TL;DR
This paper presents a step-by-step geophysical prospecting method to accurately identify and map abandoned underground coal mines (goafs) that threaten highway infrastructure. By combining high-density resistivity and high-resolution seismic surveys, followed by targeted drilling and borehole imaging, the study effectively delineates the goaf's extent and the overlying "three belts" of deformation, providing crucial data for highway stability assessments.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Abandoned underground coal mines, known as goafs, pose a significant threat to surface infrastructure, including highways. Subsidence, cracking, and even collapse can occur due to the degradation of these old mine workings, exacerbated by factors like water infiltration and time. Accurate detection and characterization of these goafs are essential for evaluating the stability of overlying structures and ensuring safety. However, obtaining this information is challenging, especially when historical mining data is scarce or unreliable. Traditional methods often lack precision or are prohibitively expensive. This paper addresses the critical need for an effective and efficient method to locate and map these hidden goafs and their associated deformation zones, specifically in the context of highway infrastructure.
Methods
The study employs a progressive, multi-stage detection strategy:
- Initial Disaster Investigation: This involves surveying the expressway and surrounding areas for visible signs of subsidence, cracks, and other geological disasters to identify potential affected zones.
- Step-by-Step Geophysical Prospecting:
- High-Density Resistivity (HDR) Method: This technique is used for initial broad-area detection. It measures the electrical resistivity of the subsurface, with goafs often exhibiting anomalous high-resistance characteristics (if filled with collapsed rock) or low-resistance anomalies (if filled with water and conductive ions). The method is applied in stages, starting with longer survey lines and progressively narrowing down to smaller, more targeted areas.
- High-Resolution Seismic (HRS) Method: Once potential goaf areas are identified by HDR, HRS is employed for more precise mapping. This method analyzes the travel times and characteristics of seismic waves to delineate the goaf's position, shape, and the distribution of the three deformation belts (curved subsidence zone, water-filled fractured zone, and caving zone).
- Verification and Correction:
- Deep Drilling: Boreholes are drilled into suspected goaf areas to obtain direct samples and geological data.
- Acoustic Detection (Borehole Wave Velocity Test): This technique measures the speed of seismic waves through the rock mass in boreholes, providing insights into the rock's integrity and the presence of fractures or voids.
- Borehole TV Imaging: This provides visual confirmation of subsurface conditions, allowing for direct observation of the goaf, cavities, and rock mass characteristics.
This combination of geophysical methods and direct verification techniques aims to overcome the limitations of individual methods and provide a comprehensive and accurate understanding of the abandoned goaf.
Datasets
The study utilizes data collected from the Tengzhou Section of China's Mu Shi Expressway. This includes:
- Surface disaster survey data: Observations of cracks, subsidence, and collapse pits along the expressway and surrounding areas.
- Regional coal mining information: Data collected from the Municipal Mining Bureau and Municipal Highway Bureau, though detailed mining drawings were unavailable.
- Shallow drilling data: Existing geological information from previous investigations.
- Geophysical survey data: Apparent resistivity profiles and inverse model resistivity sections from HDR surveys, and seismic reflection profiles from HRS surveys.
- Borehole data: Information from three characteristic boreholes (K3+732, K3+800, K3+767) including hole depth, drop depth, and drill rod detection cavity height.
-
Acoustic wave detection data: Wave velocity measurements from borehole No. 2.
-
Borehole TV imaging data: Visual records from borehole No. 2.
No new benchmark datasets were introduced; the study focuses on applying existing techniques to a specific engineering case.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Progressive Detection is Key: The "step-by-step" approach, moving from broad geophysical surveys to targeted seismic analysis and finally to direct borehole verification, is crucial for efficiently and accurately locating goafs, especially when detailed mining data is absent.
- Complementary Geophysical Methods: Combining HDR and HRS provides a more robust understanding than either method alone. HDR identifies anomalous zones, while HRS precisely maps their geometry and internal structure.
- The "Three Belts" are Critical Indicators: Identifying the curved subsidence zone, water-filled fractured zone, and caving zone provides a detailed picture of the goaf's impact on the overlying strata, essential for stability assessment.
- Borehole Verification is Indispensable: While geophysical methods are powerful, direct verification through drilling, acoustic logging, and TV imaging is vital for confirming interpretations and correcting potential errors, especially in complex geological settings.
- Water is a Major Factor: The presence of groundwater significantly influences goaf behavior and detection results, often leading to low-resistance anomalies in resistivity surveys and affecting wave propagation in seismic and acoustic methods.
Key Results
The study successfully identified and characterized an abandoned goaf affecting the Tengzhou Section of the Mu Shi Expressway. Key findings include:
- Goaf Location: The goaf is located within the K3+580~K3+830 section on the north side and K3+580~K3+900 section on the south side of the expressway, with a lateral extent of approximately 30 meters.
- Depth and "Three Belts" Distribution:
- The curved subsidence zone is found at a depth of approximately 35 meters.
- The water-filled fractured zone extends from 35 to 75 meters.
- The caving zone (goaf) is located between 75 and 90 meters.
- Average Goaf Height: The average height of the abandoned goaf is estimated to be 4.5 meters.
- Goaf Condition: The goaf is largely filled with collapsed rock and groundwater, though some distinct roadway features remain.
- Verification Success: Borehole data (drilling, acoustic, and TV imaging) confirmed the geophysical interpretations, showing consistency in the identified deformation zones and the goaf's condition.
Limitations and Future Work
- Limited Mining Data: The study was conducted without detailed historical mining drawings, which is a common challenge in such investigations. This necessitated a greater reliance on geophysical interpretation and verification.
- Irregular Goaf Shape: The irregular nature of abandoned goafs can lead to interpretation complexities and requires careful error distribution analysis for accurate correction.
- Potential for Disturbance: Intense verification drilling, while necessary, can potentially disturb the goaf's stability, a risk that needs careful management.
Future work could focus on developing more advanced inversion models that can better handle the complex geometries and material properties of abandoned goafs. Further research into integrating multiple geophysical techniques with machine learning for automated interpretation could also enhance efficiency and accuracy. The study also highlights the ongoing risk of secondary activation of abandoned goafs due to external disturbances, underscoring the need for continuous monitoring and robust stability assessment strategies.
Summary updated