Evaluating User Experience in Literary and Film Geography-based Apps with a Cartographical User-Centered Design Lens

Mina Rezaei, Patsy Eubanks Owens, Darnel DegandarXiv 2022 · DOI · arXiv

Introduction

The "spatial turn" in the humanities has fundamentally altered how we perceive the relationship between narrative and geography. Space is no longer viewed merely as a container for events but as a dynamic social and emotional construct. However, a significant gap exists between this academic understanding and the practical implementation of literary and film geography in digital applications. While university curricula emphasize the "lived experience" of space, most current apps function as digital brochures, reducing complex narratives to static coordinates on a map.

Theoretical Framework: Lefebvre’s Triad

To analyze this disconnect, the researchers utilized Henri Lefebvre’s influential "trilogy of space." This framework categorizes spatial experience into three interconnected dimensions:

  • Conceived Space: The space of planners, urbanists, and technocrats; it is tied to ideologies, rules, and abstract representations.
  • Perceived Space: The space of daily life and social practice, often linked to memory and routine.
  • Lived Space: The space of "users" and "inhabitants," encompassing social resistance, emotions, and personal meaning.
Lefebvre’s trilogy of space provides the theoretical foundation for analyzing how spatiality is taught versus how it is designed in apps.

Bridging the Academic-Industry Gap

The study involved a multi-stage qualitative analysis, beginning with the examination of 25 university course syllabi across geography, literature, and film departments. Using the MAXQDA 2020 code system, the researchers categorized course content according to Lefebvre’s triad.

The analysis revealed that while 90.9% of syllabi aimed to impart socio-spatial knowledge and research skills—heavily focusing on "Lived Space" (e.g., alienation, marginalized groups)—industry-developed platforms remained largely restricted to "Conceived Space." Most apps (such as Mappo or JoyceWays) prioritize navigation and physical locations, offering little room for users to engage with the emotional or social layers of the narrative.

The coding of syllabi for "Conceived Space" highlights themes like cinematic techniques and urban displacement, which are often simplified in commercial mapping apps.

A critical finding was the lack of domain expertise in app development; only two of the six platforms reviewed included cartographers or geographers on their teams. This absence often leads to designs that favor "immersive entertainment" over deep spatial analysis.

The Spatial User-Centered Design (SUCD) Framework

To address these shortcomings, the authors propose the Spatial User-Centered Design (SUCD) framework. This approach encourages designers to move beyond simple pins on a map and incorporate features that reflect the complexity of human experience.

Key design patterns within SUCD include:

  • Representing Perceived Space: Integrating features related to diversity, inclusion, and the evolving nature of the "future city."
  • Capturing Lived Space: Focusing on memories, emotions, and the voices of marginalized groups.
  • The Flâneur as a Design Pattern: Designing for the "flâneur"—the urban wanderer who experiences the city subjectively—allows apps to better represent the "lived" quality of stories.

To demonstrate this, the researchers developed a high-fidelity prototype for the film Lady Bird (2017), specifically designed to facilitate the subjective exploration of Sacramento through the protagonist's eyes.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The SUCD framework offers a roadmap for creating more educationally rich and immersive spatial platforms. However, challenges remain. Manually coding "lived experience" into apps is labor-intensive, suggesting a need for future research into computational methods like Natural Language Processing (NLP) to automate theme extraction. Furthermore, while the Lady Bird prototype is a proof of concept, empirical user testing is required to validate whether the SUCD approach actually enhances geographic learning and user engagement in real-world scenarios. Finally, the sustainability of these niche academic digital tools remains a concern, as many reviewed apps have already disappeared due to a lack of long-term funding.

Summary updated

Abstract

Geography scholarship currently includes interdisciplinary approaches and theories and reflects shifts in research methodologies. Since the spatial turn in geographical thought and the emergence of geo-web technologies, geography scholarship has leaned more toward interdisciplinarity. In recent years geographical research methods have relied on various disciplines ranging from data science to arts and design. Literary geography and film geography are two subfields of geography that employ novels and films in exploring spatiality, respectively. In addition to geographical concepts, these courses include many aspects of relations in space, including human-human relations, human-environment relations, et cetera, which were barely addressed in traditional geography courses. However, a review of the employment of geoweb technologies in literary and film geography practices reveals that these practices have mostly remained limited to isolating geographical passages from novels or movies. This paper explores new opportunities for designing film and literary geography-based apps using a cartographical user-centered design framework.
BibTeX
@misc{rezaei2022evaluating,
  author = {Mina Rezaei and Patsy Eubanks Owens and Darnel Degand},
  title = {{Evaluating User Experience in Literary and Film Geography-based Apps with a Cartographical User-Centered Design Lens}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2209.05734},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2209.05734},
}
Figure