  • K-EBFs are robust, but with caveats: While K-EBF structures generally demonstrate good seismic performance and meet code requirements even under these combined adverse conditions, their collapse resistance is notably reduced when these factors are considered.

Key Results

  • Increased Inter-story Drift: Under fortification earthquakes (PGA = 0.2 g), the maximum inter-story drift ratio increased by 11.1% (12-story) and 20.1% (18-story) when considering all three factors compared to no damage. Under rare earthquakes (PGA = 0.4 g), these increases were 30.0% and 56.7%, respectively.
  • Higher Failure Probabilities: The probability of severe damage increased significantly. For rare earthquakes, the severe damage probability rose by 15.3% (12-story) and 24.0% (18-story) when all factors were considered.
  • Reduced Collapse Resistance: The minimum collapse margin ratio (CMRP = 10%) decreased by 27.8% (12-story) and 32.3% (18-story) when considering the combined effects, indicating a lower safety margin against collapse.
  • Link Damage Dominance: The study concluded that link damage, along with aftershocks, has a greater impact on collapse resistance than beam-column joint damage.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their study has limitations, specifically mentioning that residual stresses, fire effects, and non-structural damage were not considered. They suggest that future research should explore these aspects to gain a more comprehensive understanding of structural behavior. Additionally, the study implicitly suggests that innovative design strategies, such as prioritizing ductile and replaceable link designs, using advanced materials for connections, and optimizing structural systems with improved bracing or isolation, could enhance performance in mainshock-aftershock scenarios.

Summary updated

Abstract

Damage to structural members or joints can change the load transfer path of the structure. Additionally, structures may experience severe damage or even collapse due to the impact of aftershocks. To investigate the effects of beam-column joint damage, link damage, and aftershocks on the seismic performance of K-shaped eccentrically braced steel frame (K-EBF) structures, incremental dynamic analysis, fragility analysis, and collapse resistance evaluation were conducted using examples of 12-story and 18-story K-EBF structures. The results showed that considering beam-column joint damage, link damage, and aftershocks compared to not considering them, and the maximum inter-story drift ratio (θmax) of the 12-story and 18-story K-EBF structures increased by 11.1% and 20.1%, respectively, under fortification earthquakes, and by 30.0% and 56.7%, respectively, under rare earthquakes. The failure probability of the severe damage limit state of the 12-story and 18-story K-EBF structures increased by 1.0% and 3.0%, respectively, under fortification earthquakes, and by 15.3% and 24.0%, respectively, under rare earthquakes. Additionally, the minimum collapse margin ratios (CMRP = 10%) of the two structures decrease by 27.8% and 32.3%, respectively. The influence of aftershocks on the structural seismic response tends to intensify as the intensity of ground motion increases, and the beam-column joint damage and link damage further increases the failure probability of different damage limit states, leading to a decrease in the minimum collapse resistance coefficient of the structure. Therefore, in the seismic performance analysis of K-EBF structures, the effects of beam-column joint damage, link damage, and aftershocks should be fully considered to accurately reflect the response of structures under seismic actions. Overall, the impact of link damage, as well as aftershocks, on the structural collapse resistance is greater than that of beam-column joint damage.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ma2025evaluation,
  author = {Zhanchao Ma and Haifeng Yu and Yifan Zhu and Zhihui Liu and Qizhi Wang and Cuixia Wei and Tianjiao Jin and Hongzhi Zhang},
  title = {{Evaluation of Seismic Performance of K-Shaped Eccentrically Braced Steel Frame Considering Aftershocks, Link and Beam-Column Joint Damage}},
  booktitle = {Buildings},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/buildings15244476},
}
Figure