Evaluating the culturing performance of two-skinned mud crabs ( Scylla paramamosain ) using intermolt and mature crabs in various eyestalk ablation and gender conditions

Vu H. Le, Ting Huang, Bac Nguyen, Ly H. Tien, Dung Doan, Doan X. DiepIsraeli 2025 · DOI

Abstract

A thorough investigation into the effects of crustacean eyestalk ablation across different genders is crucial for optimizing aquaculture practices. This research, conducted from June to September 2023, assessed how eyestalk removal and gender affected the performance of raising "double-skinned" mud crabs (Scylla paramamosain). Utilizing a completely randomized design, the study explored four ablation conditions and three gender groups. Results indicated that while eyestalk ablation did not significantly alter overall yields, it markedly improved the specific growth rate (SGR), the duration required to reach the double-skinned stage, and the feed conversion ratio (FCR). Right-side eyestalk ablation in mature female crabs emerged as the most effective strategy, balancing accelerated growth with high survival rates.

Introduction

In the premium seafood market, "double-skinned" mud crabs are a highly sought-after delicacy. These crabs are harvested in the brief window just before molting, when a soft, nutrient-rich new shell has formed beneath the old exoskeleton. Because crabs in this stage naturally burrow to protect themselves, they are difficult to harvest in the wild, making controlled aquaculture essential.

The carapace of Scylla paramamosain; monitoring shell condition is vital for identifying the high-value "double-skinned" stage.

To meet commercial demand, farmers employ eyestalk ablation—the surgical removal of one or both eyestalks. This procedure targets the X-organ/sinus gland complex, which produces Molt-Inhibiting Hormone (MIH). By reducing MIH levels, the crab's endocrine system is stimulated to accelerate the molting cycle. This study aimed to standardize protocols by evaluating the impact of ablation symmetry (left vs. right vs. bilateral) and gender on production efficiency.

Experimental Methodology

The research was divided into two primary experiments conducted in Ca Mau Province, Vietnam:

  1. Experiment 1 (Ablation Type): Mature crabs were subjected to four treatments: No ablation (control), Right-side ablation, Left-side ablation, and Bilateral ablation.
  2. Experiment 2 (Gender Factors): Using the most successful method from the first phase (Right-side ablation), researchers compared performance across three gender categories: Males, Females, and Mixed-sex groups.
Ventral view of mud crabs showing the morphological differences between males (a) and females (b) used for gender selection in Experiment 2.

Crabs were stocked at a density of 20 individuals per m² and fed a diet of trash fish at 5% of their body weight. Water quality parameters, including pH, temperature, and nitrogen levels, were strictly monitored to ensure environmental stability throughout the 90-day trial.

Key Insights and Results

The Advantage of Asymmetry

The study revealed a surprising physiological asymmetry: Right-side ablation significantly outperformed Left-side ablation. The Right-side group achieved a Specific Growth Rate (SGR) of 0.65% day⁻¹, compared to just 0.48% in the control group. Furthermore, Right-side ablation reduced the time to reach the double-skinned stage to 32.5 days, nearly a week faster than non-ablated crabs.

The Risks of Bilateral Ablation

While bilateral ablation (removing both eyes) produced the most efficient Feed Conversion Ratio (FCR) of 0.87, it proved detrimental to the animals' health. The survival rate for the bilateral group plummeted to 72.2%, compared to 94.4% for the Right-side group. The extreme hormonal shift caused by total MIH removal appears to create unsustainable physiological stress.

Gender-Based Performance

Gender played a critical role in survival and speed. Females reached the target stage faster than their male counterparts. More importantly, female crabs maintained a high survival rate of 94.4% under ablated conditions, whereas the male group's survival dropped to 66.7%. This suggests that females are naturally more resilient to the endocrine interventions required for double-skinned crab production.

Conclusion and Practical Implications

The findings provide a clear roadmap for aquaculture optimization. For commercial producers of Scylla paramamosain, the most effective strategy is the application of right-side eyestalk ablation in mature female crabs. This protocol maximizes growth rates and feed efficiency while avoiding the high mortality associated with bilateral procedures or male-centric cohorts. Future research should focus on scaling these results to large-pond environments and exploring whether specialized diets can mitigate the lower survival rates observed in male crabs.

Summary updated

Abstract

A thorough investigation into the effects of crustacean eyestalk ablation across different genders is crucial for optimizing aquaculture practices. This research was conducted from June to September 2023, with two separate experiments to assess how eyestalk removal and the gender of mud crabs ( Scylla paramamosain ) affected the performance of raising double-skinned crabs using intermolt and mature crabs. Both experiments utilized a completely randomized design with three replications in rectangular tanks (a bottom area of 0.3 m²). Crabs were divided into four eyestalk ablation groups (no ablation, right ablation, left ablation, and bilateral ablation) in experiment 1, while experiment 2 focused on right eyestalk ablation crabs and categorized them into three gender groups (males, females, and mixed-sex). The animals were stocked at a density of 20 individuals m −2 and were fed trash fish at a rate of 5% of their wet body weight throughout the experiments. The results showed that eyestalk ablation did not significantly affect overall yields. However, it improved the specific growth rate (SGR), the time needed to form double-skinned crabs (duration), and the feed conversion ratio (FCR). The right ablation group showed the most notable improvements. The bilateral ablation group showed improvements in FCR but had the fewest benefits in SGR, duration, and survival rate (SR). Additionally, gender factors had a minor effect on duration, with the shortest time recorded for the female group. Both male and mixed-sex groups showed improvements in FCR but experienced a decline in SR, with a significant reduction in the male group. Based on these findings, it is recommended that right eyestalk ablation in intermolt and mature female mud crabs is the most effective strategy for producing double-skinned crabs under the conditions studied.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{le2025evaluating,
  author = {Vu H. Le and Ting Huang and Bac Nguyen and Ly H. Tien and Dung Doan and Doan X. Diep},
  title = {{Evaluating the culturing performance of two-skinned mud crabs ( <i>Scylla paramamosain</i> ) using intermolt and mature crabs in various eyestalk ablation and gender conditions}},
  booktitle = {Israeli},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.46989/001c.130056},
}
Figure