TL;DR
This paper introduces a novel evaluation framework for the "realization of ecological products value" in China, combining objective data with expert opinions to overcome limitations of purely quantitative methods. Applied to the Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei (BTH) region, it reveals significant regional disparities in effectiveness, with Beijing leading and northern mountainous areas outperforming southern plains, offering crucial insights for targeted policy development.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
China is increasingly focused on "ecological products value realization," a concept that aims to translate natural ecosystem services into economic and social benefits, fostering ecological civilization. However, existing evaluation methods often rely solely on objective indicators, which struggle with data limitations and regional heterogeneity. For instance, pollution purification services are more easily valued in polluted areas than in pristine ones, and regional differences in natural endowments (like forest cover) can skew comparisons. This paper addresses the need for a more robust, nuanced, and adaptable evaluation system that captures the "perceived effectiveness" of these value realization efforts, considering both objective conditions and expert judgment across different types of ecological products.
Methods
The study employs an Objective-Strategy-Measurement (OSM) analytical framework to design a novel evaluation scale. This scale is built on a dual mechanism: "objective data + expert experience calibration." It covers the entire value realization chain: ecological background, economic conversion, social well-being, and benefit feedback.
Key methodological steps include:
- OSM Framework Application: Decomposing the objective of ecological product value realization into strategies and measurable actions for each of the three ecological product categories (Material-supply-oriented - MSEPs, Regulatory-service-oriented - RSEPs, and Cultural-service-oriented - CSEPs).
- Scale Design: Developing distinct evaluation scales (PEM, PER, PEC) with specific sub-indices for each ecological product type, drawing on policy documents and expert consultation.
- Delphi Process: Refining the preliminary scales through a structured Delphi process involving a multidisciplinary panel of experts to achieve consensus on evaluation items.
- Expert Scoring: Utilizing a 1-to-5 Likert scale for expert scoring, with a special provision for a score of 0 for severely detrimental impacts.
- Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP): Employing AHP to determine indicator weights, combining quantitative and qualitative analyses to assess the relative importance of criteria.
- Unitization (Min-Max Scaling): Rescaling the calculated indices to a 0-1 range for better comparability and intuitiveness.
- Coordinated Coupling Degree (CCD): Calculating the CCD to analyze the synergistic development effectiveness of the three ecological product value realization models within each region.
Datasets
The study did not use traditional datasets for training or evaluation in the machine learning sense. Instead, it relied on:
- Expert Scores: The primary data source was expert scores obtained through a structured evaluation process.
- Supporting Data for Experts: To inform expert judgments, a variety of data sources were consulted, including:
- Official statistics and departmental data (statistical yearbooks, bulletins, reports from agricultural, environmental, and natural resources departments).
- Openly accessible geospatial data.
- Other social data platforms, social media, and platform information.
- Academic research literature.
This approach aimed to integrate macro-level statistics with micro-level evidence and objective records to provide comprehensive support for the scale evaluations.
Key Insights and Ideas
- The Power of Perceived Effectiveness: Purely objective indicators are insufficient. Incorporating expert judgment ("perceived effectiveness") is crucial for a more holistic understanding of value realization, especially for intangible benefits.
- A Holistic Value Chain: The study's framework covers the entire lifecycle of ecological product value realization, from ecological foundations to benefit feedback, providing a comprehensive view.
- Regional Disparities are Stark: The Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei (BTH) region exhibits significant variations in ecological product value realization effectiveness, highlighting that a one-size-fits-all approach is inappropriate.
- Ecological Foundation Matters: Regions with stronger ecological endowments (e.g., northern mountainous areas) tend to perform better, underscoring the importance of natural capital.
- Market Mechanisms are Key: The "market mechanism maturity" is a critical soft dimension influencing effectiveness, particularly for regulatory services.
- Policy Implications: Different regions require tailored strategies. Weaker performing regions should focus on leadership strategies and exploiting specific ecosystem values (e.g., farmland ecosystems), rather than broad development.
Key Results
The study found the following average perceived effectiveness indices for the BTH region:
- Material-Supply-Oriented Ecological Products (MSEPs): 0.7054
- Regulatory Service-Oriented Ecological Products (RSEPs): 0.6482
- Cultural Service-Oriented Ecological Products (CSEPs): 0.6052
Regional Performance:
- Beijing: Ranks first across all categories, demonstrating comprehensive advantages.
- Northern Mountainous Areas (e.g., Chengde, Zhangjiakou): Show stronger effectiveness, particularly in RSEPs and CSEPs, due to rich natural resources.
- Southern Plains: Generally exhibit weaker performance, especially in MSEPs and CSEPs, facing challenges from industrial development and less favorable natural conditions.
- Coordinated Coupling Degree (CCD): The overall CCD shows a "high in the north and low in the south" pattern, with Beijing achieving the highest score (0.9776).
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations:
- Exploratory Nature: The designed scales are exploratory and require verification through a broader empirical basis.
- Data Availability: The complexity of ecological products and data limitations can still pose challenges.
- Subjectivity in Expert Scoring: While a structured process was used, expert perceptions can still introduce subjectivity.
Future Work Suggestions:
- Refining Scale Items: Incorporating more dynamic and socioeconomic factors to better reflect long-term trends and comprehensive impacts.
- Stratified Weighting Method: Including subjective perceptions from diverse groups (managers, practitioners, public) and assigning weights to enhance representativeness.
- Broader Empirical Basis: Validating the scales with more extensive data and case studies.
- Region-Specific Pathways: Developing tailored implementation strategies for different regions within the BTH agglomeration.
- Enhanced Coordination Mechanisms: Strengthening cross-regional cooperation, benefit-sharing systems, and unified trading platforms.
Summary updated