Evaluation of Multi-Satellite Precipitation Products and Their Ability in Capturing the Characteristics of Extreme Climate Events over the Yangtze River Basin, China

Shuai Xiao, Jun Xia, Lei ZouWater 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study evaluates seven satellite precipitation products (SPPs) for their accuracy in capturing extreme climate events (ECEs) like heavy rainfall and drought across the Yangtze River Basin (YRB). The findings highlight that while CMORPH and GPM IMERG generally perform best, especially in complex terrain, SPP accuracy varies significantly with region and timescale, underscoring the need for careful product selection for ECE monitoring.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurate precipitation data is crucial for understanding and predicting extreme climate events (ECEs), which are becoming more frequent and intense due to climate change and human activities. However, obtaining reliable precipitation data is challenging in regions with limited ground-based rain gauge networks, particularly in mountainous or economically disadvantaged areas. Satellite Precipitation Products (SPPs) offer a promising solution due to their high spatial and temporal resolution, covering vast areas globally. Yet, the accuracy and suitability of these SPPs for ECE analysis, especially in diverse geographical regions like the Yangtze River Basin (YRB) with its varied topography, remain a critical question. This paper aims to address this by comprehensively evaluating the performance of several leading SPPs in capturing both extreme precipitation and drought characteristics within the YRB.

Methods

The study employed a multi-faceted evaluation approach. First, the accuracy of seven SPPs was assessed against ground-based rain gauge data across different temporal scales: annual, monthly, and daily. This involved using standard statistical metrics such as the Pearson correlation coefficient (R), root-mean-square error (RMSE), and bias. For daily precipitation, categorical skill metrics like the Probability of Detection (POD), False Alarm Ratio (FAR), Frequency Bias Index (FBI), and Equitable Threat Score (ETS) were utilized, with various rainfall thresholds applied to assess performance for different rainfall intensities.

To specifically evaluate the SPPs' ability to capture ECEs, the researchers calculated eight extreme precipitation indices (e.g., maximum daily precipitation, total annual precipitation in wet days) and the Standardized Precipitation Index (SPI) for drought monitoring. The correlation between SPP-derived indices and those from rain gauge data was then analyzed. Spatial heterogeneity of SPP performance was also investigated by examining performance across the upper, middle, and lower reaches of the YRB.

Datasets

  • Reference Data: Daily precipitation data from 198 meteorological stations in the Yangtze River Basin (YRB), provided by the China Meteorological Administration (CMA) for the period 2003–2017.
  • Satellite Precipitation Products (SPPs):
    • CHIRPS v2.0 (0.25° and 0.05° resolution)
    • CMORPH (0.25° resolution)
    • GPM IMERG V06 (0.1° resolution)
    • TRMM-3B42V7 (0.25° resolution)
    • PERSIANN-Climate Data Record (CDR) (0.25° resolution)
    • PERSIANN-Cloud Classification System (CCS) (0.04° resolution)

The study used an overlapping period of 2003–2017 for all SPPs and the reference data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • No Single SPP is Universally Best: Different SPPs excel at different timescales and for different types of events. This highlights the importance of selecting the right tool for the specific research question.
  • Topography Matters (A Lot): Mountainous regions pose a significant challenge for most SPPs, leading to reduced accuracy. CMORPH and GPM IMERG show an advantage here, likely due to their improved algorithms for complex terrain.
  • Coastal Areas are Tricky Too: Estuarine and coastal regions also present accuracy issues for SPPs, possibly due to air-sea interactions and complex geometries.
  • Daily vs. Long-Term Accuracy: SPPs generally perform better at capturing annual and monthly precipitation patterns than daily variations, especially for extreme events.
  • ECE Capture is Linked: An SPP's ability to accurately represent extreme precipitation often correlates with its ability to capture drought characteristics, suggesting a common underlying performance factor.

