Evaluation of a Computer-Based Training Program for Enhancing Arithmetic Skills and Spatial Number Representation in Primary School Children

Larissa Rauscher, Juliane Kohn, Tanja Käser, Verena Mayer, Karin Kucian, Ursina McCaskey, Günter Esser, Michael von AsterFrontiers in Psychology 2016 · DOI

Abstract

Calcularis is a computer-based training program which focuses on basic numerical skills, spatial representation of numbers and arithmetic operations. The program includes a user model allowing flexible adaptation to the child's individual knowledge and learning profile. The study design to evaluate the training comprises three conditions (Calcularis group, waiting control group, spelling training group). One hundred and thirty-eight children from second to fifth grade participated in the study. Training duration comprised a minimum of 24 training sessions of 20 min within a time period of 6-8 weeks. Compared to the group without training (waiting control group) and the group with an alternative training (spelling training group), the children of the Calcularis group demonstrated a higher benefit in subtraction and number line estimation with medium to large effect sizes. Therefore, Calcularis can be used effectively to support children in arithmetic performance and spatial number representation.

Introduction

Early deficits in basic numerical skills are highly predictive of long-term mathematical difficulties. Traditional classroom settings often struggle to provide the individualized, repetitive, and stress-free practice required to bridge these gaps. While many educational math applications exist, few are built on rigorous neuropsychological models or have been empirically validated. This study addresses the need for evidence-based digital interventions that can adapt in real-time to a child's specific learning profile, focusing on the transition from basic number sense to formal arithmetic.

The Calcularis Intervention

The Calcularis program is grounded in the triple-code model and a four-step developmental model of numerical cognition. Its technical core is a dynamic Bayesian network user model that estimates the child's current knowledge state after every task and selects the next optimal challenge.

Calcularis interface showing (A) number line estimation for spatial representation and (B) subtraction tasks using structured blocks.

The training progresses hierarchically through number ranges (0–10, 0–100, etc.) and focuses on transcoding between notations (dots, Arabic digits, number words) and the development of a "mental number line."

Study Design and Participants

The study employed a randomized controlled trial (RCT) design with 138 children (grades 2–5) from Germany and Switzerland. Participants were assigned to three conditions:

  1. Calcularis Group (CAL): Received specialized math training.
  2. Waiting Control Group (WG): Received no intervention during the study period to control for natural development.
  3. Spelling Training Group (ST): An active control group receiving a computer-based spelling program (Dybuster) to control for the Hawthorne effect.
Baseline demographic and psychometric characteristics across the three experimental groups (CAL, WG, ST).

Evaluation was conducted using standardized psychometric instruments, including the BUEGA (intelligence and basic skills), HAWIK-IV (WISC-IV), and the Heidelberg Rechentest (HRT) for arithmetic fluency.

Key Results

Subtraction and Spatial Representation

The most significant gains were observed in subtraction and number line estimation. The Calcularis group showed a significantly higher increase in subtraction performance compared to the waiting control ($p = 0.001$, medium effect size) and the spelling group ($p = 0.045$, small effect size). Furthermore, children using Calcularis showed a higher gain in accuracy on the 0–100 number line compared to the spelling group ($p = 0.015$).

Linearity and Domain Specificity

The training significantly improved the linearity of children's mental number representation—shifting them away from "logarithmic" thinking (where large numbers are crowded together) toward a more accurate, linear scale. Because the Calcularis group outperformed the spelling group in math, the results suggest improvements were due to specific mathematical content and adaptive algorithms rather than the general benefit of using educational software.

Discussion and Limitations

The researchers noted that subtraction is more heavily dependent on a well-developed mental number line than addition, which often relies on rote memory. The lack of significant improvement in addition may be due to the program’s hierarchical logic, which requires mastering lower-level spatial tasks before unlocking complex arithmetic modules; the 6–8 week window may have been too short for some children to reach these advanced modules.

Future Work

While the study demonstrates immediate efficacy, limitations include a gender imbalance (two-thirds girls) and a relatively short intervention period. Future research should investigate if these gains persist long-term and if they transfer to other mathematical areas like multiplication and division.

Summary updated

Abstract

Calcularis is a computer-based training program which focuses on basic numerical skills, spatial representation of numbers and arithmetic operations. The program includes a user model allowing flexible adaptation to the child's individual knowledge and learning profile. The study design to evaluate the training comprises three conditions (Calcularis group, waiting control group, spelling training group). One hundred and thirty-eight children from second to fifth grade participated in the study. Training duration comprised a minimum of 24 training sessions of 20 min within a time period of 6-8 weeks. Compared to the group without training (waiting control group) and the group with an alternative training (spelling training group), the children of the Calcularis group demonstrated a higher benefit in subtraction and number line estimation with medium to large effect sizes. Therefore, Calcularis can be used effectively to support children in arithmetic performance and spatial number representation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{rauscher2016evaluation,
  author = {Larissa Rauscher and Juliane Kohn and Tanja Käser and Verena Mayer and Karin Kucian and Ursina McCaskey and Günter Esser and Michael von Aster},
  title = {{Evaluation of a Computer-Based Training Program for Enhancing Arithmetic Skills and Spatial Number Representation in Primary School Children}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2016.00913},
}
Figure