Evaluating longitudinal relationships between parental monitoring and substance use in a multi-year, intensive longitudinal study of 670 adolescent twins

Jordan D. Alexander, Samantha M. Freis, Stephanie Zellers, Robin P. Corley, Amy Ledbetter, Rachel K. Schneider, Chanda Phelan, Hariharan Subramonyam, Maia J. Frieser, Gianna Rea‐Sandin, Michelle E. Stocker, Helen Vernier, Ming Jiang, Yan Luo, Qi Zhao, Sally Ann Rhea, John K. Hewitt, Mónica Luciana, Matt McGue, Sylia Wilson, Paul Resnick, Naomi P. Friedman, Scott VriezeFrontiers in Psychiatry 2023 · DOI

Abstract

Overall, we found developmental changes in each phenotype, baseline correlations between substance use and parental monitoring, co-occurring changes and mutual genetic influences for time at home and cannabis use, and substantial genetic influences on many substance use and parental monitoring phenotypes. However, our geospatial variables were mostly unrelated to parental monitoring, suggesting they poorly measured this construct. Furthermore, though we did not detect evidence of genetic confounding, changes in parental monitoring and substance use were not significantly correlated, suggesting that, at least in community samples of mid-to-late adolescents, the two may not be causally related.

Introduction

Parental monitoring—defined as parents' knowledge of their children's whereabouts and activities—is a cornerstone of adolescent behavioral interventions. The prevailing assumption is that increasing monitoring directly reduces substance use. However, much of the evidence supporting this link comes from cross-sectional or sparse longitudinal studies that cannot easily disentangle directionality from genetic confounding. This study, published in Frontiers in Psychiatry, utilizes an intensive longitudinal twin design to investigate whether the relationship between monitoring and substance use is truly causal or driven by shared underlying factors.

Methods

The researchers utilized the CoTwins sample, comprising 670 twins (109 MZ and 221 DZ pairs) from the University of Colorado and the University of Minnesota. Participants were tracked over two years (ages 14–18) using a smartphone app that collected weekly surveys on alcohol and cannabis use, bi-monthly surveys on perceived parental monitoring, and passive GPS sensing to calculate "time at home" (midnight–5 AM) and "time at school" (8 AM–3 PM).

To analyze this data, the team employed Latent Growth Curve Models to estimate baseline levels (intercepts) and rates of change (slopes). These parameters were then decomposed using ACE modeling—Additive genetic (A), Shared environmental (C), and Non-shared environmental (E) components—to understand the sources of variance and correlation.

The ACE decomposed multivariate latent growth model used to estimate random effects and their genetic/environmental contributions.

Results

The study revealed distinct developmental trajectories for substance use, monitoring, and geospatial behavior. As adolescents aged from 14 to 20, alcohol and cannabis use increased, while parental monitoring and time spent at home or school decreased.

Predicted trajectories showing increases in substance use (A) alongside decreases in parental monitoring (B) and time spent at home/school (C) across adolescence.

The Longitudinal Disconnect

While parental monitoring and substance use were negatively correlated at age 14 ($r = -0.24$ to $-0.29$), the study found no significant correlation between the change in monitoring and the change in substance use ($r = -0.14$ to $0.10$). This suggests that while high-monitoring households may have lower baseline use, increasing monitoring over time does not necessarily lead to a corresponding decrease in substance use during mid-to-late adolescence.

Genetic and Environmental Influences

  • Heritability: Parental monitoring showed substantial heritability ($h^2 = 0.30$ to $0.67$), suggesting that a child's genetically influenced traits may evoke specific levels of monitoring from parents.
  • Shared Environment: The baseline link between alcohol use and monitoring was largely explained by shared environmental factors ($r_c = -0.61$), such as neighborhood context.
  • Cannabis and GPS: A strong correlation was found between increased cannabis use and decreased time spent at home at night ($r = -0.53$ to $-0.90$). Biometric analysis indicated this relationship was almost entirely genetically mediated ($r_g = -1.00$).

Discussion

The findings challenge the idea that parental monitoring is a direct "lever" for reducing substance use in mid-adolescence. The lack of correlation between slopes suggests that the baseline association may be due to stable characteristics of the family or child rather than a dynamic causal process. Furthermore, passive GPS data, while highly predictive of cannabis use, did not correlate with self-reported monitoring, indicating that "sneaking out" and "parental knowledge" are distinct constructs.

Future research should focus on identifying the "active ingredients" in parent training programs. If monitoring itself is not the primary driver of change, interventions might instead work by strengthening the parent-child emotional bond or addressing shared environmental risks.

Summary updated

Abstract

Overall, we found developmental changes in each phenotype, baseline correlations between substance use and parental monitoring, co-occurring changes and mutual genetic influences for time at home and cannabis use, and substantial genetic influences on many substance use and parental monitoring phenotypes. However, our geospatial variables were mostly unrelated to parental monitoring, suggesting they poorly measured this construct. Furthermore, though we did not detect evidence of genetic confounding, changes in parental monitoring and substance use were not significantly correlated, suggesting that, at least in community samples of mid-to-late adolescents, the two may not be causally related.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{alexander2023evaluating,
  author = {Jordan D. Alexander and Samantha M. Freis and Stephanie Zellers and Robin P. Corley and Amy Ledbetter and Rachel K. Schneider and Chanda Phelan and Hariharan Subramonyam and Maia J. Frieser and Gianna Rea‐Sandin and Michelle E. Stocker and Helen Vernier and Ming Jiang and Yan Luo and Qi Zhao and Sally Ann Rhea and John K. Hewitt and Mónica Luciana and Matt McGue and Sylia Wilson and Paul Resnick and Naomi P. Friedman and Scott Vrieze},
  title = {{Evaluating longitudinal relationships between parental monitoring and substance use in a multi-year, intensive longitudinal study of 670 adolescent twins}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychiatry},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyt.2023.1149079},
}
Figure