Key Results

  • Overall Accuracy: CMORPH showed the best agreement with ground data on daily and annual scales, while GPM IMERG performed well on the monthly scale.
  • ECE Monitoring: GPM IMERG and CMORPH generally provided higher precision for ECE monitoring.
  • Spatial Heterogeneity: Most SPPs exhibited lower accuracy in the mountainous upper reaches and the estuary/coastal areas of the lower reaches, with better performance in the middle plains.
  • Extreme Precipitation: GPM IMERG and CMORPH performed better in capturing extreme precipitation across all reaches. However, SPPs struggled more with capturing the frequency and intensity of extreme precipitation in the lower reaches.
  • Drought Monitoring: GPM IMERG and CMORPH showed the best performance in reproducing the observed SPI-3 (seasonal drought index), particularly in the middle and lower reaches. However, all SPPs showed limitations in accurately capturing the number of severe drought events, especially in the upper reach.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Spatial Heterogeneity Impact: The study acknowledges that complex terrain and coastal areas significantly impact SPP accuracy for ECE monitoring. More research is needed to understand these mechanisms and develop improved algorithms.
  • SPP Algorithm Improvements: While CMORPH and GPM IMERG showed superior performance in mountainous areas, suggesting improved algorithms, there's a continuous need for further refinement of SPP algorithms to enhance their accuracy across diverse geographical conditions.
  • ECE Monitoring Nuances: The study suggests that while SPP accuracy generally correlates with ECE capture ability, further investigation into the specific mechanisms driving this relationship is warranted.
  • Data Limitations: The study focused on a specific region (YRB) and time period (2003-2017). Future work could expand this analysis to other regions and longer time series to generalize findings.

Summary updated

Abstract

Against the background of global climate change and anthropogenic stresses, extreme climate events (ECEs) are projected to increase in both frequency and intensity. Precipitation is one of the main climate parameters for ECE analysis. However, accurate precipitation information for extreme climate events research from dense rain gauges is still difficult to obtain in mountainous or economically disadvantaged regions. Satellite precipitation products (SPPs) with high spatial and temporal resolution offer opportunities to monitor ECE intensities and trends on large spatial scales. In this study, the accuracies of seven SPPs on multiple spatiotemporal scales in the Yangtze River Basin (YRB) during the period of 2003–2017 are evaluated, along with their ability to capture ECE characteristics. The seven products are the Tropical Rainfall Measuring Mission, Climate Hazards Group InfraRed Precipitation with Station Data (CHIRPS) (25), CHIRPS (05), Climate Prediction Center Morphing (CMORPH), Precipitation Estimation from Remotely Sensed Information using Artificial Neural Networks (PERSIANN)-Climate Data Record, PERSIANN-Cloud Classification System, and Global Precipitation Measurement (GPM) IMERG. Rain gauge precipitation data provided by the China Meteorological Administration are adopted as reference data. Various statistical evaluation metrics and different ECE indexes are used to evaluate and compare the performances of the selected products. The results show that CMORPH has the best agreement with the reference data on the daily and annual scales, but GPM IMERG performs relatively well on the monthly scale. With regard to ECE monitoring in the YRB, in general, GPM IMERG and CMORPH provide higher precision. As regards the spatial heterogeneity of the SPP performance in the YRB, most of the examined SPPs have poor accuracy in the mountainous areas of the upper reach. Only CMORPH and GPM IMERG exhibit superior performance; this is because they feature an improved inversion precipitation algorithm for mountainous areas. Furthermore, most SPPs have poor ability to capture extreme precipitation in the estuaries of the lower reach and to monitor drought in the mountainous areas of the upper reach. This study can provide a reference for SPP selection for ECE analysis.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xiao2020evaluation,
  author = {Shuai Xiao and Jun Xia and Lei Zou},
  title = {{Evaluation of Multi-Satellite Precipitation Products and Their Ability in Capturing the Characteristics of Extreme Climate Events over the Yangtze River Basin, China}},
  booktitle = {Water},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/w12041179},
}
Figure