TL;DR
This paper leverages spatio-temporal big data from Foursquare and official deprivation indices to quantitatively assess the impact of the 2012 London Olympic Games on the regeneration of East London. The findings suggest that while the Games spurred physical regeneration and reduced overall deprivation, they also exacerbated housing affordability issues.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Urban regeneration policies are a common tool for governments to revitalize disinvested areas, promote social mixing, and boost economic vitality. However, historically, evaluating the true impact of these policies has been challenging due to a lack of granular, large-scale datasets. This paper tackles this challenge by investigating the effectiveness of the regeneration policies associated with the 2012 Olympic Games in East London. The authors aim to move beyond anecdotal evidence and provide a data-driven assessment of both the physical and socio-economic changes in the area, addressing whether the ambitious goals of reducing deprivation and improving liveability were met.
Methods
The study employs a multi-faceted approach to evaluate the Olympic regeneration policies:
- Venue Density Analysis: The researchers tracked the growth in the number of Foursquare-registered venues per unit area in the Olympic host boroughs compared to the rest of London. This was done to gauge physical regeneration and the emergence of new businesses and services.
- Venue Composition Analysis: Beyond just density, the paper analyzes the types of new venues appearing in East London. This helps understand the nature of the regeneration – whether it's driven by hospitality, recreation, or other sectors.
- Mobility Features Analysis: Using Foursquare "transitions" (user check-ins between venues), the study measures human mobility patterns. This is used as a proxy for local vitality and how people interact with the urban environment.
- Deprivation Analysis: The core socio-economic assessment relies on comparing the English Indices of Deprivation (IMD) for 2010 (pre-Games) and 2015 (post-Games). This allows for a quantitative measure of changes in various deprivation sub-domains (health, employment, income, etc.) across the host boroughs.
Datasets
- Foursquare Data: A four-year dataset (June 2010 to August 2014) containing user "transitions" (pairs of check-ins between venues) and venue information (geographic coordinates, category, creation time, user count). This is a location-based social network service.
- English Indices of Deprivation (IMD): Official measures of relative deprivation for small areas in England. The study uses the 2010 and 2015 versions to track changes in deprivation levels.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Big Data for Policy Evaluation: The paper demonstrates the power of leveraging large-scale, fine-grained datasets like Foursquare data to dynamically evaluate the impact of urban policies, overcoming historical data limitations.
- Physical Regeneration is Evident: The growth in venue density and the emergence of specific venue categories (like "Outdoors & Recreation," "Arts & Entertainment") indicate tangible physical regeneration in East London post-Olympics.
- Socio-Economic Improvements, But Uneven: While overall deprivation levels decreased in several host boroughs, the "Barriers to Housing and Services" domain worsened, highlighting a critical unintended consequence.
- Mobility Fluctuations: Human mobility, as measured by Foursquare transitions, saw a significant peak during the Olympic period, particularly in Newham, but returned to pre-event levels afterward, suggesting a temporary boost rather than sustained long-term change in daily patterns.
Key Results
- Venue Density: The venue density in Olympic host boroughs grew at a rate higher than the London average, eventually surpassing it by August 2014. Peaks in growth were observed in October 2011 and August 2012. Hackney and Tower Hamlets showed particularly high venue density growth.
- Venue Composition: "Food" was the most common new venue category across London, but "Outdoors & Recreation" and "Arts & Entertainment" were disproportionately higher in host boroughs, especially during key Olympic years.
- Mobility: Host boroughs generally had lower transition flows than London, with a notable spike in August 2012 (during the Games). Newham, the main Olympic site, experienced a significant peak in transition flows during this period.
- Deprivation: Overall IMD deprivation improved in Waltham Forest, Newham, Hackney, and Greenwich between 2010 and 2015. However, Barking and Dagenham, and Tower Hamlets saw relative increases in deprivation. The "Barriers to Housing and Services" domain worsened in five out of six host boroughs.
Limitations and Future Work
- Foursquare Data Bias: The authors acknowledge that Foursquare data does not represent all venues or all users in London, meaning it captures patterns of active users rather than the absolute reality.
- Causality vs. Correlation: While the study shows regeneration coinciding with the Olympic policy, it's difficult to definitively attribute all changes solely to the Olympics, as other factors might be at play.
- Short-Term Focus: The study period ends two years after the Games, and the authors suggest that longer-term follow-up analysis is needed to fully evaluate the lasting success of the regeneration efforts.
- Policy Implications: The findings suggest a need for policymakers to pay closer attention to social issues like housing affordability, which can be negatively impacted by regeneration efforts, and to consider the long-term sustainability of these changes.
Summary updated