Abstract
How does one objectively measure the performance of an individual offensive lineman in the NFL? The existing literature proposes various measures that rely on subjective assessments of game film, but has yet to develop an objective methodology to evaluate performance. Using a variety of statistics related to an offensive lineman's performance, we develop a framework to objectively analyze the overall performance of an individual offensive lineman and determine specific linemen who are overvalued or undervalued relative to their salary. We identify eight players across the 2013-2014 and 2014-2015 NFL seasons that are considered to be overvalued or undervalued and corroborate the results with existing metrics that are based on subjective evaluation. To the best of our knowledge, the techniques set forth in this work have not been utilized in previous works to evaluate the performance of NFL players at any position, including offensive linemen.
Introduction
In the NFL, offensive linemen are often the "unsung heroes" of the gridiron. Unlike quarterbacks or wide receivers, they lack traditional box-score statistics like passing yards or touchdowns. Currently, their evaluation is roughly 95% dependent on subjective film review by scouts. While platforms like Pro Football Focus (PFF) provide grades, these are still based on human judgment of a player's "intent" or "technique" rather than hard, realized outcomes. This research aims to bridge this gap by creating an objective, outcome-based methodology to determine if a player's performance justifies their salary.
Methodology
The researchers developed a multi-stage analytical pipeline to isolate individual impact and identify market inefficiencies.
Differential Statistics
To isolate a lineman's contribution, the study compared play outcomes (such as yards per carry or sacks allowed) when the play went "to their side" versus when it went elsewhere. This "not to side" data acts as a control group to account for the talent of the rest of the team. The definition of "to side" varies by position, as shown in Figure 4.
Market Pricing and Clustering
Linear regression was used to determine which variables drive NFL salaries. Interestingly, "differential statistics" showed a stronger correlation with salary than subjective PFF ratings. Instead of comparing players by simple physical traits, k-means clustering grouped 133 players into seven distinct "clusters" based on market-valued traits like experience, Pro Bowl selections, and performance metrics. For each cluster, parametric distributions were fitted to salary data to identify outliers—players whose salaries fell into the extreme tails (top or bottom 5%) of their cluster's distribution.
Datasets
The study utilized a robust combination of sources, including STATS LLC for granular play-by-play data, Pro-Football Reference for "prestige" variables, and PFF for validation. The full range of variables analyzed, from descriptive data to specific rushing and passing statistics, is detailed in Figure 3.
Key Results
The framework identified several players who were statistically mispriced during the 2013-2015 period:
- Undervalued: John Jerry (NYG, 2014) and Mike McGlynn (KC, 2014). The model suggests these players performed at a level typical of much higher-paid peers.
- Overvalued: Scott Wells (STL, 2013 & 2014) and Davin Joseph (TB, 2013).
When compared against subjective PFF rankings, the model's findings were corroborated in 4 out of 5 cases. For example, the "overvalued" players identified by the model also had significantly lower performance ranks than their salary ranks according to PFF.
Discussion and Limitations
The model suggests the NFL labor market is somewhat inefficient, heavily weighting "proxies" for success (like draft round and Pro Bowl nods) which may lag behind actual on-field utility. However, limitations remain, such as the small sample size of two seasons and the lack of defensive context (the quality of opposing defensive linemen). Future research could transition from retrospective evaluation to predictive modeling, helping teams forecast a player's value during free agency.
Summary updated