Evaluation and refinement of a handheld health information technology tool to support the timely update of bedside visual cues to prevent falls in hospitals

Ruth Chu‐Ai Teh, Renuka Visvanathan, Damith C. Ranasinghe, Anne WilsonInternational Journal of Evidence-Based Healthcare 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This study evaluated a handheld health information technology (HIT) tool designed to improve bedside visual cues for fall prevention in hospitals. The research found that while clinicians were generally willing to use the tool and recognized its potential benefits, usability and time constraints were significant barriers. The findings highlight the importance of end-user involvement in refining technology to ensure its successful adoption and effectiveness in clinical settings.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Falls are a significant cause of hospital-acquired injuries, particularly among older adults, leading to increased length of stay, costs, and poorer patient outcomes. While various fall prevention strategies exist, their effectiveness is often hampered by implementation challenges and clinician adoption. Traditional methods, like paper-based posters with colored dots to indicate fall risk, were found to be time-consuming and had poor uptake. This paper addresses the need for more efficient and effective ways to communicate patient fall risk to healthcare providers, aiming to improve timely intervention and ultimately reduce inpatient falls.

Methods

This pilot study employed a mixed-methods research design, combining focus group discussions and Likert-scale surveys to gather clinician perspectives. The research was conducted in three phases:

  • Phase 1 (Pretrial): Focus groups and surveys were used to understand initial attitudes, perceived benefits, and potential barriers to using the HIT tool before its implementation.
  • Phase 2 (Tool Trial): The HIT tool, an iPad application that automatically generated visual cues for bedside display based on clinician input of fall risk factors, was implemented on two hospital wards over 12-week periods.
  • Phase 3 (Post-trial): Similar focus groups and surveys were conducted to evaluate clinicians' experiences and perspectives after using the tool.

Qualitative data from focus groups were analyzed using content analysis, while quantitative survey data were analyzed using descriptive statistics and logistic regression.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focused on clinician feedback and perspectives rather than a dataset for training or evaluation of a predictive model.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Visual Cues are Valued: Clinicians are already familiar with and value the use of visual cues for communicating patient fall risk, a practice that predates the HIT tool.
  • Technology as a Potential Solution: There's a recognized potential for health technology to streamline and improve the accuracy and timeliness of fall risk assessment and communication.
  • Usability and Time are Critical Barriers: Even with a well-intentioned technological solution, practical concerns like ease of use and the availability of time within a busy clinical workflow are paramount for adoption.
  • End-User Involvement is Key: The study strongly emphasizes that involving end-users (clinicians) throughout the development and refinement process is crucial for ensuring technology is accepted and effectively utilized.
  • Culture Matters: Shifting workplace culture to recognize hospital falls as a significant problem and embracing new technologies is a necessary precursor to successful implementation.

Key Results

  • Pretrial: Clinicians were familiar with visual cues but found existing paper posters tedious and ineffective. They anticipated benefits from a HIT tool in providing timely, useful falls risk assessment.
  • During the Trial: Ward implementation methods varied, leading to lower uptake on one ward. The HIT tool took less than 5 minutes per patient.
  • Post-trial: Clinicians remained supportive of the tool but highlighted issues with usability and lack of time. Staff who did not use the tool had significantly less appreciation for its benefits in improving understanding of fall risk factors and preventing falls (odds ratios of 0.12 for both).
  • Recommendations: Clinicians' feedback led to technological refinements, including improved usability and the provision of an additional iPad device for more efficient use.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations: * Small sample size. * Single hospital setting. * Poor response rate and lack of consistency in participant follow-up. * Incomplete data on survey participation and tool usage frequency. * Potential for researcher bias in interpreting qualitative data. * Reluctance of focus group participants to share candid opinions due to researcher presence.

Future Work: * Retrialing the refined HIT tool on wards to evaluate clinician use, perspectives, and clinical effectiveness in falls avoidance. * Implementing the tool in facilities with high fall prevalence and among high-risk patient populations (e.g., older adults, those in residential care). * Ensuring the same clinicians participate in pretrial and post-trial assessments for greater data robustness. * Including patients and caregivers in discussions. * Conducting personal interviews and discussing topics in more depth per focus group session.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study adds to the limited pool of knowledge about clinicians' attitudes toward health technology use in falls avoidance. Clinicians were willing to use the HIT tool, and their concerns about its usability were addressed in ongoing tool improvement. Including end-users in the development and refinement processes, as well as having high staff uptake of new technologies, is important in improving their acceptance and usage, and in maximizing beneficial feedback to further inform tool development.
BibTeX
@article{teh2017evaluation,
  author = {Ruth Chu‐Ai Teh and Renuka Visvanathan and Damith C. Ranasinghe and Anne Wilson},
  title = {{Evaluation and refinement of a handheld health information technology tool to support the timely update of bedside visual cues to prevent falls in hospitals}},
  journal = {International Journal of Evidence-Based Healthcare},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1097/xeb.0000000000000129},
}
Figure