Evaluation of mechanical and thermal stress in an endodontically treated cracked premolar with three restorative designs: 3D-finite element analysis

Hanxian Fang, Peipei Wu, Cheng Qian, Yifan Gu, Y. Lu, Sheng Fang, Kailun Chen, Anna Qiu, Hongjie Huang, Qi Chen, Rui HeJournal of Prosthodontic Research 2025 · DOI

Abstract

From a mechanical perspective, the outcome of this study suggested that a full crown restoration is not the optimal choice for preventing further crack propagation. Additionally, it is recommended to reduce the consumption of excessively hot foods and beverages daily.

Introduction

"Cracked tooth syndrome" presents a significant clinical challenge, particularly after a tooth has undergone endodontic (root canal) treatment, which leaves it more susceptible to fracture. Dentists must decide on the most effective restoration to prevent crack propagation and avoid tooth loss. While full crowns are traditionally considered the gold standard for protection, their necessity is debated against more conservative options like inlays or onlays. Most existing research focuses solely on mechanical biting forces. This study addresses this gap by using 3D Finite Element Analysis (FEA) to evaluate the combined impact of mechanical loads and transient thermal stresses—such as those from hot or cold beverages—on crack progression.

Methods

The study utilized a sophisticated 3D FEA workflow to simulate various clinical scenarios. A high-fidelity geometric model was developed from a CBCT scan of a healthy maxillary second premolar. A 20 μm thick crack was digitally introduced 1 mm above the cementoenamel junction. Four restoration designs were modeled: a resin-filled unrepaired base, an inlay, an onlay, and a full crown.

3D Finite Element Model showing geometry (A), mesh (B), and loading conditions (C).

The simulation applied six coupled loading conditions combining vertical (600 N) and oblique (200 N at 45°) mechanical loads with thermal cycles (Hot: 60°C; Cold: 4°C) relative to a baseline oral temperature of 36.5°C. Von-Mises Stress (VMS) was measured at 20 points along the crack's lower margin to predict material failure and crack propagation risk. Material properties, including Young’s modulus and thermal expansion coefficients, were sourced from established literature.

Results

The analysis revealed several critical insights that challenge conventional restorative practices:

  • The Crown Paradox: Contrary to expectations, the full crown exhibited the highest stress concentration at the crack tip under lateral loading and hot thermal cycles. This is likely due to the extensive tooth preparation required for a crown, which weakens the essential "ferrule" structure near the crack.
  • Thermal Sensitivity: Hot thermal loading was found to be significantly more damaging than cold loading. The expansion of materials under heat generates outward "splitting" forces that intensify stress at the crack tip.
  • Impact of Lateral Forces: Oblique loads (200 N) induced higher stress at the crack tip than much larger vertical loads (600 N). The horizontal component of lateral forces acts as a wedge, actively promoting crack expansion.
  • Performance of Restorations: Under oblique loading, the crown showed a VMS of 22.56 MPa, notably higher than the inlay (18.50 MPa) and onlay (18.75 MPa). The highest stress in restored groups (25.74 MPa) occurred in the crown under hot thermal-oblique coupling.

Discussion and Conclusion

The findings suggest that conservative restorations like inlays and onlays may be superior to full crowns in managing cracked, endodontically treated teeth, particularly by preserving more natural tooth structure and providing better stress distribution. The study highlights that lateral forces and high-temperature thermal shocks are the primary drivers of crack propagation.

While the model assumes perfect bonding and isotropic material properties, it provides a compelling biomechanical argument for reconsidering the "full crown" default. Future research should explore diverse ceramic materials and more complex, dynamic loading patterns to further refine clinical guidelines for treating cracked teeth.

Summary updated

Abstract

From a mechanical perspective, the outcome of this study suggested that a full crown restoration is not the optimal choice for preventing further crack propagation. Additionally, it is recommended to reduce the consumption of excessively hot foods and beverages daily.
BibTeX
@article{fang2025evaluation,
  author = {Hanxian Fang and Peipei Wu and Cheng Qian and Yifan Gu and Y. Lu and Sheng Fang and Kailun Chen and Anna Qiu and Hongjie Huang and Qi Chen and Rui He},
  title = {{Evaluation of mechanical and thermal stress in an endodontically treated cracked premolar with three restorative designs: 3D-finite element analysis}},
  journal = {Journal of Prosthodontic Research},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.2186/jpr.jpr\_d\_24\_00098},
}
Figure