Evaluating Large-Eddy Simulations of Boundary-Layer Cloud Response to Climate Change using MAGIC Observations

Christopher S. Bretherton2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper validates the use of sophisticated Large-Eddy Simulations (LES) to accurately represent marine boundary layer clouds, which are crucial for global climate. By comparing LES results with ship-based observations from the MAGIC campaign, the study demonstrates that LES can skillfully reproduce cloud variations, bolstering confidence in their use for predicting future climate change impacts on these critical cloud systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurately simulating marine boundary layer clouds, particularly stratocumulus decks off the coast of California, is a major challenge for climate models. These clouds play a vital role in reflecting solar radiation back into space, thus cooling the planet. However, their formation and behavior are driven by small-scale turbulent air motions that are too fine to be resolved by the coarse grids of traditional climate models. This limitation hinders our ability to reliably predict how these clouds will respond to a warming climate, which is projected to lead to their thinning and breakup, amplifying global warming. This research aims to address this by testing the fidelity of advanced LES models, which can resolve these turbulent processes, against real-world observations.

Methods

The core of this study involves using a sophisticated Large-Eddy Simulation (LES) model to simulate the turbulent air motions responsible for forming marine boundary layer clouds. A key methodological innovation is configuring the LES to move with the research vessel, allowing for a direct comparison of simulated cloud properties with observations taken along the ship's transects. This "ship-following" approach, combined with a 6.4x6.4 km simulation domain with 50m horizontal and 5m vertical resolution, allows the model to capture the fine-scale turbulence. Large-scale atmospheric flow effects were incorporated using a weather forecast model. The study also explored mesoscale organization by running LES on a larger 100 km domain.

Datasets

The primary dataset used for evaluation is from the Marine ARM GPCI Investigation of Clouds (MAGIC) campaign. This campaign involved a container ship instrumented with a suite of sensors (surface meteorological, aerosol, radiation, cloud radar, ceilometer, radiosondes) that made periodic cruises between Los Angeles, CA, and Honolulu, HI, between October 2011 and September 2012. Data from 20 four-to-six-day cruises in each direction were utilized.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • LES as a Reliable Tool: The study provides strong evidence that LES, when configured appropriately, can accurately reproduce the observed variations in marine boundary layer cloud properties. This builds confidence in using LES for future climate projections.
  • Mesoscale Organization is Ubiquitous: The research highlights that mesoscale organization (patches of thicker and thinner clouds) is a common feature of these cloud systems, not just an anomaly.
  • Self-Aggregation Driven by Feedback Loops: The paper suggests that this mesoscale organization arises spontaneously from instabilities within the boundary layer, driven by positive feedbacks between cloud-induced circulations, radiative cooling, and moistening/drying processes.
  • Cloud-Radiation Interaction is Key: The findings emphasize the critical role of cloud-top radiative cooling in driving and sustaining mesoscale cellular convection. Without this feedback, the organization is significantly weakened.
  • Aerosol Sensitivity May Be Less Pronounced: Contrary to some previous LES studies, this work suggests that simulated cloud properties might not be overly sensitive to aerosol variations in this specific region.

Key Results

  • The LES model demonstrated remarkable skill in predicting cloudiness variations observed by the MAGIC ship across various weather regimes and seasons.
  • The LES reproduced observed transitions from stratocumulus to cumulus cloud types and matched the evolution of boundary layer structure, cloud fraction, and liquid water path.
  • Daily mean quantities like liquid water path and cloud fraction showed expected correlations with inversion strength.
  • A slight low bias in LES near-surface air temperature (-0.6 K) led to a high bias in sensible heat flux (5.6 W m⁻²).
  • LES simulations on a 100 km domain showed that mesoscale cells form spontaneously, enhanced by radiative cooling at cloud tops.
  • Simulations of closed-cell convection showed development into a 25:1 aspect ratio, consistent with satellite observations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Reconciling Aerosol Sensitivity: The paper notes a discrepancy with other LES studies regarding aerosol sensitivity. A key question for future work is to reconcile these differing viewpoints, possibly by incorporating ARM and other ground-based observations.
  • Improving Climate Model Parameterizations: The study highlights that LES excels at replicating the vertical structure of marine boundary layers and clouds, outperforming current climate model parameterizations. A significant future direction is to leverage this LES skill to develop improved parameterizations for climate models.
  • Further Study on Mesoscale Organization: While the paper elucidates the mechanisms behind mesoscale organization, further investigation into how this organization impacts horizontal-mean cloud properties and its role in climate change is warranted.

Summary updated

Abstract

Over the cool waters off California, a persistent and extensive deck of low-lying clouds forms atop a shallow, turbulent layer of moist air extending 500-2000 meters above the ocean, above which the air is much warmer and drier. Its west edge varies with weather and season and is typically half way to Hawaii. This cloud deck and similar cloud decks elsewhere reflect sunlight back to space, cooling the underlying ocean and indeed the entire planet. They must be accurately represented by a climate model to correctly simulate our current climate or future global warming. Most climate models suggest these cloud decks will thin and break up in a warmer CO2-enriched climate, so extra sunlight would reach the ocean surface and amplify warming worldwide. But these models have difficulty accurately simulating the cloud thickness and extent because the turbulent cloud-forming air currents are much too small to be simulated by their coarse computational grid. In 2012-2013, the DOE Atmospheric Radiation Measurement MAGIC program instrumented a container ship transiting between California and Hawaii to observe clouds and rain, small particles (aerosols), and weather conditions. Data were obtained from 20 4-6 day cruises in each direction. This study tested whether a sophisticated ‘large-eddy simulation’ (LES) of the turbulent air motions that create the clouds in this region accurately predicts the variations in cloud properties seen across the different cruises. If so, that model is more believable for predicting cloud changes in this region in a future warmer climate. Our LES used a numerical mesh over a 6.4x6.4 km region with 50 m horizontal and 5 m vertical grid spacing to simulate the cloud-forming eddies and the sharp overlying transition between moist and dry air. To better compare with MAGIC observations, we configured our model to simulate a region that moved along with the ship. We used a weather forecast model to specify effects of the large-scale air flow. We compared our results with balloon ascents, a radar and other instruments pointed upward at the clouds, measurements of downward sunlight and infrared radiation, aerosols, and weather variables for all suitable cruise periods. Our LES was remarkably skillful in predicting the cloudiness variations measured by the ship. MAGIC also sampled mesoscale cells, regions of cloud thickening and thinning over distances of 10-50 km. An LES run over a larger region 100 km on a side shows these cells form spontaneously, enhanced by strong radiative heat loss at the cloud tops.
BibTeX
@misc{bretherton2019evaluating,
  author = {Christopher S. Bretherton},
  title = {{Evaluating Large-Eddy Simulations of Boundary-Layer Cloud Response to Climate Change using MAGIC Observations}},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.2172/1492729},
}

Loading related content...

Figure