Evaluation of Neural Network Effectiveness on Sliding Mode Control of Delta Robot for Trajectory Tracking

Anni Zhao, Arash Toudeshki, Reza Ehsani, Joshua H. Viers, Jian-Qiao SunAlgorithms 2024 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of controlling Delta robots, which are known for their complex nonlinear dynamics. The authors propose a novel approach by using neural networks to create a data-driven, control-affine model of the robot. This model is then integrated with a sliding mode controller to achieve highly accurate trajectory tracking, demonstrating promising results in simulations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Delta robots are powerful parallel manipulators used in various applications like assembly and pick-and-place tasks. However, their highly nonlinear kinematics and dynamics make precise control a significant challenge. Traditional control methods often rely on accurate analytical models, which are difficult to derive for Delta robots due to their complexity. This reliance on precise models can lead to poor performance when dealing with uncertainties or disturbances. The paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a robust control strategy that doesn't require a perfect analytical model, specifically focusing on improving trajectory tracking accuracy.

Methods

The core of this research lies in a hybrid approach combining neural networks with sliding mode control (SMC).

  • Data-Driven Control-Affine Model: Instead of deriving a model from first principles (Newton's laws or Lagrange's equations), the authors employ neural networks to learn the robot's input-output dynamics. They specifically aim for a "control-affine" model, which has a standard form that simplifies controller design. The inputs to this model are the stepper motor joint angles and velocities, and the outputs are the end-effector positions. This model is trained using randomly sampled data from a sufficiently large workspace.
  • Sliding Mode Control (SMC): Once the neural network model is trained, it's used as the basis for designing a sliding mode controller. SMC is chosen for its robustness to uncertainties and disturbances. The controller is designed to drive the robot's state onto a predefined sliding surface, ensuring stable and accurate tracking. To mitigate the common issue of "chattering" in SMC, the authors use a continuous approximation (tanh function) instead of a discontinuous sign function.

Datasets

The paper does not introduce new benchmark datasets. Instead, it generates its own training and validation data using a SimScape model of the Delta robot. This model is built to be a "digital twin" of the physical robot, using the parameters listed in the paper.

  • Training Data Generation: Random joint angles are sampled within a defined range (θᵢ ∈ [-30°, 120°]) to cover the robot's workspace.
  • Data Split: 75% of the sampled data is used for training the neural networks, and the remaining 25% is used for validation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Data-Driven Modeling for Complex Systems: The paper demonstrates that neural networks can effectively learn the complex, nonlinear dynamics of a robot like the Delta robot, even when analytical modeling is intractable. This opens doors for controlling systems where first-principles modeling is a bottleneck.
  • Control-Affine Form Simplifies Design: By focusing on a control-affine neural network model, the authors create a structure that is amenable to established control design techniques like SMC, making the integration smoother.
  • SMC Robustness Leveraged: The choice of SMC leverages its inherent robustness to handle the model inaccuracies and potential disturbances that might arise in real-world implementations, even with a data-driven model.
  • Chattering Mitigation: The use of the tanh function as a continuous approximation for the sign function in the SMC law is a practical step towards reducing undesirable oscillations in the control output.

Key Results

The proposed neural network-based sliding mode control approach demonstrated excellent performance in simulations:

  • Trajectory Tracking Accuracy: The system achieved an average trajectory tracking error below 5 cm. More specifically, the maximum tracking errors for the x, y, and z coordinates across various trajectories (heart curve, logarithmic spiral, and spiral) were consistently around 0.011 m, with minimum errors reaching as low as 10⁻⁹ m.
  • Bounded Control Inputs: The simulations showed that the control inputs (joint torques/commands) remained within acceptable bounds, indicating a practical and stable control strategy.
  • Convergence: The theoretical analysis and simulation results suggest that the tracking errors converge to zero at an exponential rate.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simulation vs. Real-World: The current study relies entirely on numerical simulations. The authors acknowledge that implementing this approach on a physical Delta robot presents challenges due to factors like parameter variations (frames, arms, joints), backlash, and joint flexibility.
  • Hyper-parameter Tuning: The paper notes that the chosen hyper-parameters for the neural networks were not guaranteed to be optimal and were selected through trial and error.
  • Future Work:
    • Experimental Validation: The most immediate next step is to validate the proposed neural network model and control design on a physical Delta robot.
  • Transfer Learning: The authors suggest using transfer learning to further refine the neural network model and update SMC parameters as new experimental data becomes available. This would allow the system to adapt to real-world conditions and improve performance over time.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Delta robot is an over-actuated parallel robot with highly nonlinear kinematics and dynamics. Designing the control for a Delta robot to carry out various operations is a challenging task. Various advanced control algorithms, such as adaptive control, sliding mode control, and model predictive control, have been investigated for trajectory tracking of the Delta robot. However, these control algorithms require a reliable input–output model of the Delta robot. To address this issue, we have created a control-affine neural network model of the Delta robot with stepper motors. This is a completely data-driven model intended for control design consideration and is not derivable from Newton’s law or Lagrange’s equation. The neural networks are trained with randomly sampled data in a sufficiently large workspace. The sliding mode control for trajectory tracking is then designed with the help of the neural network model. Extensive numerical results are obtained to show that the neural network model together with the sliding mode control exhibits outstanding performance, achieving a trajectory tracking error below 5 cm on average for the Delta robot. Future work will include experimental validation of the proposed neural network input–output model for control design for the Delta robot. Furthermore, transfer learnings can be conducted to further refine the neural network input–output model and the sliding mode control when new experimental data become available.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhao2024evaluation,
  author = {Anni Zhao and Arash Toudeshki and Reza Ehsani and Joshua H. Viers and Jian-Qiao Sun},
  title = {{Evaluation of Neural Network Effectiveness on Sliding Mode Control of Delta Robot for Trajectory Tracking}},
  booktitle = {Algorithms},
  year = {2024},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=fYr2RZplmg},
}
Figure