Evaluating the Rationality of Land Share of Housing Value in China’s Urban Housing Market —Based on International Comparison and Risk Analysis

Xiaoping Zhou, Zhenyang Qin, Chai Duo, Zhao SongProceedings of the 3rd International Seminar on Education Innovation and Economic Management (SEIEM 2018) 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the rationality of China's land share of housing value by comparing it to international trends and conducting risk analyses. The study concludes that China's current land share is generally reasonable, falling within an internationally comparable range, and does not pose significant economic risks under various scenarios.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The rapid rise in housing and residential land prices in China has sparked concerns about potential real estate bubbles. A key factor in this discussion is the "land share of housing value," which represents the proportion of a property's total value attributed to the land itself. While this indicator is crucial for understanding the land and housing markets, comprehensive studies on the rationality of China's land share have been limited. Existing research often lacks a clear definition of rationality, uses less robust comparative methods, and relies on limited city-specific data. This paper aims to fill this gap by defining rationality, conducting a thorough international comparison, and performing a risk analysis to assess the stability of China's land share.

Methods

The study employs a multi-faceted approach:

  • Definition of Rationality: Rationality is defined as being consistent with international experience and meeting China's socio-economic stability needs. This is further broken down into three criteria:
  • Historical Value Comparison: China's current land share should be similar to that of developed countries at comparable stages of economic and social development.
  • Characteristic Comparison: The evolution trend, spatial distribution, and relationship with urban fundamentals should align with developed countries.
  • Risk Assessment: The current land share should not pose risks to future economic operations.
  • International Comparison Framework: The authors compare China's land share with that of the United States, European countries, and Japan. The comparison considers:
  • Land share at historical stages comparable to China's current development.
  • Time-varying trends of land share.
  • Spatial distribution of land share.
  • Relationship between land share and urban fundamentals (GDP per capita, population size).
  • Risk Analysis: A "stress test" method is used to evaluate economic risks under two hypothetical scenarios:
  • "Price of Future Almost Unchanged" Scenario: Assesses the impact on real estate development project profits if housing prices remain stable.
  • "Future House Prices May Decline" Scenario: Evaluates the risk tolerance if housing prices fall.

Datasets

  • China: Data for land share of housing value, land prices, and housing prices for 105 monitoring cities are sourced from China's urban land price dynamic monitoring system. GDP per capita and urban population data are also used.
  • International Data:
    • Historical land share data for other countries are drawn from "No Price Like Home: Global House Prices, 1870-2012."
    • Land share data for the United States and Japan are from the Lincoln Institute of Land Policy and the Japanese Institute of Land Research, respectively.
  • GDP per capita and urban population data for the United States are from the U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • International Parity: China's land share of housing value is not an outlier; it sits at an intermediate level when compared to developed countries at similar historical development stages. This suggests a degree of convergence in market dynamics.
  • Synchronized Trends: The fluctuations in land share in China, the US, and Japan are strongly correlated with their respective economic cycles, indicating that real estate markets are sensitive to broader economic conditions.
  • Spatial Logic: Land share distribution follows a logical pattern, generally being higher in economically developed and densely populated areas (east coast in China and US, metropolitan areas in Japan) and lower in less developed regions. This reflects the interplay of land scarcity, demand, and economic activity.
  • Economic Fundamentals Matter: A positive correlation exists between land share and urban economic fundamentals like GDP per capita and population size. This reinforces the idea that land value is intrinsically linked to economic vitality and demand.
  • Controllable Risks: Despite concerns, the study's risk analysis suggests that the current land share in most Chinese cities is unlikely to cause widespread economic risks, even under scenarios of stable or declining housing prices.

Key Results

  • China's current land share of housing value is at an intermediate level compared to developed countries' historical values.
  • The trend, spatial distribution, and relationship with urban fundamentals in China are similar to those in developed countries.
  • Under hypothetical scenarios, the land share in most of the 35 large and medium-sized cities analyzed is unlikely to cause economic risks.
  • The study proposes a reasonable range for China's land share of housing value as approximately 31.18% to 57.91%.
  • Cities like Ningbo and Fuzhou were identified as potentially experiencing small losses or needing slight price increases to break even under certain scenarios, suggesting these areas might warrant closer monitoring.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Granularity: While the study uses dynamic monitoring system data, it acknowledges that specific development projects require detailed analysis beyond the scope of this paper.
  • Hypothetical Scenarios: The risk analysis is based on hypothetical scenarios, and real-world outcomes can be influenced by numerous unpredictable factors.
  • Future Work: The authors recommend that land management departments dynamically adjust land supply plans and control land share at a reasonable level to prevent economic risks. They also suggest increasing land supply in "hot" cities with high land shares and improving land utilization efficiency in cities with scarce resources. For cities with excessively low land shares, reducing land supply is advised to prevent resource waste.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhou2019evaluating,
  author = {Xiaoping Zhou and Zhenyang Qin and Chai Duo and Zhao Song},
  title = {{Evaluating the Rationality of Land Share of Housing Value in China’s Urban Housing Market —Based on International Comparison and Risk Analysis}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the 3rd International Seminar on Education Innovation and Economic Management (SEIEM 2018)},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.2991/seiem-18.2019.28},
}
Figure