Evaluation Method for Underwater Ultrasonic Energy Radiation Performance Based on the Spatial Distribution Characteristics of Acoustic Power

Zhongzheng Liu, Tao Zhang, Yazhen Yuan, Yuhang Li, Yanzhang Geng2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel method to evaluate the performance of underwater ultrasonic energy transmission by analyzing the spatial distribution of acoustic power. This approach offers a more accurate and comprehensive assessment than traditional methods, providing crucial insights for optimizing underwater wireless energy systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Underwater wireless ultrasonic energy transmission (UWUET) is a promising technology for powering submerged devices. However, effectively evaluating its performance has been a challenge. Current methods often rely solely on overall energy transfer efficiency, neglecting the detailed spatial distribution of acoustic power and how it's affected by complex underwater environments (like varying temperature and salinity). This oversight limits the accuracy of performance assessments and hinders the optimization of UWUET systems. The paper aims to bridge this gap by proposing a method that accounts for the spatial characteristics of acoustic power distribution.

Methods

The core of this research is a new evaluation method for underwater ultrasonic energy radiation performance based on the spatial distribution of acoustic power. This involves:

  • Acoustic Power Distribution Model: Developing a mathematical model for acoustic power distribution in complex impedance-density aqueous media, accounting for multi-parameter effects of the underwater environment (temperature, salinity, etc.).
  • Acoustic Wave Propagation Equations: Utilizing modified fluctuation and Helmholtz equations to describe sound wave propagation in these complex media.
  • Sound Power Calculation: Employing a method that integrates acoustic intensity over an effective radiant area, considering the spatial distribution of sound power.
  • Acoustic Radiation Efficiency: Defining and calculating efficiency based on the ratio of radiated power in a specific direction to the total radiated power.
  • Transducer Array Modeling: Developing a model for ultrasonic transducer arrays, including vibration and sound pressure calculations, to simulate realistic radiation scenarios.
  • Numerical Simulation and Experimental Validation: Using finite-element multiphysics simulation software and comparing results with traditional methods (like the half-power angle method) to validate the proposed approach.

Datasets

Not explicitly discussed in terms of "datasets" in the traditional machine learning sense. The paper uses simulated data generated through finite-element multiphysics field simulation software. The experimental validation relies on parameters defined in Table 1, which include environmental conditions (temperature, salinity, pH) and transducer array specifications (number of elements, radius, spacing, etc.).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Spatial Distribution is Key: The paper strongly emphasizes that simply looking at overall efficiency is insufficient. The way acoustic energy is distributed in space is critical for understanding and optimizing UWUET.
  • Environmental Factors Matter: The model explicitly incorporates environmental parameters like temperature and salinity, highlighting their significant impact on sound propagation and energy distribution.
  • Beyond the Main Lobe: Traditional methods like the half-power angle often focus on the main lobe of the radiation pattern, neglecting side-lobe energy. The proposed method offers a more holistic view by considering the entire spatial distribution.
  • Weighted Arrays vs. Uniform Arrays: The study demonstrates how different array weighting schemes (Chebyshev, Hamming, etc.) affect radiation patterns and efficiency, showing that while weighted arrays can suppress side lobes, uniform arrays might offer higher energy concentration in certain scenarios.
  • Temperature's Complex Role: Higher temperatures generally increase sound speed, which can enhance transmission, but also decrease density, leading to complex effects on acoustic impedance and overall efficiency.

Key Results

  • Improved Accuracy: The proposed method demonstrates higher accuracy in calculating acoustic energy radiation compared to traditional methods, particularly the half-power angle method.
  • Comprehensive Evaluation: The method provides a more comprehensive reflection of energy distribution and spatial heterogeneity of the sound source.
  • Monotonically Increasing Efficiency: The acoustic radiation efficiency calculated by the proposed method shows a monotonically increasing trend with the acoustic radiation angle, a finding that differs from the fluctuating results obtained by the half-power angle method.
  • Uniform Array Efficiency: For the tested configurations, the uniform array's energy radiation efficiency was found to be higher than that of weighted arrays, suggesting that acoustic energy concentration plays a more significant role than side-lobe suppression in certain UWUET applications.
  • Temperature Impact: Figure 13 shows that acoustic radiation efficiency varies with temperature, with an optimal range (around 4-20°C) before complex effects of water compressibility and heat exchange become more dominant.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The paper acknowledges that the half-power angle method's accuracy is limited by its focus on the main lobe and its inability to independently calculate specific acoustic-radiation-angle-specific power values.
  • The accuracy of simulations can be influenced by meshing quality, especially at smaller acoustic radiation radii.
  • The study primarily focuses on axisymmetric radiation from transducer arrays.
  • Future Work:
    • The authors suggest that their method provides a theoretical basis and practical guidance for optimizing the design and performance enhancement of underwater ultrasonic wireless energy transmission systems.
  • Further research could explore the application of this method to more complex underwater environments and different types of acoustic sources.
  • Investigating the impact of other environmental factors (e.g., pressure, currents) on acoustic propagation and energy distribution could be a valuable extension.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{liu2024evaluation,
  author = {Zhongzheng Liu and Tao Zhang and Yazhen Yuan and Yuhang Li and Yanzhang Geng},
  title = {{Evaluation Method for Underwater Ultrasonic Energy Radiation Performance Based on the Spatial Distribution Characteristics of Acoustic Power}},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/s24123942},
}

Loading related content...

Figure