Evaluation Methods for the Human-Land Coupling Coordination Relationship in a Metro Station Area: A Case Study of Chengdu Metro Line 1

Zhiyue Qiu, Shirui Wen, Hong Yuan, Ziyi Liu, Yao Wei, Siqi Yanling, Runlong Dai, Xiang Li, Yuxin GuISPRS Int. J. Geo Inf 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel framework for evaluating the "human-land coupling coordination" in metro station areas, crucial for sustainable urban development. By analyzing Chengdu Metro Line 1, they reveal spatial patterns of coordination and identify key drivers, offering actionable strategies for better urban planning around transit hubs.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As cities grow and metro systems expand, a critical challenge emerges: ensuring that the development around metro stations is harmonious and sustainable. This isn't just about building more transit; it's about the intricate relationship between human activities (population, economy, industry) and the land and metro resources available. Uncoordinated development can lead to inefficient land use, traffic congestion, and a failure to fully leverage the benefits of metro infrastructure. Existing research often focuses on broader urban scales, leaving a gap in understanding the micro-level dynamics within specific metro station areas. This paper aims to fill that gap by developing and applying a method to quantitatively assess and understand the human-land coupling coordination in these vital urban nodes.

Methods

The study employs a multi-step approach:

  1. Indicator System Construction: An evaluation indicator system was developed, categorizing factors into two main systems: the "Human Activity Demand System" (M) and the "Metro Resource Supply System" (L). This system includes 17 specific indicators reflecting population growth, economic development, industrial agglomeration, service support, metro service scale, accessibility, and land value.
  2. Coupling Coordination Degree Model (CCDM):
    • Numerical Standardization: The range method was used to standardize indicator data, ensuring consistency across different units and scales.
  3. Entropy Weight Method (EWM): This method was applied to objectively determine the weight of each indicator based on its dispersion and influence.
  4. Coupling Degree (C) and Coordination Indicator (T): The CCDM calculates a coupling degree (C) to measure the interaction and interdependence between the human and land systems, and a coordination indicator (T) to assess the quality of this coupling.
  5. Coupling Coordination Degree (CCD): The final CCD value is derived from C and T, providing a comprehensive measure of the coordinated development. This value is then categorized into five levels, from "Serious Imbalance" to "High-Quality Coordination."
  6. Gray Relational Analysis (GRA): To identify the influencing factors on the CCD, GRA was used. This method measures the correlation between the CCD and each indicator, ranking their influence.
  7. GM(1,1) Model: This model was employed for future prediction of CCD levels in station areas.

Datasets

The study utilized multi-source data, including:

  • Population Density: China 100 m × 100 m population grid dataset.
  • Night-lighting Data: Global 500 m × 500 m NPP-VIIRS-like night-lighting grid data.
  • Average Land GDP: China's GDP spatial distribution grid dataset (1 km × 1 km).
  • POI Data: Points of Interest data from Gaode Open Platform (categorized into industrial parks, companies, public service facilities, etc.).
  • Metro Passenger Traffic Data: Average daily passenger traffic data for Chengdu Metro Line 1 stations.
  • Land Use Data: Interpreted from remote-sensing images.
  • Other Infrastructure Data: Including metro station entrances/exits, bus stops, road networks, and housing prices, sourced from Gaode map and OpenStreetMap.

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing datasets were integrated and analyzed within the developed framework.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond Simple Coupling: The study highlights that a high coupling degree (C) doesn't automatically mean good coordination. A high C can exist even with low development levels in both systems, emphasizing the need for the coordination indicator (T) and the final CCD for a true assessment.
  • Spatial Structure Matters: The human-land coordination in metro station areas exhibits distinct spatial patterns, not a uniform distribution. This suggests that planning strategies need to be spatially differentiated.
  • Centrality Drives Coordination: Proximity to the city center strongly correlates with higher levels of human-land coupling coordination, likely due to mature development and established infrastructure.
  • New Areas Need Targeted Support: Newly developed areas, even with good metro connections, may lag in coordination due to weaker population and industrial agglomeration effects, indicating a need for focused development policies.
  • Key Drivers Identified: Population concentration, activity intensity, economic development, and service support are identified as the most significant drivers of coupling coordination.

Key Results

  • Spatial Differentiation: The study found significant spatial differences in coupling coordination levels across Chengdu Metro Line 1.
  • Circular Structure: Station areas within 5 km of the central city (e.g., Tianfu Square) showed high levels of coupling and coordination. Coordination generally decreased with distance from the center.
  • Polycentric Structure: Beyond the central city, areas like the Chengdu High-Tech South Zone (Central Activities Zone) also exhibited high coordination, suggesting a multi-center development pattern.
  • Coordination Levels:
    • 5.7% of stations were in "Serious Imbalance."
    • 20% were in "Moderate Imbalance."
    • 20% were in "Basic Coordination."
    • 31.4% were in "Good Coordination."
    • 22.9% were in "High-Quality Coordination."
    • Overall, about 54.3% of stations showed moderate to high-quality coordination, but nearly half still require improvement.
  • Influencing Factors: The top influencing factors on CCD, ranked by Gray Relational Degree (GRD), were:
  • Night-lighting indicator (M12) (0.953)
    1. Accessibility of metro station (L22) (0.949)
    2. Service support (M42) (0.949)
    3. Number of catering facilities (M44) (0.945)
    4. Population density (M11) (0.933)
  • Future Predictions: The GM(1,1) model predicted that 54.3% of station areas would see improved coupling coordination by 2030, with stations in the Tianfu New District and CAZ showing significant advancements.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The study focuses on a single metro line (Chengdu Metro Line 1), which might limit the generalizability of findings to other cities or metro lines with different characteristics.
  • While the paper uses multi-source data, the accuracy and granularity of some datasets (e.g., POI data) could influence the precision of the analysis.
  • The definition of the "station area" (500m radius) is a simplification and might not perfectly capture all relevant human-land interactions.
  • Future Work:
    • The authors suggest optimizing the metro network layout, building multi-level urban centers, strengthening functional connections, and enhancing land development intensity to promote coordinated development.
  • Future research could expand the scope to include more cities and metro lines, explore different spatial scales for station areas, and incorporate more dynamic data sources to capture evolving urban dynamics.
  • Further investigation into the specific mechanisms driving the influence of identified factors would be beneficial.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{qiu2025evaluation,
  author = {Zhiyue Qiu and Shirui Wen and Hong Yuan and Ziyi Liu and Yao Wei and Siqi Yanling and Runlong Dai and Xiang Li and Yuxin Gu},
  title = {{Evaluation Methods for the Human-Land Coupling Coordination Relationship in a Metro Station Area: A Case Study of Chengdu Metro Line 1}},
  journal = {ISPRS Int. J. Geo Inf.},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/ijgi14030102},
}
Figure