TL;DR
This paper introduces a novel hybrid approach combining entropy-weighted TOPSIS and RSR fuzzy set methods to comprehensively evaluate the effectiveness of basic public health services in Hohhot, Inner Mongolia. The study highlights regional disparities in service quality and identifies key indicators for future focus, offering valuable insights for improving public health initiatives in similar regions.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Ensuring the equitable and effective delivery of basic public health services is a critical challenge for governments worldwide. While various evaluation methods exist, there's a need for robust, multi-faceted approaches that can capture the nuances of service performance and identify areas for improvement. This paper addresses the problem of evaluating the effectiveness of basic public health services in a specific region (Hohhot, Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region, China) by developing and applying a combined analytical framework. The authors aim to clarify the implementation status of these services, identify outstanding problems, and provide theoretical content and suggestions for similar regions, both domestically and internationally. The existing methods, while useful, may have limitations in capturing the complexity of multiple indicators and subjective weighting, leading to a need for a more integrated and objective evaluation.
Methods
The core of this research lies in a hybrid evaluation methodology that combines two established techniques:
- Entropy-weighted TOPSIS (Technique for Order Preference by Similarity to an Ideal Solution): This method is used to rank evaluation objects based on their proximity to an ideal solution. The "entropy weight" aspect is crucial here, as it objectively determines the weight of each indicator based on the information it provides, reducing subjective bias. The process involves standardizing data, calculating indicator weights using entropy, determining positive and negative ideal solutions, and then calculating the closeness coefficient (Ci) for each evaluation object.
- RSR (Rank-Sum Ratio) Fuzzy Set: This method is employed for a more comprehensive evaluation and staging of the services. It involves ranking evaluation objects, calculating the RSR statistic, and then using a fuzzy set approach to combine the RSR values with the TOPSIS scores. The paper explores three different weighting ratios for combining TOPSIS (C) and RSR values (0.1C+0.9RSR, 0.5C+0.5RSR, and 0.9C+0.1RSR) to provide a more nuanced understanding of the results.
The synergy of these methods aims to overcome the limitations of using either technique alone, offering a more distinguishable and measurable analysis by leveraging both ratio weighting and graded calculation.
Datasets
The study utilizes data from the 2021 annual report data of public health service project performance assessment in Hohhot City, Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region, China. This data was provided by the Health and Health Commission of Hohhot City. The researchers selected 14 primary health care service centers (denoted as X1-X14) from the district, including community health service centers and township health centers, for their analysis. The evaluation was based on 23 specific indicators derived from the "2018 National Basic Public Health Service Project" guidelines.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Objective Weighting is Key: The use of the entropy weight method for indicator weighting is a significant advantage, as it relies solely on the data itself, minimizing subjective bias often present in other methods.
- Regional Disparities Exist: The study clearly demonstrates that despite a generally balanced performance, there are notable differences in the quality of basic public health services across different districts within Hohhot. This highlights the need for targeted interventions to address these inequalities.
- Focus on Key Populations: Certain indicators, such as the health management rate of the elderly (both general and TCM-based) and BCG vaccination rates, carry higher weights. This suggests that future efforts should prioritize these areas, particularly for key demographic groups.
- Hybrid Approach Enhances Robustness: Combining TOPSIS and RSR methods provides a more comprehensive and reliable evaluation than either method alone, offering a richer perspective on service effectiveness.
- Policy and Economic Links: The study hints at a correlation between policy orientation, economic development, and the quality of basic public health services, suggesting that strategic-level decision-making is crucial.
Key Results
- Top Performing Indicators: The indicators with the highest weights were the TCM health management rate of the elderly (9.54%), the elderly health management rate (7.44%), and the BCG vaccination rate (7.26%).
- TOPSIS Evaluation: The entropy-weighted TOPSIS evaluation showed Ci values ranging from 0.378 to 0.715, indicating varying levels of service effectiveness across the evaluated centers.
- RSR Staging: The RSR staging method identified three community health centers (X2, X10, X13) as having "excellent" basic public health services. Two centers (X3, X9) were rated as "poor," and the remaining nine received "medium" ratings.
- Consistent Trends: The results from the entropy-weighted TOPSIS and the RSR fuzzy joint model were largely consistent, reinforcing the reliability of the findings.
- Fuzzy Combination Results: Across the three fuzzy combination ratios (0.1C+0.9RSR, 0.5C+0.5RSR, 0.9C+0.1RSR), X10, X13, and X2 consistently appeared among the top-performing institutions, underscoring their strong performance.
Limitations and Future Work
- Regional Focus: The study is specific to Hohhot City, Inner Mongolia. While it offers insights for similar regions, direct extrapolation to vastly different socio-economic or healthcare contexts may require caution.
- Data Specificity: The analysis is based on 2021 data, and future work could benefit from longitudinal studies to track changes and the impact of interventions over time.
- Indicator Balance: The discussion notes that differences in fuzzy combination results for some districts (e.g., X1, X3, X6) suggest an imbalance in the management of the 23 indicators, indicating areas where service delivery might be uneven.
- Future Research Directions: The authors suggest focusing future research on the key population-related items identified as having higher weights. They also advocate for a deeper exploration of the factors influencing regional differences in basic public health services and the development of more effective dynamic adjustment mechanisms for public health projects. There's also a call to strengthen pediatrics in community health centers and improve the timeliness and accessibility of medical services for children.
Summary updated