Evaluation of Cultural and Creative Products of Jinshan Farmer Painting Using Fuzzy Analytic Hierarchy Process

Chen Liu, Hong-Mei Dai, Yuan Shen, Yuxuan Liu2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a Fuzzy Analytic Hierarchy Process (FAHP) framework to evaluate the success factors of cultural and creative products derived from Jinshan Farmer Painting. The study identifies market demand, design innovation, and traditional cultural inheritance as crucial indicators, with market demand and design innovation emerging as the most influential.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The preservation and innovation of traditional art forms in the face of globalization and evolving consumer culture presents a significant challenge. Jinshan Farmer Painting, a distinct Chinese folk art, is being integrated into cultural and creative products. However, effectively evaluating the success of these products, which must balance cultural heritage with market viability, is complex. This paper addresses the need for a robust evaluation system to identify the key drivers of success for such products, moving beyond subjective assessments to a more structured, data-driven approach.

Methods

The study employs the Fuzzy Analytic Hierarchy Process (FAHP), a hybrid approach that combines the structural advantages of the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) with fuzzy set theory.

  • AHP: Used to break down the complex evaluation problem into a hierarchical structure of criteria and sub-criteria. This involves pairwise comparisons of factors to determine their relative importance.
  • Fuzzy Set Theory: Incorporated to handle the inherent uncertainty and vagueness in expert judgments. Fuzzy numbers are used to represent linguistic terms (e.g., "important," "very important") from expert questionnaires, allowing for more nuanced and less subjective evaluations.

The process involved:

  1. Literature Review: To establish an initial set of evaluation indicators.
  2. Hierarchical Framework Construction: Organizing indicators into primary (cultural value, market potential, innovation, sustainability) and secondary levels.
  3. Questionnaire Design: A Likert scale questionnaire was used for expert opinions, with fuzzy linguistic scales for pairwise comparisons.
  4. Data Analysis: Expert opinions were converted into triangular fuzzy numbers. Group aggregation (Buckley's geometric mean method) was used to combine these opinions.
  5. Fuzzy Weight Calculation & Defuzzification: Fuzzy weights were calculated and then defuzzified using the centroid method to obtain crisp values.
  6. Normalization & Hierarchical Integration: Weights were normalized, and hierarchical linkage was applied to derive final overall weights for each indicator.
  7. Consistency Check: The consistency of expert judgments was verified using the Consistency Index (CI) and Consistency Ratio (CR).

Datasets

The study utilized a dataset derived from a questionnaire survey administered to 12 experts. These experts included individuals from cultural and creative industries, folk art research, marketing, innovation design, sustainable development, and practitioners from the cultural creative product industry. The paper also references entries from the "Shanghai Bay Area Painting Jinshan" 2nd Jinshan Farmer Painting Cultural and Creative Product Design Competition for practical verification.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Balancing Tradition and Modernity: The core challenge for Jinshan Farmer Painting products is to successfully blend traditional artistic elements with modern market demands and consumer expectations.
  • FAHP as a Robust Tool: The FAHP proves effective in quantifying subjective expert opinions and handling the inherent uncertainties in evaluating cultural products, offering a more reliable assessment than traditional methods.
  • Market-Driven Innovation: While cultural heritage is vital, market demand and design innovation are identified as the most significant drivers of success. This suggests that products must not only be culturally rich but also appealing and practical to consumers.
  • Holistic Evaluation: The framework considers multiple dimensions (cultural value, market potential, innovation, sustainability), emphasizing that a successful product requires a balance across these areas.

Key Results

The study identified four primary indicators: Cultural Value (0.309), Market Potential (0.258), Innovation (0.227), and Sustainability (0.206).

  • Top Secondary Indicators:
    • Market Demand (0.100): The most critical factor overall, highlighting the need for thorough market assessment.
  • Design Innovation (0.087) & Traditional Culture Heritage (0.088): These are crucial for creating unique and culturally resonant products.
  • Market Competitiveness (0.086) & Environmental Friendliness (0.062): Important for long-term success and meeting modern consumer expectations.
  • Product Evaluation: In a practical verification using three design entries (music box, bowl and spoon set, coaster):
  • The bowl and spoon set scored highest overall (57.833), excelling in market potential and innovation.
  • The music box scored highest in cultural value and social impact (54.833), demonstrating strong cultural representation.
  • The coaster scored well in cultural symbolism and environmental friendliness (51.750).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Sample Size: The authors acknowledge that the limited sample size of experts might not capture all perspectives, and the findings might not be generalizable to all folk art or cultural products in different regions.
  • Subjectivity in Expert Opinions: While FAHP mitigates subjectivity, expert opinions can still introduce biases.
  • Focus on Jinshan Farmer Painting: The study is specific to this particular art form, limiting direct application to other cultural products without adaptation.

Future Work Suggestions: * Expand the range of expertise and include more respondents from diverse backgrounds. * Optimize the FAHP model by incorporating other multi-criteria decision-making methods like TOPSIS for more accurate evaluation. * Explore similar evaluation approaches for traditional arts in different regions to assess their potential in the cultural and creative industries. * Developers should focus on combining cultural heritage with innovative design, emphasizing market demand, and developing effective brand strategies, while also considering sustainability.

Summary updated

Abstract

We evaluated the cultural and creative products of Jinshan Farmer Painting in Shanghai, utilizing the fuzzy analytic hierarchy process (FAHP) to determine the key evaluation indicators. Through a literature review, we constructed a hierarchical framework of evaluation indicators. A questionnaire survey was then conducted to collect expert opinions, followed by FAHP weight calculation and analysis. Finally, the consistency of the evaluation results was verified. The results revealed that market demand, design innovation, and traditional cultural inheritance are the key indicators influencing the success of Jinshan Farmer Painting cultural products. Among these, market demand and design innovation have the highest weights in the overall evaluation, highlighting the critical role of market acceptance and product innovation in the success of cultural products. Additionally, the emphasis on traditional cultural inheritance and cultural symbolism in cultural value underscores the importance of cultural content and artistic expression in a product’s success. These results provide practical information for the development of Jinshan Farmer Painting cultural products and offer a theoretical basis for future research.
BibTeX
@misc{liu2025evaluation,
  author = {Chen Liu and Hong-Mei Dai and Yuan Shen and Yuxuan Liu},
  title = {{Evaluation of Cultural and Creative Products of Jinshan Farmer Painting Using Fuzzy Analytic Hierarchy Process}},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/engproc2025098046},
}
Figure