TL;DR
This paper introduces a novel approach to evaluating the visual aesthetic impact of cultural landscape remediation designs using Virtual Reality (VR) technology. By combining VR-based visual analysis with water quality monitoring, the study demonstrates that their remediation strategy effectively enhances visual appeal and improves the ecological health of heritage sites in China's Tujia settlement areas.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Rapid economic development in China has led to the degradation of cultural heritage resources. While there's a growing recognition of the need for cultural landscape conservation, existing research often lacks specific focus on individual sites, especially in minority regions. Furthermore, traditional evaluation methods for remediation designs are often qualitative and lack robust quantitative data. This paper addresses the challenge of objectively assessing the visual and ecological effectiveness of cultural landscape remediation designs, particularly in the context of the Tujia ethnic minority in southwest China, where rapid development has impacted traditional heritage.
Methods
The study employs a multi-faceted approach:
- Remediation Design: A "Linjun Culture" activation and eco-landscape remediation pattern was developed, focusing on restoring the unique functions of "worship," "lighthouse," and "cohesion" associated with the Tujia heritage. This involved architectural restoration, vegetation planning, and the integration of digital technologies.
- VR Technology for Visual Aesthetic Evaluation: Virtual Reality (VR) technology was utilized to quantitatively assess the visual aesthetic effect of the restored cultural landscape. This involved using a Tobii X2-30 virtual eye tracker and specialized software to record participants' eye movements (fixation counts and saccade counts) while they viewed simulated environments of the cultural sites before and after remediation. This method aims to provide a more objective measure of visual engagement and fatigue reduction compared to traditional surveys.
- Water Environment Quality Comparison: To complement the visual assessment, water quality data from the study area before and after remediation was collected and analyzed. This involved comparing pollutant concentrations (DO, NH3-N, TN, CODMn, BOD5, F, TP, CODcr) against national standards to evaluate the ecological impact of the remediation efforts.
Datasets
The study utilized the following data sources:
- Remote Sensing Image Data: GF-2 satellite imagery (2m resolution) was used for geographic alignment, geometric correction, radiation correction, and image fusion to obtain data on the natural environment of the cultural landscape area.
- Social and Environmental Data: Data on water, soil, gas, and solid waste in the cultural landscape area were obtained from the National Bureau of Statistics (NBS). Pollution limits were based on national evaluation standards.
- Field Survey Data: Samples were collected through field surveys and indoor experiments to supplement NBS data.
- Water Pollutant Data: Environmental Quality Reports (2016-2019) from the local Environmental Protection Bureau were used to assess water quality changes.
Key Insights and Ideas
- VR as an Objective Evaluator: VR technology offers a powerful, objective tool for evaluating visual aesthetics in landscape design, moving beyond subjective qualitative assessments. The eye-tracking data provides quantifiable metrics for user engagement and visual fatigue.
- "Activation" Theory for Heritage: The concept of "activating" cultural heritage by connecting it to collective memory and modern needs (like tourism and digital platforms) is crucial for its preservation and relevance.
- Synergy of Visual and Ecological Assessment: Combining visual aesthetic evaluation with ecological monitoring provides a holistic understanding of remediation project success, demonstrating that improved aesthetics can go hand-in-hand with environmental health.
- Tujia Culture as a Foundation: Leveraging the unique cultural identity and collective memory of the Tujia people is key to developing effective and resonant remediation strategies for their heritage sites.
Key Results
- Vegetation Cover Increase: The study reported an increase in vegetation cover in the restored relics area from 46.57% in 2016 to 65.44% in 2019.
- Enhanced Visual Engagement: After remediation, participants' fixation counts and average saccade counts increased by 61.19% and 59.23%, respectively. This indicates increased visual interest and engagement with the restored landscape.
- Reduced Visual Fatigue: The VR analysis suggested that the restored cultural landscape reduced visual fatigue and provided a better visual aesthetic experience.
- Improved Water Quality: The water quality analysis showed significant reductions in pollutant concentrations (DO, NH3-N, and TN) in the relic areas after remediation, indicating improved ecological quality.
Limitations and Future Work
- Sample Size: The authors acknowledge that the experimental procedure may have affected data accuracy due to a small sample size of 16 subjects. They suggest increasing the number of participants in future work to improve evaluation accuracy.
- Heterogeneity of Locations: The research team plans to extend their method to study areas with different location characteristics to explore heterogeneity and develop a more comprehensive evaluation system.
- Further Integration: Future work will involve forming cultural heritage protection associations and collaborating with local departments to provide image data, subjects, and evaluation tools for broader application. The potential for inviting "net celebrities" for live-streaming promotions to enhance tourism is also mentioned.
Summary updated