Evaluation of PC‐ISO for customized, 3D printed, gynecologic HDR brachytherapy applicators

J. Adam M. Cunha, Katherine Mellis, Rajni Sethi, Timmy Siauw, Atchar Sudhyadhom, Animesh Garg, Ken Goldberg, I‐Chow Hsu, Jean PouliotJournal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics 2015 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the suitability of PC-ISO, a 3D-printable material, for creating custom gynecologic brachytherapy applicators. The study found that PC-ISO exhibits radiation attenuation properties very similar to water, making it compatible with existing brachytherapy planning systems and clinical workflows. This opens the door for more personalized and effective cancer treatments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Current gynecologic (GYN) brachytherapy applicators, while available in various shapes and sizes, offer limited customization. This lack of personalization can lead to issues like loose fits (increasing dose uncertainty), patient discomfort from tight fits, or the need for extra interstitial catheters to achieve treatment goals. The authors aim to address this by exploring the use of 3D printing with a specific material, PC-ISO, to create patient-specific applicators with precisely designed internal channels for delivering radiation seeds. The core challenge is to ensure that this 3D-printed material is safe and effective for clinical use, particularly regarding its interaction with radiation and imaging systems.

Methods

The researchers developed a custom testing apparatus 3D-printed from PC-ISO. This apparatus featured a single catheter channel and a slit to hold radiochromic film, designed to mimic the geometry relevant to clinical GYN brachytherapy. They then computed a brachytherapy dose plan using an 192Ir source, delivering a cylindrical dose distribution to the film. To evaluate the material's radiation attenuation, they compared the film's exposure to an identical test performed in water. Additionally, they used CT scans to compare the Hounsfield Unit (HU) distributions of the PC-ISO apparatus, water, and a commercial GYN applicator. The study also considered the material's biocompatibility and sterilizability, noting that PC-ISO is FDA-approved and can be sterilized using methods like STERRAD.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study primarily relies on experimental measurements and simulations rather than pre-existing datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Water Equivalence is Key: The most critical finding is that PC-ISO's radiation attenuation is remarkably close to that of water, which is the standard medium assumed by brachytherapy planning systems. This "water equivalence" is crucial for accurate dose calculations.
  • No CT Artifacts: The PC-ISO material did not produce significant CT artifacts, which is essential for accurate imaging and treatment planning.
  • Customization Potential: The study demonstrates that 3D printing with PC-ISO allows for the creation of highly customized applicators, including complex internal channel geometries, which can directly improve patient treatment.
  • Practical Clinical Integration: The material's compatibility with existing clinical workflows, including sterilization and planning systems, makes its adoption feasible.

Key Results

  • The dose depth curve of PC-ISO, as measured by radiochromic film, was within 1% of water between 1 cm and 6 cm from the catheter channel.
  • The mean Hounsfield Unit (HU) for PC-ISO was -10, compared to -1 for water. This is significantly closer to water than a commercial applicator's mean HU of +524.
  • The study confirmed that PC-ISO is biocompatible, sterilizable, and does not produce CT artifacts.
  • The authors have since implemented custom PC-ISO applicators in their clinical practice when they can improve patient treatment.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Contouring Difficulty: A notable limitation is that the near water equivalency of PC-ISO makes it difficult to delineate the applicator's boundary during CT contouring, especially at the tip. The authors suggest using radiopaque dye and a condom as potential solutions.
  • Cost of 3D Printers: While the technology is promising, the high cost of FDA-approved 3D printers ($100,000+) is a barrier. However, the authors note that clinics can still leverage this technology by outsourcing printing to vendors.
  • Future Work: The paper implicitly suggests future work in refining contouring techniques for these near-water-equivalent materials and exploring other 3D-printable materials for brachytherapy applications. The successful clinical implementation of custom PC-ISO applicators also points towards broader adoption and further refinement of the design and manufacturing process.

Summary updated

Abstract

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the radiation attenuation properties of PC-ISO, a commercially available, biocompatible, sterilizable 3D printing material, and its suitability for customized, single-use gynecologic (GYN) brachytherapy applicators that have the potential for accurate guiding of seeds through linear and curved internal channels. A custom radiochromic film dosimetry apparatus was 3D-printed in PC-ISO with a single catheter channel and a slit to hold a film segment. The apparatus was designed specifically to test geometry pertinent for use of this material in a clinical setting. A brachytherapy dose plan was computed to deliver a cylindrical dose distribution to the film. The dose plan used an 192Ir source and was normalized to 1500 cGy at 1 cm from the channel. The material was evaluated by comparing the film exposure to an identical test done in water. The Hounsfield unit (HU) distributions were computed from a CT scan of the apparatus and compared to the HU distribution of water and the HU distribution of a commercial GYN cylinder applicator. The dose depth curve of PC-ISO as measured by the radiochromic film was within 1% of water between 1 cm and 6 cm from the channel. The mean HU was -10 for PC-ISO and -1 for water. As expected, the honeycombed structure of the PC-ISO 3D printing process created a moderate spread of HU values, but the mean was comparable to water. PC-ISO is sufficiently water-equivalent to be compatible with our HDR brachytherapy planning system and clinical workflow and, therefore, it is suitable for creating custom GYN brachytherapy applicators. Our current clinical practice includes the use of custom GYN applicators made of commercially available PC-ISO when doing so can improve the patient's treatment.
BibTeX
@article{cunha2015evaluation,
  author = {J. Adam M. Cunha and Katherine Mellis and Rajni Sethi and Timmy Siauw and Atchar Sudhyadhom and Animesh Garg and Ken Goldberg and I‐Chow Hsu and Jean Pouliot},
  title = {{Evaluation of PC‐ISO for customized, 3D printed, gynecologic HDR brachytherapy applicators}},
  journal = {Journal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1120/jacmp.v16i1.5168},
}
Figure