Evaluating the Comprehensive Benefit of Group-Affiliated New Energy Power Generation Enterprises for Sustainability: Based on a Combined Technique of STBI and TOPSIS

Wenyin Yang, Lin Liu, Xiaobao YuSustainability 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel method for evaluating the comprehensive benefits of new energy power generation enterprises within large groups, addressing the challenge of diverse and complex data sources. By combining the Stochastic Transformation for Blended Information (STBI) and Technique for Order Preference by Similarity to Ideal Solution (TOPSIS), the authors provide a robust framework for ranking these enterprises, offering valuable insights for sustainable development and management.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The rapid growth of the new energy sector in China, driven by government initiatives, has led to the formation of large new energy power generation groups comprising numerous regional enterprises. However, a significant gap exists in evaluating the comprehensive benefits of these group-affiliated enterprises from an internal management perspective. Existing research often focuses on single aspects (economic, environmental) or external viewpoints, failing to account for the complex, multi-source, and multi-form data generated by different management departments within a group. This lack of a comprehensive evaluation framework hinders effective benefit growth and sustainable development for these enterprises.

Methods

The core of this paper is a novel hybrid evaluation model that combines two key techniques:

  • Stochastic Transformation for Blended Information (STBI): This method is designed to handle "blended evaluation information" – data that comes from multiple sources and exists in various forms (real numbers, interval numbers, fuzzy numbers, linguistic terms, ordinal numbers). STBI transforms this diverse data into a uniform format and then uses Monte Carlo simulations to generate a stable ranking by accounting for the probabilistic nature of the original information. This approach aims to preserve the original data's characteristics and avoid information loss.
  • Technique for Order Preference by Similarity to Ideal Solution (TOPSIS): A well-established multi-criteria decision-making (MCDM) method, TOPSIS ranks alternatives based on their distance from both a positive ideal solution (best possible outcome) and a negative ideal solution (worst possible outcome).

The paper integrates these by using STBI to preprocess and standardize the complex, blended evaluation data, and then applying TOPSIS to the standardized data to derive the final rankings. This combined approach allows for the evaluation of enterprises with diverse data types and provides a more objective and comprehensive assessment.

Datasets

The study utilizes empirical data from four regional new energy power generation enterprises affiliated with the Huaneng Renewables Group in China. This data represents the annual operating performance of these enterprises across various indicators. The paper does not introduce a new benchmark dataset but rather applies its methodology to real-world data from existing enterprises.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Internal Management Perspective is Crucial: The paper highlights the importance of evaluating group-affiliated enterprises from the perspective of the parent company's internal management, which is often overlooked in existing literature.
  • Blended Information is the Norm: The reality of evaluating complex organizations like new energy groups involves dealing with diverse data types from various departments, making a method that can handle this "blended information" essential.
  • STBI + TOPSIS Synergy: The combination of STBI and TOPSIS offers a powerful solution for comprehensive evaluation problems where data is complex and multi-modal, preserving original information better than traditional methods.
  • Sustainability and Benefit Growth are Intertwined: The evaluation framework is built on indicators that balance sustainability goals (as outlined in China's "Thirteenth Five-Year Plan") with the practical needs of internal management for benefit growth.
  • Probabilistic Ranking is More Realistic: The STBI-TOPSIS approach yields probabilistic rankings, which are more appropriate for complex evaluations where absolute certainty is difficult to achieve, especially in emerging fields.

Key Results

The study applied the STBI-TOPSIS model to four regional enterprises of the Huaneng Renewables Group. The results indicated a ranking of Inner Mongolia (01) > Yunnan (04) > Liaoning (02) > Shandong (03) in terms of comprehensive benefit. This ranking was found to be consistent with the actual situation and the weightings of various indicators, particularly those related to economic benefit and operation quality. The paper demonstrates that the model can effectively differentiate between enterprises and provide a meaningful basis for management decisions.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the data preprocessing methods used might indirectly impact the evaluation results, suggesting that future research could explore comparisons of different preprocessing techniques. They also propose the development of application software based on their method to facilitate quicker and more efficient comprehensive benefit analysis for new energy generation groups.

Summary updated

Abstract

As an efficient way to deal with the exhaustion of traditional fossil fuels, new energy power generation has obtained much attention from the Chinese Government. In this context, more and more new energy power generation groups that consist of large numbers of regional enterprises have been founded and developed rapidly. However, researches related to comprehensive benefit evaluation of group-affiliated new energy power generation enterprises is still blank in China, which will hinder the benefit growth and sustainable development of such enterprises. A novel hybrid evaluation indicator system is proposed from both perspectives of sustainability and the internal management within the groups. Considering the preference information given on each of the indicators is featured by multi-source and multi-form, an evaluation framework to integrate the blended and complex evaluation information is designed. In addition, different from previous studies, this paper employs a combined technique of Stochastic Transformation for Blended Information (STBI) method and the Technique for Order Preference by Similar to Ideal Solution (TOPSIS) to simulate the evaluation process and rank the comprehensive benefit of evaluation objects. It can efficiently handle the comprehensive evaluation problems with blended and complex evaluation information and preserve the initial evaluation information to the utmost simultaneously. Finally, this paper applied the evaluation model to empirical research and the results show that the model meets the actual situation of the new energy power generation group and can provide a certain reference value.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yang2017evaluating,
  author = {Wenyin Yang and Lin Liu and Xiaobao Yu},
  title = {{Evaluating the Comprehensive Benefit of Group-Affiliated New Energy Power Generation Enterprises for Sustainability: Based on a Combined Technique of STBI and TOPSIS}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3390/su10010024},
}
Figure